New Yorkers Will Vote on Community Board Term Limits This November

Under the Charter Revision Commission's proposal, community board members would lose their spots after four consecutive two-year terms -- but could be reappointed after a two-year hiatus.

Community boards tend to be bastions of parking preservation. Photo: David Meyer
Community boards tend to be bastions of parking preservation. Photo: David Meyer

If all goes as planned, New Yorkers will get a chance in November to vote on community board reforms, including theoretical term limits for board members.

Under the proposal, approved yesterday by the mayor’s Charter Revision Commission, community board members would be limited four two-year terms in a row. However, council members and borough presidents would be able to reappoint former members after a two-year hiatus.

The commission voted yesterday in favor of that initiative and two others, versions of which will be put on the ballot for the November 6 general election [PDF].

Community board members have served unlimited terms since the boards were created in 1963. Borough presidents and council members keep reappointing the same people over and over.

The lack of turnover means boards are often out of touch with ever-changing communities. Even in districts with low car ownership, board members will often fight tooth and nail to preserve parking at the expense of projects with widespread community benefits.

The process of choosing board members, meanwhile, varies borough by borough, and is often shrouded in secrecy.

In Brooklyn this year, for example, safe streets advocate Hilda Cohen lost her spot on Community Board 2 on the grounds that “other devoted community residents be given an opportunity to make their contributions.” But Cohen had served just three years on the board, while Council Member Laurie Cumbo reappointed multiple people who had served for longer.

The community board proposal — of which only a portion may end up on the ballot — also includes transparency measures, which would be the same for all boroughs. Borough presidents would be required to issue annual reports identifying the number of open board spots, “information about current board members,” recruitment methods, and “evaluation criteria” for selecting members.

A separate ballot item would create a “Civic Engagement Commission” tasked with providing urban planning support and other resources to community boards.

“Throughout our public engagement process, we heard strong interest in making community boards more reflective of communities they represent, and more effective in representing those communities,” commission executive director Matt Gewolb said before yesterday’s vote.

  • be careful not to throw away the baby with the bath water . It takes years to learn land use and transportation or business licenses. It would be simpler to fix the real problem : #mayor de blasio’s lack of balls and his fixation on free parking

  • Robert Perris

    Can you quantify the statement, “Borough presidents and council members keep reappointing the same people over and over.”? At Brooklyn Community Board 2 (CB2), approximately one-third of the members have been appointed since Eric L. Adams was elected borough president a little over four years ago.

    And can you establish the causality in the statement, “The lack of turnover means boards are often out of touch with ever-changing communities.”?

    One statement that I can confirm is that giving others the opportunity to serve seems to be the only explanation ever provided to community board members who are not reappointed. A few years ago, the elected secretary of CB2 was removed with that boilerplate statement and he had only been a member for a year, not to mention that he was doing a job that nobody else wanted.

    There are 59 community boards. I find the generalizing about them on Streetsblog, mostly by commenters but not exclusively so, intellectually stunted.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

City Council Reso Calls for Community Board Term Limits and Transparency

|
A resolution brewing in the City Council recommends major reform for community boards. Introduced by freshman City Council Member Ben Kallos, the reso calls for board members to serve a maximum of five consecutive two-year terms, and for unspecified term limits for board and committee chairs. It also recommends a transparent appointment process and highly publicized, […]