Vision Zero or Zero Vision? Here It Is, the Craziest Blocked Bike Lane Picture — Ever [Updated]

The photo speaks for itself — and speaks about a DOT employee who should probably be reassigned.

Sort of speaks for itself, doesn't it? Photo: Scott Knobler.
Sort of speaks for itself, doesn't it? Photo: Scott Knobler.

Streetsblog has covered taxis in bike lanes. It has covered cops in bike lanes. It has covered drivers doing a lot of crazy stuff.

But the picture above takes away the breath of even the most-jaded activists.

Yes, this is a Vision Zero van parked in a bike lane.

The photo was taken by new Streetsblog hero Scott Knobler on Saturday in the Rockaways. There’s really not much more you can say about it: It’s a picture of a van promoting Mayor de Blasio’s goal of protecting cyclists and pedestrians … by putting cyclists at risk by making them maneuver into the car lane or putting pedestrians at risk by forcing cyclists onto the sidewalk.

The photo speaks for itself — and speaks about a city Department of Transportation employee who should probably be reassigned. But I asked Knobler to provide some details because, you never know, maybe there were extenuating circumstances to exonerate the van driver.

Um, no.

“I was mocked and laughed at when I questioned why they were parking there,” Knobler, who posts on Reddit as KingNeptuna, told Streetsblog, repeating a sentiment cyclists know rather well.

In fact, he added, “the people from the van taunted me while the police sat there and watched. … I continued down the bike path and almost got hit head on by a beach cop on a moped…and get this, he yelled at ME! Mopeds do not belong in the bike lane. Law enforcement mopeds in the bike lane. … This should get that guy suspended at best.”

Yeah, well, sure, but one thing at a time. I reached out to the DOT and the NYPD’s 100th Precinct to see if the van driver was fired or at least ticketed, and I’ll update the story if I hear back.

Update: Here’s the statement from DOT…

While this van was at the location for the unloading of equipment and materials provided by Vision Zero safety street teams, it should not have been there. We will be mindful of vehicle placement at such events and the appropriate unit addressed this matter with the driver.

  • Camera_Shy

    Bike lanes need to be grade-separated from the car/parking lanes. This is hilarious!!!

  • qrt145

    Maybe the NYC Department of Health will start giving away Big Gulps branded with a “Sugar Zero” campaign next…

  • Danny

    Do you mean grade-separated like the sidewalk level in the above photo – on which there’s an NYPD van parked? Properly designed streets are part of the equation of Vision Zero, but driver etiquette is another part.

  • Daphna

    I would think those DOT employees in the van would at least be apologetic about it and explain the reason why they had to block the bike lane (that their own agency designed and installed, based on studies done by their own agency, and in response to the safety need for it that their own agency determined existed).

  • DoctorMemory

    At the current rate that we’re going, I think we can pretty much guarantee that by 2020 at the absolute latest, the NYPD will be handing out $225 “Distracted Walking” tickets to pedestrians for wearing headphones while crossing the street, and touting it as a “Vision Zero” initiative.

  • Jim Burke

    Before the Shore Front Parkway was resurfaced -it was a real protected bike lane with very little incursions with a decorated Jersey barrier. I could bring my 75 year old mom and she could ride the entire length safely. Now she will not because it’s often blocked by park department vehicles, ice cream trucks, beach goers, idling police cars and ambulances. It’s really a shame she has no place to ride because my mom will not ride in traffic so can’t pass these vehicles and the boardwalk has so many places that force you to walk your bicycle – she can’t physically do that but she can ride her bike but only if she feels safe to do so and it’s not. . https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/61f90794b38d41b073ad992be80a40cdea7eb87c752b59cf7ee46f1561b05af4.jpg d

  • Scott Knobler

    Nice work Gersh! Thank you

  • djx

    Tickets? They’ve already gone straight to beatings. For the jaywalkers safety. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hI93p4S2sAs

  • relevantjeff

    Either that or beating cyclists – and then ticketing them. Bikers are the last group of people left that it’s okay to hate.

  • If only the tickets were that lenient. Montclair, CA charges over $500 for that privilege on the third and subsequent offense.

  • Camera_Shy

    Agree, but at least the van parked at sidewalk level is not parked IN the sidewalk area. From that respect I’d say he (NYPD van) is being courteous. Whether the other two vehicles would be so courteous if the bike lane were elevated to the sidewalk level in this photo remains to be seen.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

What Planet Is DOT Living On?

|
Last week, Henry Melcher at the Architect’s Newspaper ran a thoughtful piece about the state of NYC DOT’s bike program that got buried almost immediately by comments from Bill Bratton and Mayor de Blasio about the Times Square plazas. Melcher asked why DOT so often passes up the chance to add bike lanes in its […]

Good News: New York City Cyclists Have All But Achieved Vision Zero

|
Yesterday the 104th Precinct, in Queens, tweeted a photo of officers giving a ticket to a cyclist. The precinct deleted the tweet when it triggered blowback from street safety advocates, but you can see it at the end of this post. “Bicyclists are no exception to Vision Zero,” it read. “Ride safe!” If NYPD’s goal is encouraging cyclists […]

Michael DenDekker: Slowing NYC Drivers Is a Pointless Waste

|
Assembly Member Michael DenDekker, the Queens rep who once proposed legislation to register cyclists and monitor them with bike lane cameras, says efforts to slow city drivers under Vision Zero are pointless. DenDekker wants an audit of Vision Zero spending, which he reportedly believes is wasted unless it’s going toward traffic signals to eliminate motorist-pedestrian conflicts […]