Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
John Flanagan

Marty Golden’s Word on Speed Cams Has Been Good for Nothing

State Senator Marty Golden

So much for Marty Golden using his pull to get a vote on the speed camera bill in the State Senate.

With less than a week until the city's 140 speed cameras go dark, there's been no movement from Senate Majority Leader John Flanagan to convene a special session and vote on the Every School Speed Camera Act, which would extend the program until 2022 and expand it to 290 school zones.

Flanagan himself didn't respond yesterday after Governor Cuomo and members of Families for Safe Streets called for a vote on the bill in the Senate. That fell to Senate GOP spokesperson Candice Giove, who told reporters a few howlers about noble Senate Republicans crusading for safe streets, buffeted by the cynical campaign of advocates, professional engineers, trauma doctors, and victims' families who've lost everything to dangerous drivers.

It wasn't a coherent argument. Giove told Ken Lovett and Khadija Hussain at the Daily News that "the city’s own report shows that most pedestrian deaths and injuries occur where speed cameras are not permitted by law," which sounds like... an excellent case for more of the speed cameras that have markedly reduced speeding, traffic injuries, and fatalities where they've been installed.

But debating Giove is beside the point. It's Flanagan's conference, and Flanagan has little use for things like data-based policy or logical consistency. He just needs to satisfy the Senate GOP's core constituencies while preventing politically lethal fallout for any of his vulnerable caucus members. Losing any seat in November could flip the Senate to Democratic control.

For the speed camera bill, Flanagan's constituency isn't the millions of New Yorkers who are less likely to get injured or killed when speeding is less prevalent. Only three of NYC's 26 state senators caucus with Republicans.

The constituency Flanagan wants to protect is the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, the largest union representing NYPD officers. The PBA ostensibly opposes speed cameras because they threaten the jobs of police officers, but trends in NYPD's headcount since the debut of the cameras don't support that explanation. More plausibly, PBA members resent getting $50 camera-issued fines for speeding at least 11 mph above the limit in school zones.

Since the beginning of 2015, the PBA has contributed $68,500 to the Senate Republican Campaign Committee, $19,200 to Golden, and $5,000 to Flanagan. A disproportionate share of PBA members also live in the Senate GOP strongholds of Staten Island and Nassau and Suffolk counties, which include Flanagan's own district.

The fact that the speed camera bill is still at an impasse may seem baffling, since Golden and two other Senate Republicans now say they support it. Unless, of course, Flanagan is trying to keep the PBA happy while shielding Golden from the anger of constituents who want to keep speeding in check. In which case, the hold-up makes perfect sense.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Ugly Truth: Feds’ Canal Street Raid Pushed Aside NYPD, Safety and Free Speech

President Trump's heavily armed and masked immigration troops are turning American cities into battlegrounds — and eliminating accountability and free speech in the public realm.

October 27, 2025

Bikelashers Beware! Court Street Redesign Has Turned Chaos to Safety

Court Street's protected bike lane already shows a lot of promise. But that doesn't stop the hate.

October 27, 2025

Adams Administration Has Made It Nearly Impossible To Build Safe E-Bike Charging Stations

It's impossible to build an e-bike charging cabinet in NYC, despite city initiatives meant to boost the industry.

October 27, 2025

That’s Rich! DoorDash Supports E-Bike Speed Limit

DoorDash supports a 15-mile-per-hour speed limit, but that's easy for them to say, given that under-pressure workers will be the ones getting tickets.

October 27, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Everybody to the Limit Edition

Mayoral frontrunner Zohran Mamdani wants to keep the 15-mph Citi Bike e-bike speed limit. Plus more news.

October 27, 2025

Friday Video: Amtrak Is Way More Successful Than You Think

Why do so many people still treat Amtrak as a failure — and what would it take to deliver the rail investment that American riders deserve?

October 24, 2025
See all posts