Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Detroit

Man Walks 21 Miles to Commute Each Day Because of Detroit’s Awful Transit

A piece in the Detroit Free Press about 56-year-old factory worker James Robertson and his 21-mile round-trip walking commute to the Detroit suburbs is going viral this week. It is both an amazing story of individual perseverance and a scathing indictment of a failing transportation system.

Robertson's total commute is actually a 46-mile round-trip, split between different buses and a marathon walk. He has been taking this route to reach his job in Rochester Hills from his home in Detroit since his Honda Accord died 10 years ago, he told the Detroit Free Press. Baldwin can't afford a new car on the wages from his $10-an-hour job.

Despite this formidable obstacle, Robertson has never missed a day of work. "I can't imagine not working," he told the paper.

Readers from around the country who were inspired by Robertson's story have raised $72,000 for him (at the time we published), more than enough to get a car. But a crowdfunded car can't help everyone who's in a similar situation in Detroit.

CeCe Grant, executive director of Americans for Transit, says Robertson's situation is "partially by cruel design." Detroit's suburban bus system, SMART, allows municipalities to "opt-out." That "has always sported a sharp cultural edge, because it nudges up against the notion that some communities don't want 'those people,' be they Detroiters or blacks or bus riders, coming through their locales," she said. "Because Rochester Hills doesn't participate in SMART, Robertson must walk the last seven miles of his journey to work -- after taking a SMART bus as far as it can reach into Oakland County."

Detroit is in the bottom tier of major American metros when it comes to job accessibility via transit, according to the University of Minnesota's Access Across America study, rating below sprawling Sunbelt cities like Atlanta and Tampa.

That could change with the passage of legislation to fund a new regional transit agency for Detroit, which will be on the ballot later this year. But the long campaign for a stable regional transit system will have to overcome some unfortunate timing. Writing for U.S. News and World Report, The Century Foundation's Jacob Anbinder notes that Governor Rick Snyder will appeal to voters in May to raise $1.2 billion in taxes for the state's infrastructure -- mostly roads. Will metro Detroit residents have the appetite for another transportation tax increase when they vote on Detroit's RTA in November?

They'll have to, or else other people like Robertson will remain cut off from jobs by a car-centric transportation system.

"Even if my situation changes, I'll never forget, there are so many other people who are in my situation," Robertson told the Detroit Free Press.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Death of a Legend: Donald Shoup, Parking Reformer

The OG of understanding how "free parking" isn't free has died.

February 8, 2025

Report: Efforts to Speed Up Bus Speeds Have Stalled … Like Bus Speeds

City buses move slower than ever after Mayor Adams reneged on his commitment to build more bus lanes, according to a new analysis.

February 7, 2025

Paradigm Shift: MTA Boss Says State Should Pony Up More For Capital Plans

"Every time the MTA capital program comes up, we treat it like, 'Oh my god, they need a bailout,'" the MTA CEO said, pointing out the absurdity.

February 7, 2025

Who is Trump’s FTA Pick Marc Molinaro — And Will He Kill Congestion Pricing?

If confirmed, Trump FTA pick Marc Molinaro can do a lot to gum up funding for mass transit across the country. Here's a look at his record.

February 7, 2025
See all posts