Got a Parking Problem? David Greenfield’s Purported Solution Won’t Fix It

Six months ago, when Council Member David Greenfield got the chair of the land use committee, it looked like a bad sign for parking reform in New York City. Can the city eliminate costly parking minimums if the land use committee is led by an elected whose approach to every parking problem seems to be “add more”?

Greenfield’s recent response to parking issues in his district adds more cause for concern: He has joined Brooklyn Community Board 12 in pushing a developer to add as much new parking as possible to a project on Coney Island Avenue in Midwood.

Council Member David Greenfield wants more parking. Photo: NYC Council

Developer Baruch Singer is proposing a nine-story building containing mostly retail and medical offices at 1504 Coney Island Avenue, by the corner of Avenue L [PDF]. New York’s zoning code mandates 346 parking spaces for the project. Singer is planning to build an automated parking facility to squeeze as many cars as possible into an underground garage [PDF], but that still can’t fit all the required spaces.

Building to the parking mandate would require a deck at least three levels deep, and that’s not going to happen. “It is simply not possible to dig another level,” said Howard Goldman of real estate law firm Goldman Harris, representing Singer at the Board of Standards and Appeals last Tuesday. “The second level is right at the water table, so any further excavation will be into the water.”

So the developer is looking to build 74 fewer parking spaces than required. The developer says 272 spaces would still be more than enough to accommodate the peak-hour demand from the project, which it calculated at 198 spaces.

That’s not enough for Greenfield and CB 12, which see Singer’s project as the solution to parking dysfunction near the popular Pomegranate grocery store across the street. During busy shopping hours, Pomegranate’s 30-space surface lot overflows as shoppers park at on-street meters and delivery drivers double-park along Coney Island Avenue. Greenfield and CB 12 want to maximize the amount of parking at the new development. They don’t seem to be aware that adding more parking will simply induce more traffic and won’t solve the problems they want to address.

The curbside problems will persist as long as curbside parking remains underpriced, so I asked if CB 12 has ever approached DOT about adjusting parking rules. By altering meter rates and delivery hours, curbside spaces could turn over more frequently, double-parking could be reduced, and more loading zones would be freed up. “I’m not aware of any requests made to change the meter regulations,” CB 12 district manager Barry Spitzer said.

What about Greenfield?

“The Councilman has spent a lot of time working with the NYPD, DOT, Pomegranate and neighbors to resolve the parking challenges at that intersection,” Greenfield chief of staff Jane Carey said, without offering specifics. “That is one of the reasons he believes any new development at this intersection must have appropriate parking.”

Update (corrected): Ben Kabak of Second Avenue Sagas pointed out that CB 12’s Spitzer was Greenfield’s deputy chief of staff; Spitzer told Streetsblog he no longer works for the council member.

A nine-story development features two stories of underground parking, but that's not enough for David Greenfield and Community Board 12. Photo via CPEX Retail Leasing [PDF]
A nine-story development features two stories of underground parking, but that’s not enough for David Greenfield and Community Board 12. Rendering via CPEX Retail Leasing [PDF]
The evidence that more parking causes more traffic hasn’t swayed CB 12. “Adding parking doesn’t add congestion. Adding businesses adds congestion,” Spitzer said. “I don’t think additional parking will add congestion to the neighborhood, in my opinion.”

While the project highlights how much work remains to educate council members and community boards about how parking works, the number of parking spaces that will be built is not really in doubt. The developer is going to build 272 spaces either way, since it can substitute non-profit offices for medical offices and, thanks to the vagaries of NYC parking requirements, no special permit will be necessary.

In January, CB 12 voted 23-1 to recommend a rejection of Singer’s special permit request to build less parking than required. The developer went before the Board of Standards and Appeals last Tuesday, and a second hearing at the BSA has been scheduled for September 9.

“I don’t know that we properly explained it to them or that they fully understood what was going on, but they opposed it,” Goldman said of CB 12. “We are continuing to try to meet with the council member to explain this further and hopefully change his mind.”

  • bolwerk

    Okay, first off, don’t take at face value anything anyone shoots out as many carelessly constructed fibs as kenney.

    There is a small grain of truth in what he said. There is no single interpretation of Orthodox (or any) Judaism. It ranges from quite progressive strains like Modern Orthodoxy, where some members could be big gay rights supporters, to any number of more politically and religiously strict ones that go so far as to separate men and women in all sorts of ways. There are private buses run by Haredi sects in Brooklyn that segregate men and women.

    But overall, no, Orthodox men and women are not adverse to being in public together. And it’s a silly thing to build policy around period.

  • Maggie

    thanks! It feels like weird territory when we get to: my religion decrees parking. The gender segregation just adds to it. I come back to, if you can’t mingle on public transportation, that also rules out flying on commercial airlines?

    Anyways, sorry. Shiksa questions!

  • Andrew

    Who’s harassing you or demonizing you?

  • Andrew

    If all of our commerce is motor vehicle driven and has been for almost a century, then how is it that most NYC households don’t even own a car?

    Get out of your bubble. Not everyone is like you.

  • Andrew

    A far cry from your earlier claim that “the men cannot ride on public transportation,” wouldn’t you say?

    No less an authority than Rabbi Moshe Feinstein declared that riding a crowded train is permissible. While there may be some who don’t accept that ruling, they are in the extreme minority.

  • Andrew

    The prohibition is on men touching women in an affectionate manner. If a train is so crowded that strangers are touching, then it’s certainly not in an affectionate manner (unless we’re talking molestation, which I certainly hope isn’t the assumption.

    Read the last source in the link I posted a few days ago. Moshe Feinstein was a widely respected rabbinic decisor who lived on the Lower East Side until his death in the 1986. He was no stranger to the subway.

    Plenty of orthodox men ride the subway, take flights, and mingle with gay men.


City Council’s Zeal for Affordable Housing Crumbles If It Means Less Parking

On Tuesday, members of the City Council hammered the de Blasio administration for not guaranteeing enough housing units for low-income New Yorkers in new construction. But yesterday, when the topic turned to building more affordable housing by reducing parking requirements, several Council members lost their zeal for housing and worried more about car storage. The hearing yesterday […]

This Week: City Council Considers Greenfield’s Dirty Streets Bill

James Vacca and the City Council Transportation Committee continue to tackle the pressing issues facing our streets and transit system. Among the legislation getting a hearing at this week’s transpo committee meeting is a bill from Brooklyn Council Member David Greenfield that would ban city agencies from placing adhesive stickers on motor vehicles. The Department […]

Meet Your New Transportation and Land Use Committee Chairs

It’s official: Council Member Ydanis Rodriguez is chair of the transportation committee, and Council Member David Greenfield will head up the powerful land use committee. While Rodriguez’s appointment has been greeted mostly with optimism by street safety advocates, Greenfield’s ascendance raises flags about whether the city will be able to get much-needed parking reforms through […]

Ridiculous David Greenfield Parking Bills: A Timeline

A few years back Streetsblog ran a post with the headline “Another Year, Another David Greenfield Parking Bill.” And it’s true! Except for 2014, Greenfield has introduced or sponsored legislation intended to somehow lessen the hassle of parking every year since 2010. While he’s a vocal proponent of Vision Zero, it still seems Greenfield has never […]

Rezoning to Encourage Street Life on Brooklyn’s Fourth Avenue

When the Department of City Planning put forward its rezoning of Park Slope in 2003, one of the earliest of the now 111 rezonings under Mayor Bloomberg and City Planning Commissioner Amanda Burden, it was intended to help turn Fourth Avenue into “a grand boulevard of the 21st Century.” The sought-after residential development has started […]