Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bridge Tolls

John Liu Releases a Bridge Toll Plan That Panders to Motorists

So John Liu has managed to take an excellent idea -- tolling the East River bridges -- and turn it into a policy disaster.

The key component of Liu's plan, which he says would raise $410 million annually, isn't the tolls -- it's the exemption for city residents. Here's what Liu said at an Association for Better New York event today:

To get that money, we would toll the East River Bridges for non-city residents. It's something that's been talked about before, and I think certainly makes sense, and is more realistic than a restoration of the commuter tax -- that I would love to see, but I'm not sure how open Albany would be.

Of course, Albany is just going to fall in love with a toll plan where Nassau, Suffolk, and Westchester pay, while New York City doesn't.

Here's an excerpt from the press release that accompanied the release of the "People's Budget" -- an overall fiscal plan that Liu released in his capacity as comptroller:

Tolling the East River Bridges would mean that membership -- or in this case, residency, New York City residency -- has its privileges. Non-residents commuting by car can and should contribute to the upkeep of our city's infrastructure.

By exempting motorists who live in the five boroughs, Liu's plan would not solve the city's transit funding problems -- the next MTA capital program will still have a gaping hole. (Compare Liu's $410 million to the $2.8 $1.5 billion projected net revenue from the Sam Schwartz plan.) While Liu suggested devoting revenue to "infrastructure," he also mentioned that it could be used for "offsetting increased city contributions to the MTA," which might just lead to tolls that pad other areas of the city budget.

It's somewhat baffling why Liu would propose a non-starter like this. Exempting millions of motorists negates the value of tolls as a tool to meaningfully reduce congestion, and it undermines the notion that motorists should pay for using roads. Let's hope this idea doesn't infect the other campaigns.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Sean Duffy’s ‘Great America Road Trip’ Wants You to Drive to Central Park

Sean Duffy's "Great American Road Trip" encourages Americans to drive to sites in the most transit-rich and car-choked parts of the country.

July 3, 2025

Ex-DOT Official Warns NYC’s ‘Counterproductive’ E-bike Speed Limit Will Curb Biking, Safety

The mayor is working overtime to undo the decade of gains for cycling in the Big Apple, a former de Blasio administration official told Streetsblog.

July 3, 2025

Thursday’s Headlines: Just the News Edition

Things are slowing down for summer, but not entirely. Here's the news.

July 3, 2025

DOT Boss Defends Adams’s ‘Vision Zero’ Record As Agency Fights A Bike Lane in Court

Traffic fatalities are down and the DOT is taking a victory lap — even as it argues against a protected bike lane in court.

July 2, 2025

Cyclist Arrested After Crash with Electric ‘One-wheel’-Style Unicycle

Carolyn Backus is charged with fleeing the scene of a crash causing serious injury, but the details are murky.

Wednesday’s Headlines: Return of Summer Streets Edition

Summer Streets is back and bigger than ever. Plus more news.

July 2, 2025
See all posts