Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycle Parking

Indoor Parking Swap: More Space for Bikes, Less for Cars?

bike_parking.jpgA diagram showing proposed bike parking requirements for one class of residential construction. Source: DCP (PDF)

Yesterday the City Planning Commission heard feedback on a proposed zoning amendment to mandate bike parking in new construction. Together with the Bikes in Buildings Bill, which would improve bike access to existing buildings, the measure is intended to address one of the major hurdles to bike commuting -- the lack of a secure place to put your ride.

The zoning change faces less opposition than the bill -- which would achieve a much bigger impact -- but yesterday's hearing was not without debate. You've got to like the sound of the compromise that might be on the table, though. Reader Nathan Skodola sends this recap:

Theopposition was largely organizations involved in low-income housing. Apparentlyfederal subsidies for housing of this kind are determined on a per-unit basis, soadding a non-occupied room gets no extra money. However, virtually all of theopponents would favor the bill if they could exchange a mandatory car parkingspot for 20 mandatory bike parking spots. The commissioners seemed veryreceptive and for the most part in favor of the change.

The commission will weigh yesterday's testimony along with recommendations from community boards and borough presidents.

Both the zoning change and the Bikes in Buildings Bill may come before the City Council around mid-March, says Transportation Alternatives. The bill first needs to clear the Transportation Committee, which held a hearing on it late last year. Following that hearing, the bill is being reworked to clearly require bike access, as opposed to storage, said Tim Roberts, policy director for sponsor David Yassky. The key provision to keep an eye on is the escape clause, which will have to grant exemptions to landlords who need one, without giving too much leeway to those who don't.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

City Council to Bring Back Year-Round Outdoor Dining After Adams-Era Decimation

New Council Speaker Julie Menin wants to scrap Adams-era rules that shrunk the program to just 400 approved locations from a pandemic era high of 8,000.

February 4, 2026

Meet Steve Fulop, Corporate New York’s New Mouthpiece

Streetsblog sat down with former Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop last week to discuss his new role at the Partnership for New York City.

February 4, 2026

Promising E-Bike Subsidy Pilot Is Denied Funding By State Agency

New York City's first e-bike subsidy program is stalled after not receiving state funding for implementation.

February 4, 2026

Wednesday’s Headlines: Nothingburger From The Albany Sausage Grinder Edition

OK, so the transportation hearing was a bust, but two groups questioned the governor's car insurance proposal, so that's a start. Plus other news.

February 4, 2026

Cyclists in Criminal Court Say Mamdani’s Bike Crackdown is a ‘Waste of Time’

The hearings reveal that the mayor's promise to end criminal summonsing against cyclists has not been kept.

February 3, 2026

‘Lowballing Victims’: Crash Survivors Furious At Hochul’s Car Insurance Proposal

Crash victims and a key state lawmaker are not yet sold on Hochul's car insurance scheme, and hope that the state listens.

February 3, 2026
See all posts