Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

Hochul Must Put Up or Shut Up on Congestion Pricing, New Senate Transportation Chair Says

Gov. Hochul must produce a "100-day plan" to replace the $16.5 billion MTA funding shortfall created by her decision to cancel congestion pricing.

Streetsblog Photoshop Desk|

State Sen. Jeremy Cooney (inset) has a blue-ribbon idea for Gov. Hochul, seen recently at a panel frustratingly not about congestion pricing.

Fix the mess.

Gov. Hochul must produce a "100-day plan" to replace the $16.5 billion MTA funding shortfall created by her decision to cancel congestion pricing's June 30 launch — either through an "alternative method of financing" or reinstating a "version" of the plan she kiboshed, a top Albany official said on Wednesday.

"The time for debating the merits of congestion pricing has passed, what is most important is keeping our promise to the passengers and workers impacted across the state," state Sen. Jeremy Cooney, who took over as chair of the Senate's Transportation Committee in May, wrote in an op-ed for USA TODAY.

State Sen. Jeremy CooneyNYS Senate Media Services

"The governor should convene finance, industry, labor and passenger representatives to thoughtfully recommend either an alternative method of financing the capital program or a version of the congestion pricing plan we already had in place," said Cooney, a Democrat from upstate Rochester. "Regardless of which of these options we choose, it’s clear that we can’t keep the MTA waiting until the next state budget or beyond."

Cooney's op-ed also called attention to the billions of dollars companies far from the MTA region will miss out on thanks to Hochul's decision, which he said "hurts upstate New York manufacturing." The total hit to the upstate economy amounts to about $12 billion and 100,000 jobs, according to Reinvent Albany.

"From Western New York and the Southern Tier, to the North Country and the Hudson Valley, every region in our state is affected by the decision to pause congestion pricing," Cooney wrote.

Hochul's abrupt and unexpected June 5 announcement to "indefinitely pause" congestion pricing threw the MTA into financial disarray. Transit officials have said some $16.5 billion worth of projects must be "deferred" without the tolling money — including station accessibility, signal upgrades, new trains and buses and the Second Avenue Subway extension into East Harlem.

The MTA may also have to turn to its operating budget to repay loans, raising the possibility of fare hikes or service cuts, officials warn.

The impact of Hochul's disastrous congestion pricing decision: less expansion, less accessibility, dirtier buses, older trains, outdated signals and more.Graphic via MTA

Other leaders in Albany may not share Cooney's urgency. Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, who represents a Bronx district that would benefit greatly from MTA improvements, refused to condemn the governor's decision and insisted that he wants to "work on a solution that all parties can agree to" ... without offering any actual solution.

The senate leader, Senate President Andrea Stewart-Cousins, who represents a district in southern Westchester, has stayed mostly silent, deferring to her caucus — where a substantial number of senators back the tolls. Senate Finance Chair Liz Krueger, for example, believes that Hochul's subversion of the congestion pricing plan the legislature passed in 2019 violates the law.

Hochul, for her part, has been sanguine to the point of delusion about the MTA's prospects.

"We've been funding the MTA since the 1910s — billions of billions of dollars. We somehow did it without a few months of congestion pricing," Hochul said glibly last week in an interview with the Albany Times-Union's Dan Clark.

Reps for governor's office did not immediately return a request for comment. In the past, the governor has said she will fund the MTA's current and future capital plans, though she has offered no replacement for the congestion pricing revenue.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Report: Efforts to Speed Up Bus Speeds Have Stalled … Like Bus Speeds

City buses move slower than ever after Mayor Adams reneged on his commitment to build more bus lanes, according to a new analysis.

February 7, 2025

Paradigm Shift: MTA Boss Says State Should Pony Up More For Capital Plans

"Every time the MTA capital program comes up, we treat it like, 'Oh my god, they need a bailout,'" the MTA CEO said, pointing out the absurdity.

February 7, 2025

Who is Trump’s FTA Pick Marc Molinaro — And Will He Kill Congestion Pricing?

If confirmed, Trump FTA pick Marc Molinaro can do a lot to gum up funding for mass transit across the country. Here's a look at his record.

February 7, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: It Never Ends Edition

A great Hell Gate story about fake placards is our top story. Plus other news in our digest.

February 7, 2025
See all posts