Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

The Roller-Coaster Ride of MTA Boss Janno Lieber

The MTA CEO's role appears to be changing rapidly.

The Streetsblog Photoshop Desk

With DAVE COLON in ALBANY — MTA CEO Janno Lieber went from congestion pricing standard-bearer to Gov. Hochul's tin cup shaker — but his role appears to be changing rapidly as the legislature remains in confusion.

Lieber, who sources have told Streetsblog opposes and was blindsided by the governor's decision to delay congestion pricing, initially started working the phones to get congestion pricing advocates in the state legislature to support a stopgap, non-toll funding scheme — with the hope that congestion pricing can be saved as a concept when lawmakers return to Albany next year.

"He's calling everyone saying he needs money and thinks the stopgap will save congestion pricing for the future," said one Albany lawmaker who received a call from Lieber as legislators take up Hochul's still-non-existent plan to cobble together some combination of taxes or other funding to raise $1 billion for the MTA now, and kick the congestion pricing can down the road.

Another state lawmaker told Streetsblog that Lieber said in a call that without a one-time cash infusion — ironically, the very cash that congestion pricing was supposed to start delivering on June 30 — the MTA won't be able to do any of the existing capital work.

But since those initial calls, Lieber has apparently pulled back after fully understanding the massive backlash to Hochul's betrayal, one lawmaker said. And at one point, Lieber even threatened to resign over the governor's delay, the Post reported — though it is unclear at what point in this fast-moving timeline that may have occurred.

In any event, Lieber is reading the same tea leaves as everyone else and now sees that a substantial number of legislators won't support the governor.

"She doesn't have the votes in our chamber," one state Senator told Streetsblog.

The bottom line, said a different insider, is it's now up to the governor to make the calls and twist the arms to convince lawmakers to accept her congestion pricing delay and fill the MTA's budget gap. Which could explain why no one has seen the governor in days.

And now, said another source inside the MTA's Lower Manhattan headquarters, the agency will have to take a serious look at dramatically scaling back its aggressive — and until Wednesday, well-funded — capital reconstruction and modernization plans.

With Jackie Zamora in Manhattan

This is a breaking story and will be updated.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Streetsblog to DOT: We’ll See You in Court — Again!

Streetsblog is quite a FOIL to the Department of Transportation!

September 17, 2024

Carmageddon: Shift to Remote Work Led to Increase in Driving and Congestion Nationally

Driving miles are higher today than they were before the pandemic, even though more Americans than ever still work from home.

September 17, 2024

Tuesday’s Headlines: Make McGuinness Safe Edition

The mayor's failure to implement the full road diet on McGuinness Boulevard continues to have terrible repercussions. Plus other news.

September 17, 2024

Opinion: A Lethal Threat to New York City’s Air and Citizen Enforcement 

Intro 941 jeopardizes clean air improvements hard-won through the city's citizen enforcement program.

September 17, 2024

Hamstrung! Congestion Pricing ‘Pause’ Screws Over the Next MTA Capital Plan: Report

Gov. Hochul’s congestion pricing pause will eat into the MTA’s execution of its next capital plan and push the start of work on that plan back by years, a new report argues.

September 16, 2024
See all posts