MTA Board Member: Capital Plan Vote Might Not Even Happen This Year

The board and the governor are at loggerheads. So what happens now?

We'll take two out of three. Okay fine, one out of three! Photo by Dave Colon
We'll take two out of three. Okay fine, one out of three! Photo by Dave Colon

A Metropolitan Transportation Authority board member said yesterday that, lacking a draft capital plan, the board may not be able to vote on funding for the authority when it meets in late September.

“To this day, we still have not seen a draft of the proposed capital program,” MTA Board member Veronica Vanterpool told reporters on Monday afternoon. “And it’s not clear whether or not we will be voting” — as the board is required to do by statute. The 2015-2019 capital plan came in at a record $32 billion, a mark that may be eclipsed by the rumored $50 billion cost for the 2020-2024 plan.

The MTA has still not come close to finishing work on the 2015-19 capital plan, but a delay on the upcoming plan will only serve to push back necessary system improvements like line-wide signal upgrades and new subway cars.

Vanterpool blamed Governor Cuomo for the hold-up.

“The governor made it very clear in his letter to the board that there would not be a capital program submission until some of the other needs were met,” Vanterpool said, referring to a July letter Cuomo wrote to the board.

In  the letter, Cuomo told the board to continue a series of reforms like the AlixPartners-led MTA reorganization and a number of task forces related to issues such as  train speed, safety and fare evasion. Most important, Cuomo wrote that “there can be no new capital plan” until after an independent entity completed a forensic audit of the MTA, an audit that is not due until January 2020.

Adding more confusion, Cuomo wrote another letter to the MTA Board on Monday afternoon laying out what he said were his main priorities for the capital plan. The letter demanded that the MTA (an entity that the governor effectively controls) undertake somewhat contradictory paths, such as prioritizing both system expansion projects and signal upgrades.

The governor also wrote that the Long Island Railroad and Metro-North must get  “an equitable distribution of resources” in the plan, which no one has seen and is due for a vote in two weeks, even as the commuter railroads have received more MTA capital money than they give to the system in fares and taxes.

Okay. So how can the board take its vote by Oct. 1, as state law requires?

No one can tell, and many Albany watchdogs are pissed off about it.

“Any uncertainty around the plan’s approval is unacceptable with less than four months remaining until 2020,” Rachael Fauss of Reinvent Albany said. “Uncertainty creates the opportunity for the process to be done behind closed doors, without public input.”

Reinvent Albany recently demonstrated that previous capital plans suffered from a lack of meaningful input or oversight before votes.

Transparency advocates are especially alarmed because the MTA is about to come into a cash windfall, thanks to congestion pricing, which is scheduled to debut in 2021.

“A secretive rush job of a capital plan does not inspire confidence in the process,” said Collin Wright of the TransitCenter. “The next capital program must deliver the repairs and upgrades necessary for the subway to function at the level that New York’s growing population demands.”

Vanterpool’s remarks came as transit advocates rallied in support of a new report recommending ways in which the agency could reform itself by build trust among its constituencies and controlling costs.

The fact that Vanterpool, a board member with voting power, said that she doesn’t believe the capital plan will see the light of day this year is not a good opener for a new era of trust.

The MTA did not respond to a request for comment.

  • Benita

    I most of the time secure somewhere within 6,000 $-8,000 $ each 1 month through the internet. I lost my job after working for the same enterprise for a long period, I wanted very trusted income. I was not researching for programs that promises to make you rich in just few days you see online. The greatest benefit of working online is that I am always home with the children and also enjoy time with family on different beaches of the world. The instructions are really easy, you don’t have to be a computer whiz, however you must understand how to use the internet. It is as simple as being on Facebook. Here’s the means with which to begin ->->->->

  • Larry Littlefield

    Based on what I saw in the city budget, the city and state contributed money to the MTA capital plan for one year, then cut it off when congestion pricing was approved.

    Leaving the capital plan funded by (dwindling) federal money, debt, and debt backed by congestion pricing.

    I get the feeling Cuomo does not want any reinvestment in the subway signal system, which on many lines is approaching the collapse date.

    And with all the worse abuses on the Long Island Railroad, why is the big fight with the TWU?

    And as for what the contractors are charging, there is no way, no how that we have $50 billion. Some of these numbers — $11 billion for jails, for example, are absurd.

    Any real plan would admit we are in system decline, and that this would continue. They should be talking about what parts of the system they are non-planning to abandon, not what parts they want to expand.

    I though Bloomberg cared about the future of the schools. Then he cut the 25/55 UFT pension deal. I though maybe Cuomo cared about the future of the transportation system, or at least parts of it. Parts of it it is.

    The serfs will leave. They should, rather than paying taxes and being abused like this. They pay and pay. The subway is one of the few things they need the government to do for them.

  • BikeGuyEmoji

    BikeGuyEmoji – Nothing is getting abandoned. The population ain’t gonna collapse and New Yorkers will keep expecting good subway service.

  • Larry Littlefield

    New to the city?

    You may have missed half the Manhattan Bridge tracks shut down for 20 years before the money and will was scrounged up to replace it.

    And the serious discussion of abandoning the Sea Beach line.

    A Canarsie Line with service limited to one train in the tunnel at a time, because the fan plant was inoperable and there was no money to fix it.

    The 3rd Avenue El torn down because the Second Avenue Subway was “coming soon.”

    And you might not have noticed that U.S. life expectancy has fallen three years in a row, despite rising lifespans for those over 65, and that millennials are paid 25 percent less than Baby Boomers were at the same age, despite higher educational attainment.

    Ah, but not to worry, “they” will somehow take care over everything.


Here Are Six Times the MTA Was a State Entity Under Cuomo’s Control

Yesterday on WCNY’s “Capitol Pressroom,” Susan Arbetter hosted Governor Andrew Cuomo for a discussion of the MTA capital program. Lately, the governor has been pushing City Hall to fund a greater share of the authority’s investment plan. Arbetter, pressing the governor, asked a simple question: “Isn’t the MTA a state entity?” “It’s not, actually,” Cuomo replied. “It [covers] a metropolitan downstate […]

It’s Cuomo vs. Transit Experts on MTA Funding

Yesterday, Governor Andrew Cuomo called the region’s transit investment plan “bloated” and rejected calls for new revenue. Today, MTA Chairman and CEO Tom Prendergast, speaking at a forum on best practices in regional transit governance, hammered home the need for elected officials to find new money to fill the half-funded capital plan’s $15 billion gap. “This is […]