Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycling

Think Cars Will Always Dominate Because ‘New York’s Not Holland’? Well, Neither Was Holland!

This is what many New York streets could be like. Photo: Clarence Eckerson Jr.

This one's for all you politicians and community board types out there who reject street safety plans because "New York's not Holland."

Video Valkyrie Clarence Eckerson has just returned from Delft — and his latest mini-doc for Streetfilms shows again why it's foolish to protest life-saving road redesigns on the grounds that New York can't be as nice as The Netherlands. The reason? The Netherlands weren't even The Netherlands until they were The Netherlands.

With expatriates Chris and Melissa Bruntlett as his guides, Eckerson reveals the hidden history of the canal-ringed western Holland city sandwiched between Rotterdam and The Hague. Decades ago, Holland was the Detroit of Europe — filled with cars and roadways designed exclusively for their use. (See below)

This is what the road to the local university once looked like. Now, it's a bike and busway.
This is what the road to the local university once looked like. Now, it's a bike and busway.
This is what the road to the local university once looked like. Now, it's a bike and busway.

But with political will — and the desire to bring livability back to their car-choked streets — the Delfites fought back. It was a 20- to 30-year process to get the cars out of the city center, Chris Bruntlett says in the film. "They did it one street at a time."

That's how the revolution will start here. New Yorkers will simply get sick of roadways with 225,000 crashes per year and 61,000 injuries per year, and 200-plus deaths per year. So, no, maybe we're not Holland yet.

But why not aspire to become better than we are now? Cars are a lifestyle choice that is destroying our city. Can we just make other choices easier?

This was another murderstrip before the Dutch fixed it.
This was another murderstrip before the Dutch fixed it.
This was another murderstrip before the Dutch fixed it.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

SHAMEFUL: Pro-Parking DOT ‘Forced’ Lawmakers To Scale Back Daylighting Bill, Says Queens Pol

A parking-first City Hall has thrown up road blocks against pedestrian safety.

November 13, 2025

House T&I Chair Vows ‘No Money for Bikes or Walking’ in Fed Transportation Bill

The outlook for active transportation won't be good if advocates don't stand up.

November 13, 2025

Is Rad Power Bikes Riding into the Sunset?

The Seattle-based e-bike giant may close. It's a big deal for employees and customers.

November 13, 2025

Thursday’s Headlines: Seeing Daylighting Clearly Edition

Hats off to Frank Morano, a Republican from car-dominated Staten Island, who can see the basic logic behind the Council's effort to require daylighting at every intersection in the city. Plus other news.

November 13, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: Slow ‘Em Down Edition

Here's one day when it's OK for reporters to drive a car! (OK, not just any car.) Plus other news.

November 12, 2025
See all posts