CYCLE OF RAGE: NYPD is Not Doing Enough to Crack Down on Cabbies on their Phones

This is the last thing we want to see. Video still: ABC7
This is the last thing we want to see. Video still: ABC7

Updated, Nov. 20 | You see them all day long — cabbies parked in bike lanes checking their phones or driving while searching for their next fare on their devices. Today’s app-based systems basically require New York City taxi drivers to be on their phones almost constantly.

Yet the NYPD wrote just 41 tickets in the first nine months of this year to cabbies violating this basic safety rule, according to data provided by the Taxi and Limousine Commission.

That’s fewer than five tickets per month. Total. From 77 police precincts citywide.

It’s not that cops don’t know it’s illegal for cabbies to operate their phones while driving or unlawfully parked. It’s in the state vehicle and traffic law, chapter 33, section 1225-c and 1225-d. But it’s also right there in the cab driver rule book: Section 80-14(g) states, “A driver must not use an electronic communication device while operating a vehicle. A driver can use an electronic communication device only while the vehicle is lawfully standing or parked.”

And it’s not that the problem isn’t happening. The Taxi and Limousine Commission’s 175 or so enforcement agents wrote 5,259 tickets for drivers violating 80-14(g) over the same nine-month period this year that the NYPD wrote just 41 tickets.

And the Port Authority Police, who patrol predominantly at the airports, wrote 1,102 such tickets this year, again according to the TLC — up from just 73 over the same period last year.

Washington University in St. Louis
This is how too many cabbies race down our streets. Photo: Washington University in St. Louis

These tickets are literally life-savers.

It’s unclear exactly how many of the 171,000 crashes between Jan. 1, 2018 and Sept. 30, 2018 were strictly the result of a driver on a phone, but city data cited “driver inattention/distraction” as the cause of 39,870 or 23 percent. And of the 33,304 crashes that resulted in injuries, inattention and distraction was the cause of 8,221 or 25 percent.

Any way you cut it, drivers who operate vehicles while on their phones are a safety menace. But in a city where tens of thousands of Uber, Lyft, Via and other app-based drivers are required to manipulate their devices as part of their job, cabs are an even bigger threat. Anecdotally, cyclists, pedestrians and cab passengers logged scores of complaints about phone-juggling cabbies on the Reported app — evidence that the NYPD could easily be writing dozens of tickets a day, not just 41 in nine months.

Scrolling through the app’s data stream — which Reported shared with Streetsblog under the agreement that users would not be identified by name — is like plucking the lowest-hanging fruit of Vision Zero.

“As I was riding north on Sixth Avenue in the protected bike lane I saw the driver holding and looking at a cellphone in one hand while making a turn onto 19th St.” one Reported app user posted earlier this year, echoing a fairly common complaint.

Keep scrolling. There are literally dozens of entries that should scare anyone using the roads — and motivate the brass at 1 Police Plaza:

Driver was looking down at phone while driving on west side highway.

Driver is watching YouTube clips while driving on his phone on this dash.

Driver was scrolling through his news feed on his cell phone while driving and waiting in traffic. … This happens way too often.

During the drive, he missed several lights and swerved in and out of lanes nearly rear-ending cars because he was texting. We asked him on several occasions to stop texting because we were concerned about our safety and he refused. He kept taking on and off his glasses it appeared he needed the glasses to text but couldn’t drive with them. Cars repeatedly honked at him for swerving and missing lights changing.

Driver was obviously texting and driving, her head was down looking at her phone while driving across 106th St. This is distracted driving and it is illegal.

Was on phone entire time driving, texting, searching while driving and was being yelled at by pedestrians

Driver failed to yield to pedestrian waiting to cross in a marked crosswalk where there is a yield to pedestrian sign. She was also clearly on her phone looking down. This is extremely dangerous driving behavior.

Ran a red light into a busy pedestrian crosswalk. Using his phone while driving in his right hand as he pushed his way through the crosswalk.

Want the best example of what happens when drivers are distracted by their phones? Read the 2015 lawsuit against Uber driver Aliou Diallo and the taxi company after Diallo ran over and killed Wesley Randall Mensing on the Upper East Side (court document below). The case, which is now sealed, specifically cites the Uber app as a contributing factor to the death because Diallo was on his phone at the time of the crash.

“Diallo … and Uber Technologies knew or should have known that the use of the Uber app” violates section 1225-d, the suit says. Uber “derived great economic benefit through a business model that encouraged violations of 1225-d. The conduct [of the company and its driver] is egregious and constitutes a danger to the public.”

The Taxi and Limousine Commission says it prioritizes 80-14(g), but its numbers this year are 13 percent off the same period last year. Still, the agency is writing far more tickets than the NYPD, which admitted that it doesn’t take the issue seriously enough.

Only certain police officers are trained to write TLC violations,” said Sergeant Jessica McRorie. “There are less than 25 officers trained in TLC enforcement.”

Fewer than 25 officers? Out of a force of more than 38,000?

You do the math. That’s not enough cops dedicated to one of the simplest ways of keeping cyclists, pedestrians and drivers safe.

The NYPD declined to answer further questions.

Gersh Kuntzman is Editor-in-Chief of Streetsblog. When he gets angry, he writes the Cycle of Rage column. They’re archived here.


Wesley Randall Mensing Death Complaint against Uber by Gersh Kuntzman on Scribd


Council Member Antonio Reynoso will rally today for sanitation reform. Photo: John McCarten/NYC Council

Wednesday’s Headlines: A Very Full Day Ahead Edition

It's going to be a busy day, what with a court hearing on Mayor de Blasio's Morris Park Avenue safety redesign at 9:30, an announcement by Revel scooters at 11 a.m., a press conference on Antonio Reynoso's private carting reform bill, then the passage of the Vision Zero Design Standards bill by the Council, despite Mayor de Blasio's opposition, and then we'll end the day with a Taxi and Limousine Commission "dialogue ride" between cyclists and cabbies. Start with the news.

How Do You Handle Dangerous-Driving Cabbies?

A reader sent in this photo of the weekend collision between a yellow cab and a horse carriage on 60th Street at Fifth Avenue. NY1 reports: Central Park erupted into a scene of chaos early Saturday afternoon after witnesses say a taxi heading west from 60th Street toward Fifth Avenue hit an empty horse and […]