De Blasio’s Congestion Plan Isn’t Serious, and Neither Is the City Council Transportation Committee

Today's transportation hearing felt like a throwback to the City Council of 10 or 20 years ago, when the main purpose of the committee was to provide a forum for gripes about parking hassles.

Photo: giggel/Wikimedia Commons
Photo: giggel/Wikimedia Commons

City Council Speaker Corey Johnson and transportation chair Ydanis Rodriguez generally have smart things to say about transit, congestion pricing, and shifting to a low-car transportation system. The transportation committee they oversee is an entirely different story.

Today, Rodriguez convened a hearing to discuss the de Blasio administration’s “Congestion Action Plan” — introduced as a political stunt in the fall to sap momentum from congestion pricing. The plan relies on NYPD to keep some roadway lanes clear during rush hours, but even if it works as planned, the effect will be negligible. Unlike congestion pricing, it won’t actually reduce traffic volumes.

Council Member Ruben Diaz, Sr. at today's transportation hearing.
Council Member Ruben Diaz, Sr. at today’s transportation hearing.

Launched last week, the new curb restrictions have drawn opposition from businesses and industry groups who claim delivery times aren’t negotiable for many merchants.

Those complaints were apparently the impetus for today’s hearing. Other tools at the city’s disposal to reduce congestion were not on the committee’s agenda.

Instead, DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg listened to council members vent about bus lanes in their districts. It felt like a throwback to the City Council of 10 or 20 years ago, when the main purpose of the transportation committee was to provide a forum for griping about the hassles of parking a car for free on NYC streets.

Bronx rep Ruben Diaz Sr., in his second stint on the City Council after an eventful 14-year tour in Albany, set the tone, blaming car congestion on DOT “shrinking streets.” He then launched into a diatribe about the scourge of buses clogging general traffic lanes at the expense of “private citizens” in personal vehicles. The fact that the buses are full of private citizens losing time because people in personal vehicles block bus lanes didn’t seem to register.

Fernando Cabrera, also of the Bronx, echoed that complaint, though at least he added that NYPD doesn’t ticket bus lane blockers fast enough.

Peter Koo, of Queens, and Rafael Salamanca, from the Bronx, both suggested, in different contexts, that New York should allow more personal vehicles to use bus lanes.

The hearing was by and large a wasted opportunity to deliver the strong dose of oversight that Mayor de Blasio’s “clear curbs” strategy needs. It’s a poor substitute for other traffic management policies City Hall could pursue, like placard reform, smarter curbside regulation, HOV restrictions on the East River Bridges, and increased bus priority on city streets.

Rather than demand a more effective approach to congestion reduction from City Hall, Rodriguez and Council Member Keith Powers, who represents Midtown, asked only for better communication and thorough reporting on the plan’s effects.

Trottenberg defended the city’s approach, implying that “clear lanes” and related strategies were all the city can do on its own.

Only Council Member Antonio Reynoso pushed back, calling the city’s traffic plan “nonsense.”

“I don’t think it’s a real congestion plan,” he told Trottenberg. “I think this hearing, for me, is underwhelming and a waste of time when it comes to actually dealing congestion. I’m concerned about the fact that you even have to be up here presenting what I think [are] inconsequential suggestions to a problem that is so grave.”

If de Blasio was serious about reducing congestion, Reynoso said, he’d put his political weight behind congestion pricing. “The mayor supporting [congestion pricing], endorsing it, would be a step in the right direction,” he said.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Why Is There So Much Traffic in NYC? It’s the Free Roads, Stupid

|
Since the de Blasio administration attempted to cap for-hire cars this summer, the debate over Manhattan traffic has gotten louder, but not more productive. Uber claimed it definitely wasn’t the problem. Some council members wondered if bike lanes were slowing down cars. Amid all the noise, something important got lost. At a hearing about Manhattan traffic this morning convened by Borough President Gale Brewer, a simple […]

Rodriguez Champions Toll Reform in Broad Vision for NYC Transportation

|
Reforming New York’s broken road pricing and parking policies top an extensive list of transportation priorities from City Council Transportation Committee Chair Ydanis Rodriguez, which he unveiled this morning in a speech at New York University’s Rudin Center for Transportation. The most pressing item on Rodriguez’s agenda is the Move New York toll reform proposal, which would […]

Parking Reforms Cut Congestion, So When Will DOT Get Serious About Them?

|
Earlier this month City Council transportation chair Ydanis Rodriguez convened a hearing on city parking policy. The committee addressed abuse of DOT- and NYPD-issued parking placards, but did not discuss one of the most promising initiatives in the city tool kit. PARK Smart is a program that increases parking rates on certain blocks at times when demand is highest. […]

Rodriguez Bill Would Mandate Daylighting at 25 Intersections Per Year

|
City Council transportation chair Ydanis Rodriguez introduced legislation today intended to improve pedestrian safety along bus routes and at intersections with high crash rates. Intro 912 would require DOT to daylight the five “most dangerous intersections” in each borough annually, as determined by the number of fatalities and injuries. Curb extensions would be installed to […]