Not This Time, David Weprin

Advocates with the Riders Alliance chanted over Weprin's anti-congestion pricing press conference, calling on him to get out of the way of a policy to reduce traffic and raise funds for transit.

Photo: Rebecca Bailin/Riders Alliance
Photo: Rebecca Bailin/Riders Alliance

Anytime congestion pricing gains some political momentum, you can count on Eastern Queens Assembly Member David Weprin to stage a press event at the foot of the Queensboro Bridge and proclaim that driving for free into the most car-clogged part of the city is an essential right.

Usually, Weprin gets his message across uncontested. But yesterday he had some competition. With Governor Cuomo’s Fix NYC panel recommending a congestion pricing plan worth rallying behind, advocates with the Riders Alliance chanted over Weprin’s press conference, calling on him to get out of the way of a policy to reduce traffic and raise funds for transit.

“David Weprin is standing up for the few people who are rich enough to drive and park in Manhattan,” said Riders Alliance organizer Rebecca Bailin, “and he is ignoring the needs of the vast number of working and middle-class New Yorkers who rely on the subway and buses.”

Advocates came ready with the data to back up their message, citing research from the Community Service Society showing that a small share of outer borough residents car commute to the Manhattan CBD, and those that do tend to be well-off — stats that seeped into coverage in AMNY and Politico.

Photo: Ben Fried
David Weprin, to the left of the mic, was joined by Council Member Barry Grodenchik and State Senator Leroy Comrie at yesterday’s ritualistic press conference. Photo: Ben Fried

The Weprin presser featured ritualistic quotes about Eastern Queens commuters who’d be ravaged by congestion pricing (even though the proposed fee is about equal to subway fare for any car commuters who have a carpooler), and the purported hit that small business owners who run trucks into Manhattan would absorb.

The volunteers who showed up for the Riders Alliance weren’t buying it, and they spoke from personal experience.

“I like that bus service will improve,” said Jim Burke, 52, who commutes from the Rockaways to Midtown. “Anyone who’s taken a crosstown bus wants to jump out the window, it’s so slow.”

Burke rides the QM16 express bus to work in morning, when the route goes through the tolled Queens Midtown Tunnel to cross the East River. When the bus heads back to the Rockaways in the evening, it goes over the free Queensboro Bridge, and the traffic renders it unusable.

“You cannot take it home,” Burke said. “You hit the 59th Street bridge, you will kill yourself.” More than 16,000 people ride buses over the Queensboro each weekday, enduring molasses-like speeds during the p.m. rush. In Queens Plaza, buses poke along at walking speed, according to a 2010 study by DOT [PDF].

Toby Sheppard-Bloch, 41, lives in Glendale and used to run a small interior remodeling business, with two vans and three to four employees. The costs and aggravation of congestion were a major factor in his decision to close shop a few years ago.

“I had to drive all over town, and it’s awful,” he said. “You don’t know if it’s going to take 45 minutes or two hours.”

If one of his vehicles didn’t get to a building by 5 p.m., any scheduled work had to get pushed to the next day, he said. “It was aggravating, it was frustrating, it inhibited the growth of my business.”

“As a rule,” said Sheppard-Bloch, the price of a congestion fee is “dwarfed” by the expense of operating vehicles in heavy traffic. “It’s pennies to dollars.”


David Weprin: The Parking Garage Industry’s Valet?

The Post finds that Queens City Council Member David Weprin has been raking in campaign contributions from parking garage owners, all the while serving as one of the loudest critics of Mayor Bloomberg’s congestion pricing plan. This ought to sound familiar to Streetsblog readers. Back in May we found that Weprin had taken in at […]

Dueling Videos: Weprin and McCaffrey vs. New York’s Future

Azi Paybarah at the Politicker shot this video of Queens City Council Member David Weprin’s anti-pricing rally yesterday. Sharing the podium with Weprin is Walter McCaffrey of Keep NYC Congestion Tax Free. Can you count the distortions relayed in this nine minute reel? After the jump, Azi gets a response from Michael O’Loughlin of the […]

Anti-Pricing Council Member Has Pro-Parking Industry Fans

With one possible exception, no elected official has been more outspoken against congestion pricing for New York City than Queens Council Member David Weprin. A scan of the city’s campaign finance database reveals over 20,000 reasons why that could be. It may not be a significant amount in relative terms, but since taking office in […]

What Western Queens Stands to Lose Without Congestion Pricing

Queens residents crash Friday’s anti-pricing rally We’ve received several reports that Friday’s anti-pricing rally on the Queens side of the 59th Street Bridge, spearheaded by City Council Member Tony Avella, was a bust. According to our sources, of the council members slated to attend — Avella, Leroy Comrie, Melinda Katz, David Weprin "and other possible […]

MTA Chief Lee Sander Talks Congestion Pricing in Queens

MTA CEO, Queens native and LIRR commuter Lee Sander received a warm reception then "faced some tough questions when he addressed a combined meeting of the Saul Weprin and Eleanor Roosevelt Democratic Clubs on Thursday in Hollis Hills" last Thursday, the Queens Chronicle reports: Although he was welcomed back by old school chum Councilman David […]