Can Cuomo Deliver an Effective Congestion Pricing Plan Without East River Bridge Tolls?

The moment of truth is approaching.

Photo: NY Governor's Office/Flickr
Photo: NY Governor's Office/Flickr

Will Andrew Cuomo’s congestion pricing plan deliver the goods and rid NYC of its most debilitating traffic jams? It’s still anyone’s guess.

In cryptic remarks at his budget address yesterday, Cuomo said his plan will “define a pricing zone” but “doesn’t toll bridges.”

“It uses new technology that can define a geographic zone,” he said. “If you drive into that zone at certain times you can pay a toll increase… We have to define the zone, we have to determine the fees, we have to determine the hours.” A full report from his Fix NYC commission is coming at the end of the week.

Cuomo is describing the core traits of a real congestion pricing system: charging all motorists traveling within a prescribed area, with a variable fee that rises and falls in response to the intensity of traffic.

But it’s hard to imagine an effective congestion pricing plan for New York City that doesn’t toll the free East River bridges.

The price differential between the MTA’s tolled East River crossings and the four free bridges leads to “toll shopping” that manifests as crushing traffic jams on streets approaching the bridges. More than 450,000 motor vehicles enter or leave Manhattan via those four bridges on a typical weekday. Much of the benefit of the Move NY toll reform plan derives from equalizing the tolls on all East River crossings and eliminating the incentive to toll shop.

A plan that doesn’t toll drivers crossing the East River — drawing a cordon around the heart of Midtown, for instance — might appease congestion pricing opponents like Eastern Queens Assembly Member David Weprin, but it won’t deliver the regionally significant traffic reduction that a plan like Move NY would.

Under Move NY, bus riders in western Queens and downtown Brooklyn would notice the drop in traffic. With fewer cars clogging the streets, they would get faster, more reliable trips. A smaller pricing zone won’t ripple out the same way — it will speed up Midtown trips for the Uber-riding class and not much else.

A kinder interpretation of Cuomo is that he doesn’t intend to toll the actual bridges, but will define the cordon so drivers crossing the bridges can connect to the FDR Drive without paying a fee. All drivers who use the local street network would still pay. In effect, this would toll most bridge traffic — which is good policy but an awkward fit with his comments yesterday.

So is Bill de Blasio on the case, pressing the governor to get the details right? A small pricing zone has big implications not only for traffic and bus service, but for transit fares. It wouldn’t raise nearly as much revenue for the MTA capital plan as Move NY, which means straphangers would be on the hook instead in the form of higher fares.

Preventing future fare hikes should be something a good progressive like de Blasio is directly attuned to. Of course, none of that registered with mayor motorhead:

“Brooklyn and Queens,” in de Blasio’s mind, refer to the small, mostly affluent cadre of residents who car commute to Manhattan, not the millions of people who are dealing with worse transit service and steadily rising fares.

Not to be outdone in this arena, Cuomo’s draft budget doesn’t say anything about congestion pricing revenues reducing the need for fare-backed debt at the MTA. In fact, Politico reports, it shifts the burden of paying for subway and bus investments to City Hall and de Blasio, who would be expected to come up with several billion dollars each year.

It’s an outrageous power play that “comes from an alternate reality,” Reinvent Albany director John Kaehny told Politico. As a Cuomo strong-arm tactic to open negotiations over congestion pricing, it’s a little less outrageous. But is his congestion pricing plan even worth supporting? We’ll know more by the end of the week.

  • Cuomo’s MTA

    I can already hear Trump’s term for the governor during the 2020 presidential race. With Andy’s high pitched voice, it will be “Cowardly Cuomo” hiding from the big decisions and shirking responsibilities. He and DeBlasio will sink together.

  • vnm

    de Blasio: “What does Brooklyn and Queens get back from the equation?” How about more reliable and better subways?????? WTF.

  • AnoNYC

    I’m worried about this. Move NY checks a lot of boxes, this sounds totally different.

  • kevd

    “Can Cuomo Deliver an Effective Congestion Pricing Plan Without East River Bridge Tolls?”
    Yes.
    Will he?
    I really doubt it.

  • kevd

    thats cute.
    Cuomo’s new budget requires NYC to pay for all of NYCT’s capital plan.

  • Reggie

    I had the opposite interpretation of Cuomo’s “geographic zone” comment, which grew out of an op-ed—I forget who wrote it—stating that congestion isn’t limited to Manhattan below Central Park. Rather than assume the governor meant a smaller area, I thought he might be saying the cordon would be set at (say) the Barclays Center rather than the East River crossings. I probably have my head in the clouds. It’s Thursday; we’ll know what he means soon enough.

  • By any chance was the op-ed by David Leonhardt of NYT?
    (via Planetizen: “Op-Ed: Only Political Cowardice Stands in the Way of Congestion Pricing in New York,”Jan 10, 2018
    https://www.planetizen.com/news/2018/01/96643-op-ed-only-political-cowardice-stands-way-congestion-pricing-new-york

  • If folks haven’t read this Nov. 18 piece from Emma G. Fitzsimmons, et.al in NYT, on dire state of subway, please do, but be forewarned, it’s very long, and very sad.
    “How Politics and Bad Decisions Starved New York’s Subways,”
    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/18/nyregion/new-york-subway-system-failure-delays.html?rref=collection%2Fbyline%2Femma-g.-fitzsimmons

  • Reggie

    Well done, sir. I didn’t agree with everything that Leonhardt wrote but he did say something that no one else had (that I noticed).

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

On Congestion Pricing, Cuomo Plays the Pundit, Not the Governor

|
Andrew Cuomo knows he’s the governor of New York, right? You couldn’t tell from this exchange about congestion pricing yesterday, via Transportation Nation: Q: Have you seen Sam Schwartz’s revised congestion pricing plan? Do you support it? A: I have not seen it. We’ve talked about congestion pricing for many years. We’ve tried to pass […]

Cuomo: College Should Be Priced Rationally. Roads? Not So Much.

|
At a press conference today, Governor Cuomo touted a new plan to introduce a “rational” pricing mechanism to help the state provide critical resources to New York residents. He was talking, of course, about SUNY tuition, which will be structured to rise five percent a year for the next five years. As for introducing a […]