How DOT Is Using Data to Perfect Its Street Safety Projects

The agency hopes a new data model will enable fine-grained analysis of how specific street design changes help prevent crashes and injuries.

Developers at DataKind used DOT's existing traffic counts, which encompass just five percent of city streets, to generate a model of traffic on all other streets. Image: DataKind
Developers at DataKind used DOT's existing traffic counts, which encompass just five percent of city streets, to generate a model of traffic on all other streets. Image: DataKind

When NYC DOT planners set out to make a city street safer, they have a variety of design tools at their disposal. But it’s not always obvious which one will make the biggest impact to reduce traffic injuries and deaths. So DOT is developing a data model to provide a clear answer.

Over the last year, DOT has been working with developers at the non-profit DataKind to analyze the effects of its street safety projects. Factoring in before-and-after crash data and the design components of each project — the sidewalk extensions, signal adjustments, and other ingredients in its engineering toolkit — DOT aims to get a sharper sense of the specific effect of each component on safety.

DataKind has actually created two models. One helps DOT quickly assess the effect of a street intervention on motor vehicle traffic. Yes, this reflects the fact that the agency still factors in traffic flow when making street design decisions (which is regrettable!), but in this context, it’s a tool to accelerate safety projects.

Because DOT only has hard traffic counts for about 5 percent of city streets, currently planners go out and measure vehicle flow at the location of a redesign, a process that takes about a month. The DataKind model may make this step in the process obsolete by extrapolating traffic data for streets that haven’t been measured directly.

“That means that the planner who’s about to start working on a project… sitting at their desk they can immediately have a sense of whatever design they’re thinking about, whether it’s [viable],” said DOT Director of Safety Policy and Research Rob Viola.

The other data model aims to forecast the safety effect of a specific redesign. It’s still a work in progress, because the model doesn’t have a large enough dataset to accurately predict the safety impact of individual design elements.

“When you really chop up the [street improvement projects] into these pieces, there’s just not enough of each individual piece throughout the city for the software to figure out” their effectiveness, Viola said. “This model is getting us closer to being able to estimate when you put in a project, not only how it will affect traffic in the future, but how it will affect safety in the future.”

The map shows the level of increase or decrease in crashes causing injuries at locations of safety projects implemented between 2008 and 2014. Image: DataKind
The map shows the increase or decrease in crashes causing injuries at locations of safety projects implemented between 2008 and 2014. Image: DataKind

When the dataset is sufficiently robust, DOT will use it to evaluate projects with greater attention to detail.

Why, for example, do some protected bike lanes reduce crashes and injuries more than others [PDF]? On Eighth Avenue, where DOT installed protected bike lanes between 2008 and 2010, injuries declined 20 percent between 14th Street and 23rd Street, but only 4 percent between 23rd Street and 34th Street.

“Once we have that knowledge, that’s going to make us more precision-guided in terms of [design elements],” Viola said.

  • Mike

    So will they be using this model to implement the new Barnes Dance intersections?

  • AnoNYC

    Why are planners still doing traffic counts?

    At this point the city should have the technology automatically enabled to detect automotive volumes on every street (includ bridges and highways).

    For pedestrians, cellular phone data would perhaps give a good estimate. Bluetooth or wifi hotspots passed on foot (e.g. LinkNYC)

    The technologies exist!

  • 1ifbyrain2ifbytrain

    fewer cars, lower speed limits, enforcement of existing laws, police and government employees using public transportation…

  • Janet Liff

    DOT might look at the pedestrian counts. Is that part of the puzzle? Pedestrian counts are higher further north on 8th Avenue; maybe people are being forced into the street.

  • J

    So no models to measure ped traffic, bike traffic, and transit? Guess those modes don’t matter much.

    “Safety first!… as long as drivers aren’t inconvenienced too much”

  • JK

    Do they model parking regs, placards, illegal parking and double parking? That has as much as effect on street safety and traffic flow as just about anything. Placard vehicles create double parking (those UPS, electricians etc have to park somewhere) and those double parked cars force cyclists way out into traffic where they can get picked and even doored 20 feet from the curb. Gotta fix curbside parking as part of Vision Zero — not just street engineering.

  • Vooch

    what do pedestrians have to do with midtown traffic ?


  • Assessing he design elements impact on safety is very encouraging .
    A model for traffic flows is a complete waste of time since any small construction project can change the conditions drastically. How many utilities projects are taking place in the streets everyday?


NYC DOT Shares Its Five Principles for Designing Safer Streets

Earlier this month, NYC DOT put out a major new report, Making Safer Streets [PDF], that collects before-and-after data from dozens of street redesigns and distills five key principles to reduce traffic injuries. The excitement of election week overshadowed the release, but this is an important document that livable streets supporters will want to bookmark. […]

The 2013 NYC Streetsies, Part 3

Happy New Year, and welcome to the third and final installment of the 2013 NYC Streetsies, also known as the Streetsblog Hall of Fame induction ceremony. Lifetime Achievement We take it for granted these days that NYC DOT is primed to make change happen — that every year, the department will roll out a fresh new […]

DOT Can’t Control the Seasons, But de Blasio Can Fund Safer Street Designs

Today DOT announced a “dusk and darkness” traffic enforcement and education campaign to reduce pedestrian injuries and deaths during fall and winter, when fatal crashes tend to be more frequent. “As the days get shorter and the weather colder, crashes on our streets involving pedestrians increase — and so we are enlisting data-driven strategies to address that upturn,” […]