5 Highlights From Last Night’s Bike-Share vs. Parking Meeting

A dense network of stations is what makes bike-share work so well in these Brooklyn neighborhoods.

Last night’s Brooklyn Community Board 6 bike-share forum lacked the fireworks of previous meetings — no physical threats this time. While the tone was civil, the demands from the anti-bike-share crowd weren’t exactly reasonable.

So far, Citi Bike has proven incredibly popular in CB 6, with some stations getting as much as seven rides per dock each day. That’s a lot more activity than the average free car parking spot ever sees.

Opponents said they would be fine with the bike-share stations if they didn’t occupy curb space that previously served as free car storage. They suggested the docks be moved onto sidewalks and that the station density be cut in half. But sidewalks in Park Slope and Carroll Gardens don’t have room for bike-share stations, and reducing station density would ruin the usefulness of the bike-share system. Bike-share only works well when you don’t have to walk more than a couple of minutes to reach a station.

With the room at capacity, Council Member Brad Lander live streamed the meeting for people stuck outside. The entire one-hour, 45-minute video (which amazingly does not capture the entire meeting) is available on Lander’s Facebook page. Here are the highlights:

The Cobble Hill Citi Biker who called opponents on their bluff (1:28)

“As a taxpayer who’s been subsidizing free parking for people who have cars, I myself don’t have one, I never understood how angry people felt when they felt like something has been taken away from them that belongs to them,” Cobble Hill resident Lily Geller said. “Until I became a member of the Citi Bikes program, and the thought of losing the dock that’s on my street terrifies me. I would be so upset if I don’t have access to Citi Bikes anymore.”

Geller went on to defend the density of the stations. “The density is what makes it work,” she said. “The problem comes in when you don’t have a place where you can park a bike that you’ve taken out, or where you’re not within a place where there’s a bike within four, five or ten blocks from you.” Listen to the whole thing. She hits the nail on the head.

The Park Slope mom who gave up her family’s car (49:00)

Park Slope resident Gail Hines said that getting rid of her family’s car was “the most liberating thing I ever did,” and she was met with applause. “I defy you to find somewhere — in the city charter, in the state constitution, in the constitution of the United States — that guarantees you a free parking space. And I don’t think there’s an 11th Commandment ‘Thou shalt have free parking.'”

That Upper West Sider who drives to visit his friends in Brooklyn (13:00)

Yes, this happened. “I usually come out in my Jeep,” said Upper West Side resident Bill Porter. “You can’t replace the automobile with the bicycle,” he said. “The real problem is the lack of affordable parking. If you get indoor parking that can be afforded for $100 or a couple hundred dollars a month. If you try to put your car in a garage out here, it’s incredibly pricy. It’s a real high-profit industry. So what you need to do is you need to pass legislation forcing developers to provide affordable parking.”

Of course, “affordable parking” comes at the expense of affordable housing.

Carroll Gardens vs. Carroll Gardens (1:02)

Dennis Sciria, who started an online petition called “Say No to Citi Bike,” told the audience that he wasn’t entirely opposed to the program, but that his family needed his car — and a spot to park it in. “I have two young children. I need a car. I need to get around. I need to pick them up and go shopping,” said Sciria, who said he walks to work in Brooklyn Heights from his home in Carroll Gardens.

Immediately after Sciria, 32-year Carroll Gardens resident Dan Ross stood up to defend the program. “Not all of the longtime residents of Carroll Gardens are opposed to Citi Bike,” Ross said. “I’ve been parking on the street in Carroll Gardens for 30 years. It was hard 30 years ago, it was hard before Citi Bike, it’s still hard. Personally, I don’t think [Citi Bike]’s made much of a difference.”

The old timer thrilled at Citi Bike’s arrival (1:24)

While many of the bike-share opponents were self-described “old timers” whose families have lived in the area for decades, Lori Chaumont, who moved to Cobble Hill in the mid-1960s, told the room she was thrilled that Citi Bike had finally come to the neighborhood. Chaumont, who nows lives in Park Slope, said she had hoped it would come in time for her to bike to work in Crown Heights. “I’m now retired, so I can’t ride it to Crown Heights, but I have grandchildren in Cobble Hill, so I go back and forth between Park Slope and Cobble Hill on the bike very often,” she said.

  • Geck

    Here is a twist on the Citibike and parking. Citibike makes it easier to park because you can find parking further from home and use Citibike to get to and from your parked car. I’ve done it.

  • fdtutf

    That Upper West Sider who drives to visit his friends in Brooklyn (13:00)

    If only New York had a usable public transportation system that connected the Upper West Side and Brooklyn!

    I know, I’m a dreamer.

  • Eric McClure

    In defense of the UWS Jeep-driving guy, it sounded like he helps out with repairs and carts around tools, etc. But yeah. There’s probably a metered spot nearby in which he can park.

  • jeremy

    Now we need PROTECTED bike routes all over Brooklyn

    5 Million people in Brooklyn, and we barely have any.

  • JudenChino


    He keeps a car on the UWS and advocates for subsidized car parking.

  • JudenChino

    Baby steps. We’ve finally #FixedJaySt Isn’t it great. From this morning: https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/2312358d010e9150b1e14b0672ab4e074ad9f36862b80649212c50321b6884bb.png

    Also, for what it’s worth, still saw at least 3 or 4 parents taking their kids on bike, in the rain, this morning. All this White Whine about parking parking parking — and yet, these parents are able to figure it out WITH KIDS!

  • c2check

    I love that folks think you need to own a car to get around in NYC, which has the best taxi/car service available of any city in the US.

    Also it’s interesting to see folks acknowledging parking is and always has been difficult; as well as folks getting flustered when the high real cost of car storage is made more obvious. Yes, that is how much it costs to build and maintain a parking structure. It ain’t cheap.
    And of course, providing more parking may well lead to more traffic congestion, too.

  • c2check

    This is a “protected” bike lane;
    the NYPD is actively “protecting and serving”

  • JudenChino

    Also useful for zipcar. That condo monstrosity (which I looked at as a rental) on 4th and 12th has a Zipcar lot in its basement and a citibike station. When I need to do a day trip, I can just ride down to there.

  • jeremy

    “I have two young children. I need a car. I need to get around. I need to pick them up and go shopping”
    Too many I’s in a just a few words. Just shows how self centered these people are

  • “The real problem is the lack of affordable parking. If you get indoor parking that can be afforded for $100 or a couple hundred dollars a month.”

    Funny how this logic of “But it’s expensive!” never extends to car ownership itself. Do these people get that a lot of people don’t own cars because they can’t afford one or, even if they can, don’t want to waste the money?

    I really hope that at the end off all this no stations are relocated to sidewalks. Pedestrian space ought to be sacred, and many of the existing stations are already on sidewalks precisely because it allowed DOT/Citi Bike to avoid “taking” too many parking spaces in the first place. Putting stations on sidewalks to get back 10 – 20 parking spaces would be a big FU to pedestrians and to the many compromises that already went into this long planning process.

  • I do this all the time now. It makes picking up and returning a ZipCar so much easier, and also allows me to cast a wider net when looking for better prices on a rental.

  • Vooch

    take citibike fo ones parked Car ? Brilliant !!!!!!

  • Chris Mcnally

    A perfect use case for an electric bike

  • HamTech87

    More reason for pricing parking, so this guy can find a spot.

  • HamTech87

    Has the City considered creating dedicated ZipCar spots on more blocks? Didn’t Hoboken do this?

  • JK

    Somehow they managed to put Citibike Stations all over Manhattan’s UWS, which is far, far denser than Park Slope. You think nobody there wants a free curb spot for their car?

  • Yes. Hoboken had [has?] a thing called “corner cars,” which is on-street reserved spots for car sharing vehicles.


    If I remember correctly from when I was there last, it also had a safety component in that the cars were parked in the last spot away from the crosswalk, leaving enough space for visibility for pedestrians.

    Compare to NYC, where giant SUVs and even trucks can be parked right up to the edge of the crosswalk, making it hard for people on foot and in cars to see each other.

  • qrt145

    “some stations getting as much as seven rides per dock each day”

    According to the source, these were seven “events” (docking or undocking a bike), not rides. An event should be counted as half a ride.

    This is still a much better usage of curb space than car storage, though.

  • SSkate

    My local assemblyman has complained about the parking space issue. Which is weird because the only Citibike station within 4 blocks of where he lives is a sidewalk station.

  • kevd

    when a single free parking space, anywhere is lost, all cars suffer..

  • kevd

    I used to do this with a car – ride to car, put the bike in the trunk – find a new spot (street cleaning), then ride home.
    Made is so much easier, because I would park places other people didn’t want to, because they were somewhat more isolated.

  • Eric McClure


  • Eric McClure

    Yes. His call for the city to provide cheap off-street parking in a neighborhood in which property sells for $1,000 a square foot was particularly ironic. I was just pointing out that he said he hauled around equipment; for social calls, I would highly recommend taking transit.

  • Larry Littlefield

    If they do so, don’t rent to one of the three oligopoly companies that have taken the price of rental cars in Brooklyn to the moon.

  • Kevin Love

    Protecting and serving themselves.

  • Eric McClure

    Front edge or back edge of the crosswalk?

    Also, Paris has a city-run electric car-share program.

  • qrt145

    Obviously, this poor innocent driver was forced to park on the crosswalk because those darn Citi Bikes took his spot!

  • kevd

    how many million???

  • Nathan Rosenquist

    No, they do not get that. For them car ownership is the default, and it always has been, and that money was already spent before they ever even earned it. Ignoring the astronomical price of a car is a big part of how Americans were hoodwinked into believing that cars are essential.

    I wouldn’t worry about DOT listening to the ridiculous demands that these docks be pushed off onto pedestrians. Citibike docks require a sidewalk to be at least 16 feet wide to allow egress, DOT just won’t do it otherwise, and Park Slope sidewalks are too narrow.

  • Nathan Rosenquist

    Oh this was from your submission to CIBL. Let me know if I got it right, I think I pieced together all the fields correctly from your three separate uploads 😛

  • Nathan Rosenquist

    Yup that’s how you sell residential parking permits, too.

  • com63

    I was amazed at how few people spoke of the obvious solution to the problem which is pricing on street parking. Some people really do need their cars and would be happy to pay for a permit. Other people do not need their cars and would get rid of them if they had to pay to park every day.

  • JudenChino

    Yes, but the plate number is 9355 14 – I can e-mail you a better photo later. Do you have an e-mail submission?

  • JudenChino
  • JudenChino

    I live in NYC precisely so I don’t have to own a car. Like, am I supposed to drive to FiDi every morning and take an hour to get 5 miles that takes me 30 mins on bike? or between 25 and 45 minutes via train?

  • Miles Bader

    There should be a law that no property-protection laws apply to cars parked in crosswalks (or on sidewalks): You can key them, break into them and take everything inside, take a giant saw and saw them in half, whatever, no legal repercussions. Open season.

  • Nathan Rosenquist

    Thanks, updated the -01 ending to -14: http://www.carsinbikelanes.nyc/index.php?id=1137 (I prefer this image since it show’s the car’s tires sitting right on the green paint).

    I prefer uploads to come through the form on the website, but if you email carsinbikelanesnyc@gmail.com with minimum relevant info (plate, date/time, state, location, and photo) I can certainly add it manually.

  • Reggie

    I heard something recently that makes me believe San Francisco has dedicated parking for its car-share company.

  • Jeffrey Baker

    There are a couple hundred on-street spaces used by City Car Share, Zipcar and Getaround in San Francisco, and a handful in Oakland, too.

  • sammy davis jr jr

    The typical UWS Street or sidewalk is wider than those in Park Slope. The point, in any case, is that more density means less room for curbside parking. A row of parked cars is essentially a traffic lane that doesn’t ever move.


Tell CB 6 and Mayor de Blasio That Bike-Share Belongs on Brooklyn Streets

Citibike is really cramping the parking spaces of the Park Slope working classes #bikenyc pic.twitter.com/0VJmE9KFK9 — Michael Pick (@mikepick) September 18, 2016 Last week a bunch of people showed up at a Brooklyn Community Board 6 meeting to complain about Citi Bike, which has recently expanded into Park Slope, Carroll Gardens, Cobble Hill, Gowanus, and Red Hook. […]

Bike-Share Already Getting More Use Than Park Slope’s Free Parking Spots

The new bike-share stations in Brooklyn south of Atlantic Avenue are getting a lot more use than your average free on-street parking space, according to recent Citi Bike data compiled by Carroll Gardens resident Viktor Geller [PDF]. Geller addressed the report to Brooklyn Community Board 6, which is holding a hearing on Thursday in response to complaints about bike-share stations […]

A Handful of Car Spaces, or a 27-Dock Citi Bike Station?

Because a construction site is blocking the sidewalk on Kent Avenue in Williamsburg, a Citi Bike station was taken off the sidewalk in mid-April and re-installed along the protected bike lane on the other side of South 11th Street a couple of weeks ago, replacing a handful of parking spaces. The new site was the only […]

As Jersey City and Hoboken Fight Over Bike-Share, Everyone Loses

A dispute between Hoboken and Jersey City is making the decision to operate separate bike-share systems in each city look even worse. In late 2013, the two cities — along with neighboring Weehawken — announced plans for a combined bike-share system, called Hudson Bike Share. At first Hudson Bike Share was envisioned as a “smart lock” system that allows […]