City Council Passes Several Bills to Reduce Reckless Driving

Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito and other reps before today's meeting. Photo: ##
Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito and other reps before today’s meeting. Photo: ##

The City Council today passed a slate of bills and resolutions aimed at improving street safety.

The 11 bills — outlined in detail here — include Intro 238, which would make it a misdemeanor for a driver to “make contact” with a pedestrian or cyclist who has the right of way, punishable by up to $500 in fines and 30 days in jail; and Intro 171, known as “Cooper’s Law,” which would suspend or revoke TLC licenses of cab drivers who are summonsed or convicted, respectively, of traffic violations stemming from crashes that result in critical injury or death.

Council Member Mark Weprin, of Queens, cast the lone vote against Intro 171. Weprin said the bill comes too close to creating a strict liability standard — which, according to attorney and traffic law expert Steve Vaccaro, is exactly what New York State needs to reduce deaths and injuries. Weprin said he fears the law would punish some unfairly — that a driver’s career shouldn’t end because of one incident, and that a cabbie who rolls through a stop sign and causes a crash should not necessarily be subject to the same penalties as one who crashes while speeding. (The cab driver who killed Cooper Stock failed to yield and had an otherwise clean record.) “This is the livelihood of these drivers,” said Weprin. Council Members Vincent Gentile and Jumaane Williams abstained from voting on the bill.

Other bills would combine points issued by the state DMV and the TLC against hack licenses and set new TLC license suspension and revocation standards; require the TLC to review and report on cab driver crashes and subsequent disciplinary actions; codify the number of Slow Zones DOT implements each year; codify DOT work zone safety standards; require DOT to study the safety of arterial streets, study safety issues pertaining to left turns by motorists, and inspect and/or repair broken traffic signals within 24 hours; and prohibit “stunt behavior” by motorcyclists.

The bill to require the TLC to institute a one-year pilot program for “black box” technology to record and report taxi driver behavior was not on today’s agenda. TLC Commissioner Meera Joshi told the transportation committee in April that the agency has issued RFIs for the program, but she made no mention of the pilot in budget testimony before the council earlier this month.

One bill in the transportation committee hopper not taken up today would mandate side guards for trucks to help prevent people from being swept beneath them. DOT asked that the council hold off on legislating truck guards in lieu of a pending study already underway within the department.

The council approved resolutions asking Albany to grant the city control over speed and red light cameras, increase the penalty for driving on a sidewalk to $250 and three license points, make it a misdemeanor to violate the state’s vulnerable user law, increase the penalty for reckless driving that results in death or serious injury, and pass extant bills to increase penalties for leaving the scene of a crash.

Also today:

  • While voting in favor of all traffic safety bills, Council Member Andy King of the Bronx said that, as a motorist, he looked forward to seeing the city “hold pedestrians accountable for texting and walking.” Texting while walking is completely legal in NYC, and most pedestrian-involved crashes are caused by drivers breaking the law.
  • Council Member Robert Cornegy lamented the “contentious effort” to bring a Slow Zone to Bedford-Stuyvesant, which he seemed to blame on DOT. Cornegy, who recently said he believes Select Bus Service and wider sidewalks impede commercial foot traffic, expressed skepticism of the community-driven Slow Zone process and DOT data.
  • Council Member Laurie Cumbo of Brooklyn voted against the “stunt riding” bill, as she believed it would impose on “motorcycle culture,” and would lead to young people being arrested. The bill was intended to address behavior of dirt bike riders who take over streets, and even sidewalks, in NYC neighborhoods, particularly in Upper Manhattan, every year during warm weather months, and was proposed after a confrontation between motorcyclists and a family in an SUV resulted in serious injuries.

Streetsblog will have more on these new laws, and their impact on street safety in NYC, in the coming weeks.

  • bolwerk

    Any alternative to my “assumption” would have to assume malice or indifference on Weprin’s part. So if you think my assumption is off, you’re being less generous than I!

    I’m not knocking his intentions, but he really seems to live in the past in a lot of ways. This idea that buses (or any transit) is going to, by itself, get cars off the streets? Not particularly efficacious. (That doesn’t make the transit a bad idea, but by itself it probably doesn’t do much or anything to calm traffic.)

  • Aunt Bike

    The above quote from Mr. Matteo makes me suspect he’s more concerned with the fact that the city is collecting revenue than he is about slowing the speeders down.

  • Aunt Bike

    The bill as I read it says the DOT will be required “to post signs at intersections where speed cameras are located”.|Text|&Search=speed+cameras

    I think they’ll be worse than useless, I think they’ll make more trouble…the signs will warn drivers where they can’t speed…an absence of signs will tell them when they can.

  • lop

    ‘At any location where one or more photo speed violation monitoring system is in effect, the department shall place one or more signs, visible to traffic approaching from all directions, to warn drivers that such a system is in operation at such location.’

    Cameras are expensive. They’re often only monitoring one direction on one road at an intersection. This puts up signs for every direction even if only one is monitored at least. And if drivers slow down whenever they see these signs and so the cameras don’t make much money, it might not be as bad as you think. Showing that enforcement cuts speeding and doesn’t bring the city much money might take some of the wind out of the argument that traffic enforcement is just a revenue grab. And since the cameras would still be likely to cover their costs, extensive deployments would be possible.

    Though ideally this bill would be modified to say the sign should say it may be a monitored intersection, not that it is one, and make explicit that DOT can put those signs on any street, not just photo enforced school slow zones.

  • Aunt Bike

    Not sure if anything like that is going to placate camera opponents. But what the heck, hopefully Matteo’s bill will waste away in committee like Vincent Ignizio’s bill to warn red light runners.

  • Kevin Love

    Mr. Weprin appears to not understand the concept of induced demand. In reality, there are really only two ways to “get cars off the streets.”

    There is the carrot of making walking, cycling or public transit the fastest, easiest and most convenient way of getting from A to B. Then there are sticks ranging from congestion charges to making streets car-free.

  • San Jose Airport taxi

    Wow Buddy Thats Call The Real Blog This Blog Is The Gold Mine i like your blog and also services i give you 5* for your services 🙂

  • bolwerk

    Yes, this. Braess’s paradox too.

    It may be well-meaning, but when politicians treat transit as a traffic reduction tool they implicitly treating transit as something that should cater to drivers. This, in turn, makes transit suck for vast majority of people who are not trying to replace a car trip.


De Blasio Signs 11 Traffic Safety Bills

Mayor Bill de Blasio signed 11 bills today intended to make it safer to walk, bike, and drive in New York City. De Blasio was joined by in Queens this morning by Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg, NYPD Chief of Transportation Thomas Chan, City Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito, council transportation chair Ydanis Rodriguez, and other council members. Bills signed […]

City Council Hard at Work on Pro-Parking Bills

Maria Baez wants all teachers to hit the road. Transit-riding New Yorkers, take heart. In these tough times, your City Council members are at this moment pushing a slew of bills that will make your lives easier. All you have to do is trade your MetroCard for a set of car keys. In December and […]

Council Bill Would Fine Drivers for Leaving the Scene of a Crash

Council Members Jimmy Van Bramer and Ydanis Rodriguez have introduced a bill that would impose civil penalties for hit-and-run crashes. Intro 371 would attach escalating fines, based on injury severity, for violating Section 600 of the state traffic code, which deals with leaving the scene. Fines would begin at “not more than” $250 for drivers […]