Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In

A recent post on Vox went viral with the argument that cyclists shouldn't have to make full stops at stop signs and should be allowed to proceed through red lights "Idaho stop"-style.

Image via Copenhagenize
Image via Copenhagenize
false

The author, Joseph Stromberg, gave a lot of compelling reasons why cyclists shouldn't be forced to strictly adhere to rules that were designed for people driving cars. That got veteran engineer Chuck Marohn at Strong Towns thinking. As someone who's designed streets for a living, he has plenty of insight into why the "same road, same rules" mentality falls short:

Stop signs weren’t designed for cyclists. In fact, very little of our built environment was designed with cyclists in mind. What we have done -- as I pointed out way back with the video on the diverging diamond -- is developed a tolerance for cyclists, and that only with some heroic effort. Engineers now generally accept cyclists and have even created checklists to help us accommodate them -- at least the skilled ones -- at a minimal level in our current transportation system. Tolerating cyclists, and sometimes even attempting to accommodate them, is a far cry from designing systems based on their needs...

For those of you that believe automobile traffic laws should apply to cyclists, my first reaction is (and please don’t be offended because, granted, this is a broad brush): do you ever bike? Do you bike in traffic? In the United States? Perhaps you do. I admit that I didn’t until the last few years, but doing so opened up my eyes to a new set of challenges and changed a lot of my beliefs on cycling in urban areas.

As an engineer and a planner, I had designed a number of cycling facilities, but I really hadn’t used them. At least not regularly. So, a few years ago I decided to start biking to work. I couldn’t do it during the school year or when I needed to pick up my kids, but on the days that I could, I would bike the 12 miles each way to and from the office. I could take back roads for the first eight miles or so, but the last bit was on nasty stroads in high traffic areas where I experienced a rational human response: fear...

We need to rethink our urban areas. They need to be redesigned around a new set of values, one that doesn’t seek to accommodate bikers and pedestrians within an auto-dominated environment but instead does the opposite: accommodates automobiles in an environment dominated by people. It is people that create value. It is people that build wealth. It is in prioritizing their needs -- whether on foot, on a bike or in a wheelchair -- that we will begin to change the financial health of our cities and truly make them strong towns.

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Political Environment reports that a lawsuit against Wisconsin DOT has yielded a settlement that will provide $13.5 million for transit service during construction of a massive Milwaukee highway project. Streets.mn discusses colleges' natural orientation toward urbanism. And Steve Patterson at Urban Review STL explains why he's voting "no" on Missouri's proposed transportation sales tax hike.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Adams Considering Letting Midtown Business Group Issue Parking Tickets So NYPD Can Tackle ‘More Serious Issues’

The Department of Finance retracted its proposal to allow the 34th Street Partnership to be the first business improvement district empowered to enforce city parking rules after we started asking about it.

December 5, 2024

Could ChatGPT Make America More Walkable?

No, generative AI shouldn't plan a whole city — but a new study argues it could help identify gaps in our sidewalk networks, tree canopies, and more.

December 5, 2024

Thursday’s Headlines: The Case of the Misidentified Getaway Bike Edition

Wednesday's wall-to-wall coverage of a Midtown assassination had a small transportation angle. Plus more news.

December 5, 2024

City Scales Back Hugely Popular Fifth Ave. Holiday Open Street Despite Sales Boosts

Mayor Adams is the Grinch who stole his own car-free Christmas shopping spree!

December 4, 2024

The ‘Instacart Loophole’: Council Seeks To Expand Minimum Wage to Grocery Deliveristas

City pols want to close a loophole that is allowing grocery delivery app companies like Instacart to get around paying their workers the deliverista minimum.

December 4, 2024
See all posts