On Bike-Share Opening Day, the Post Wears Its Rotten Heart on Its Sleeve

The New York Post screams of "ruin" on bike-share launch day; the New Yorker, obviously, took a different tack.

This morning’s headline stack was full of attempts by the New York Post to pour cold water on today’s bike-share launch. The tabloid is so committed to its cause, it plastered it on its front cover, just below the day’s most important celebrity gossip.

Like the rest of the NYC press corps, the Post is covering today’s launch. I was interviewing bike-share users at Fulton Street and Hudson Avenue in Brooklyn at about 10:45 a.m. when Post reporter Julia Marsh stopped her car in the travel lane and hopped out to do an interview. Once she realized she wasn’t going to get a story there, she got back in her vehicle and sped off, engaging in a honking match with a motorist who was trying to pass her.

The New Yorker, meanwhile, offered some food for thought on physical activity and urban space. As illustrator Marcellus Hall explained in the magazine, “I’m not one of those hard-core bike freaks; it’s just a good way for me to get around in the city.”

  • Joe R.

    I think what says it all here is the fact that the NY Post considers the latest celebrity meltdown front page news. With priorities like this, it’s hard to take anything they write as serious journalism.

  • wait they are a new paper? I thought it was just the paper version of TMZ cross with a tea party newsletter.

  • Anonymous

    People take what they say seriously? When did this happen?

  • Peter

    Care to comment on the actual substance of the Post’s article – that a Citibike rack was place right outside of Frank’s bike shop! What a slap in the face to a long time local business and cycling advocate!

  • Bike salesman

    Actually it’s great exposure for his business. He should capitalize on it.

  • Guest

    So true!

  • Guest

    How ridiculous! The store owner knows what’s good for his business – not you!

  • Peter

    thats pretty silly

  • Bike share is a great way to get people who are not ready to spend $500 on a bike to discover that hey… this isn’t so bad to bike in NYC.

    When my mom started riding she first rented then, she slowly thought “hmm I could buy my own bike”

    I think there will be something of a symbiotic relationship.

    And let’s face it it’s not a replacement for day rentals even (which are less expensive) or for owning a bike by far.

    You can’t do five-boro on a citi bike, or a long commute–

    And they are clunkers– nothing like a bike that fits your body!

  • Ian Turner
  • Larry Littlefield

    His problem is the rack is not directly in front of his shop. That’s what I would want if I owned a bike shop.

    He needs to put out a sign saying now you can try getting around by bicycle for just $95 for a year, and can get your helmet and other accessories here!

    And then in a year put out another sign. Now that you’ve tried Citibike for a year, how about getting a bike of your own right here!

    Ask yourself this question. How many bike shops did the Post contact before coming up with one owner who thought it might be a negative?

  • Ridgewoodian

    The POST’s article is dishonest. It mentions that he rents bikes to tourists for $30 a day (which I assume is correct) but that the CitiBike 24 hour pass will be $10. Well, okay, but what they don’t mention is that that $10 only gets you half an hour for free. If you ride it for another half hour and don’t swap it out for a new one it’s going to be another $4, or $14 total. If you ride for another half hour hour it’s going to be another $13 – so after a 90 minute ride (which isn’t all that long), if you haven’t been swapping bikes, you’re already up to $27. At 91 minutes it’s already cheaper to rent for the day from Frank. Also, I assume that his bikes are a little less clunky and a little more fun to ride longer distances. CitiBike is like a cab, it only exists to get you from point A to point B. And, although I found it enjoyable enough to ride, that’s not its point. CitiBikes and Frank’s bikes are both bikes but that’s where their similarity end. They serve different purposes. So all Frank has to do is communicate this – you know, be a salesman – and I bet he does just fine.

  • ADN

    Sure, Peter, I’ll comment on the “substance” of the article. As has been reported in other cities with bike-share programs: It’s great for local bike shops. People spend money on helmets and accessories, they learn to ride a bicycle in the city and they buy their own bikes. Bike-share creates new cyclists. If you have to take your personal bike into the shop for repairs and leave it over night, it’s great to have a bike-share station right next door. The Post easily could have found this out had they bothered to make phone calls to a couple of bike shops in, say, Boston, D.C., London or Paris. But that would have ruined their story, right?

  • Anonymous

    I’m sorry but while Frank himself is a good mechanic, he’s no thinker or much of a salesman, his other mechanics stink and in fact his shop now sucks eggs.

  • Zubair Khatri Soomro

    I found this much
    informative, as to what I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and
    please keep it up.


  • Zubair Khatri Soomro

    Hey what a
    brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out
    for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across

    back link

  • Zubair Khatri Soomro

    Thanks for a very
    interesting blog. What else may I get that kind of info written in such a
    perfect approach? I’ve a undertaking that I am simply now operating on, and I
    have been at the look out for such info

    car title loan in Los

  • Zubair Khatri Soomro

    I couldn’t find any
    knowledge on this matter prior to.Alsooperate a site and if you are ever
    interested in doing some.

    custom shopping bag

  • Zubair Khatri Soomro

    You definitely have
    some great insight and great stories.

    anti aging serum

  • Irfan Ali

    Keep doing what you
    are doing – can’r wait to read more posts.

    business SEO company


The 2013 NYC Streetsies, Part 1

The Streetsie votes are in and it’s time to hand out virtual hardware. But first, a friendly reminder that Streetsblog needs your support. Reader donations are what Streetsblog runs on. Contribute to our year-end pledge drive and you’ll help produce reporting and commentary that makes a difference, so that when this time rolls around next year, […]

Sadik-Khan, Wolfson Invite New Yorkers to Sign Up for Bike-Share

In 2009, the Department of City Planning released an ambitious blueprint for bike-share in New York, and in 2011, the Department of Transportation began an extensive public process to site actual bike-share stations. Now the planning is giving way to implementation, with North America’s largest year-round bike-share system set to launch in May. Today, Transportation Commissioner Janette […]

How the Post Engineers Bike-Share Bashing, Facts Be Damned

It took a few days, but the Post found someone to go along with its bike-scare nonsense, according to the Post. Here’s the latest: “The bike racks present challenges to firefighters and frankly, trying to get around the city now is harder than ever before,” Uniformed Firefighters Association President Steve Cassidy said at a press […]