Leroy Comrie Bill Would Force NYPD to Report to Council on Hit-and-Runs

Queens City Council Member Leroy Comrie is set to introduce a bill that may have an impact on how NYPD approaches hit-and-run crashes, which kill dozens of NYC pedestrians and cyclists a year.

Leroy Comrie. Photo: ##http://observer.com/2010/06/leroy-comrie-the-sheriff-of-land-use/##Observer##

A statement from Comrie’s office says the bill would require NYPD to report to the council annually on “hit and run incidents that result in a fatality or severe injury with a description of all actions that were taken to determine who was responsible.” Comrie also plans to introduce a resolution “calling for the NYPD to include the mandatory collection of video surveillance from cameras within the vicinity of a hit-and-run accident that results in a fatality or severe injury.”

At least 37 pedestrians and cyclists have been killed by hit-and-run drivers in NYC since January 2012, according to crash data compiled by Streetsblog. The vast majority of drivers involved in those crashes were not immediately caught or identified.

A loophole in state law gives motorists who have been drinking an incentive to flee the scene of a crash, and many hit-and-run cases are closed when a driver says he or she did not see the victim.

Even when a perpetrator is identified and arrested, state laws make it difficult to bring a hit-and-run driver to justice. A felony charge of leaving the scene of an incident resulting in death requires prosecutors to prove that a motorist knew or had reason to know injury had been caused — a burden that can be insurmountable.

We’ve asked Comrie’s staff how the bill and resolution will define “severe injury.” The new NYPD protocol, announced earlier this year, is intended to trigger investigations of incidents involving critical injury, a standard that excludes many crashes.

Technically, Comrie’s bill won’t make it easier to prosecute hit-and-runs. And the council has said it can’t compel NYPD to change the way it conducts crash investigations, though the department’s procedures are said to be in violation of state law. But by requiring NYPD to account for the way it handles hit-and-run crashes, it’s possible those investigations will improve. If nothing else, Comrie’s bill, if adopted, may draw attention to hit-and-run crashes and their many victims.

Comrie voted in favor of the proposed NYC speed camera demonstration program, now stalled in the state legislature, and is a supporter of red light cameras. He is scheduled to announce the hit-and-run bill and resolution this afternoon in Cambria Heights, at an intersection where a motorist was killed in a high-speed crash in 2012.

  • I give this proposal 2 and 3/4 cheers.
    Last I checked, hit and run crashes were illegal, whether there was a fatality, serious or minor injury or simply left with property damage.

    If the Council is going to bother asking the NYPD for data on hit and run crashes, why not ask for ALL the data. Or at least give the NYPD the greater opportunity to stonewall over releasing any of the data. The article already concedes that releasing the fatal and severe crash data probably won’t directly increase the arrest and conviction rate, but adding all the other reported hit and run crashes ought to shine even more light on the failings of the police, DMV, DAs and court system.

  • cmu

    >A felony charge of leaving the scene of an incident resulting in death requires prosecutors to prove that a motorist knew or had reason to know injury had been caused

    And one wonders why the legal system is such a stupid charade. What about the *presumption* of causing injury when a 2-ton vehicle hits a human? The driver should *assume* injury was caused and by leaving the scene, he’s culpable of illegality.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Council Overrides Bloomberg Veto of NYPD Hit-and-Run Transparency Bill

By Brad Aaron |
The City Council today voted to override a number of vetoes handed down by former Mayor Bloomberg. According to the Staten Island Advance, among the bills passed was Intro 1055, which requires NYPD to release information on hit-and-run crashes and investigations. The bill mandates that NYPD report quarterly on the total number of “critical injury” hit-and-run […]

Council Transpo Committee Passes NYPD Hit-and-Run Transparency Bill

By Brad Aaron and Stephen Miller |
The City Council transportation committee passed a bill today that would require NYPD to issue quarterly reports on hit-and-run crashes and investigations. Originally, Intro 1055 would have had NYPD report to the council every two years on hit-and-runs resulting in serious injury or death. The language of the bill was tightened after sponsor Leroy Comrie and other committee members […]

First Up for Ydanis Rodriguez: Override of NYPD Hit-and-Run Data Veto

By Stephen Miller |
Today’s transportation committee meeting, the first chaired by Council Member Ydanis Rodriguez, was short and sweet. The new chair opened with a statement outlining his goals for the 13-member committee, which minutes later unanimously passed an override of Mayor Bloomberg’s veto of a bill that would give the council more information about NYPD’s hit-and-run investigations. […]