A Smart Growth Wake-Up Call for NIMBY-Plagued Long Island

Last week, a report from the Long Island Index outlined how rail service can guide economic growth, and it also contained warnings about the slow pace of construction for transit-oriented development in the region. If transit stations are to become focal points for growth, the authors argued, Long Island’s governments need to start taking action.

Ridership growth on LIRR has lagged behind NJ Transit and Metro-North. Image: ##http://www.longislandindex.org/explore/d33887f7-7cba-4430-b5bc-728d25dc3e83##Long Island Index##

While praising projects like East Side Access (which will connect LIRR trains to Grand Central) that are already underway, the report pointed to the need for two additional expansions — a second track from Farmingdale to Ronkonkoma and a third track on the LIRR Main Line between Floral Park and Hicksville — to keep the system from running up against capacity constraints that could lead to more driving.

Writing in the New York Times, Lawrence Downes picked up on the importance of moving beyond the NIMBYism that threatens to keep Long Island mired in cars-first suburbia. “It is an old suburb that ran out of places to sprawl,” he wrote. “It needs its vitality back.”

The Long Island Index report emphasized that, in order to jump-start its economy, Long Island must rebuild around its transit hubs. Initiatives are already planned for Ronkonkoma, Wyandanch, and a future station at Republic Airport, but there aren’t many shovels in the ground at this point.

This lethargy is also reflected in LIRR’s ridership numbers, which are growing more slowly than Metro-North and New Jersey Transit. On those systems, expansions such as Midtown Direct, Secaucus Junction, and a third track on the Harlem Line helped boost ridership and make the areas around stations more attractive for development.

The New York-Connecticut Sustainable Communities program is developing a blueprint for transit-oriented development in much of the region, and the report argues that local governance has to catch up. The parking lots and strip malls around Long Island’s train stations need more than viable transit service and continued planning. They also need local governments to move ahead with the zoning and infrastructure that enables walkable development.

Contrast the slow pace in the Long Island suburbs with what’s happening in Northern Virginia’s Tysons Corner, where planning and rezoning coupled with transit investment have primed a suburban hub for walkable growth. Long Island could undergo a similar evolution, if leaders don’t surrender the future to the NIMBY chorus.

  • Brandon B

    LIRR getting their costs under control would help too. Higher frequency and (especially) lower cost service would help make these TODs viable. The practical ability to use LIRR to get around Long Island between suburban downtowns hinges on running it more like rapid transit as well, rather than the idea that everyone is going to Penn Station (and soon, Grand Central).

  • HamTech87

    it is not just about getting its “vitality” back, but about not drowning — literally — when the next storm comes.

    Too often in New York, we don’t connect transportation projects (hello Governor, the Tappan Zee Bridge calling!) and climate change impacts.  Long Island just saw those connections big time.

  • JK

    How much are taxpayers spending on East Side Access?  It’s absurd that this massive expenditure to improve LIRR service isn’t being matched by even modest zoning and land-use changes on the LI end. How long will it take for ESA to create market forces around LIRR stops powerful to get through NIMBY?  Fifty years? Will it matter given rising oceans?

  • i agree that a inter-hub express bus service would make using transit within long island more feasible and promote or at least leave option for car-less travel within the island.  The Nassau bus system should have simple lines that go north-south connecting various stations. (there are a few but not many)  Each station should have a bus stop that eventually connects with another branch in the system.   I.e. the Oyster Bay branch (Oyster Bay having no buses to that city at all) should have a bus that connects to a station on the Huntington line and the Ronkonkoma line.  The South shore stations, say Rockville Center or Seaford should have buses that go north and connect to Ronkonkoma/Huntington etc.    Just on branch line failure along, this makes practical sense. 


    Agenda 21 baby.


Cuomo’s Long Island Growth Plan: More Trains and More Traffic

This morning, Governor Cuomo announced plans to move forward with the Long Island Railroad’s project for a third track on the main line between Floral Park and Hicksville in Nassau County. At the same time, Cuomo wants to study a car tunnel linking Long Island to either the Bronx, Westchester, or Connecticut. The LIRR project will […]
Long Island's bus and rail networks are run as two separate and unequal systems. Photo: Adam Moreira/Wikimedia Commons

On Long Island, Transit Operates as Two Separate and Unequal Systems

The Long Island Railroad is building some of the biggest infrastructure projects in the region -- even the world. The hugely expensive East Side Access tunnel and terminal at Grand Central and the construction of a third track for the LIRR Main Line will open up new possibilities for convenient, all-day transit that people can use for all types of trips. But not if Long Island continues to operate its rail and bus networks as a two-tiered transit system.

In New Report, RPA Reinforces Link Between Transit and Growth

Following yesterday’s Build for America launch and last night’s presidential debate, the Regional Plan Association released a major report today recommending an array of public transportation improvements for New York City and northern New Jersey, adding its name to the ever-growing list of orgs and officials calling for federal investment to spur and sustain economic […]

Inside the Rail Worker Disability Program That Never Says “No”

Independent auditors at the Government Accountability Office (GAO) have just released the results of their lengthy investigation of the Railroad Retirement Board, the federal agency that evaluates disability claims by commuter railroad workers — and has historically approved more than 99 percent of them. Photo: NYT The New York Times obtained an early copy of […]