New York Rightfully Takes Over Top Spot on Walk Score

New York's least walkable areas are in Staten Island and Eastern Queens, according to ##http://www.walkscore.com/NY/New_York##updated Walk Score data.##

Step aside, San Francisco!

Walk Score, the website that ranks locations, neighborhoods and cities based on the number of amenities within walking distance and the pedestrian-friendliness of the street network, has come out with its first new city rankings since 2008. Based on updated listings and new Census data, New York City has taken over the top spot from the former West Coast champ.

The gap between the top two cities is slight, however, only 0.4 points out of 100. So Walk Score is opening the question of who’s the most walkable up to the public. San Francisco is currently winning in the online balloting. We here at Streetsblog New York are unwilling to let that stand, however. Here’s why:

First, while Walk Score’s methodology is impressively constructed, the ultimate measure of walkability is the amount of walking. According to the Census, slightly more New Yorkers walked to work between 2005 and 2009 than San Franciscans. Far more rode transit, which usually includes a walk on either end of the trip.

Another metric that isn’t included in Walk Score’s calculations is pedestrian safety. New York City has a lower traffic fatality rate than San Francisco [PDF], with pedestrians representing a roughly equivalent share of fatalities in each city.

Finally, all the walkability in San Francisco just doesn’t add up to that much compared to New York City. The entire city has a population of 805,000. The population of Manhattan alone is roughly double that, and there’s not a single neighborhood on the island that doesn’t have a Walk Score high above San Francisco’s. Sure, Staten Island drags down New York’s walkability, but according to Wikipedia, it’s nine times more densely populated than San Mateo County, just south of San Francisco.

There’s a lot New York City should do to make it more walkable. But compared to any other big American city, it’s not even close.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

Is Charlotte the Least Walkable City in America?

|
Walk Score just released its annual list of the nation’s most walkable cities, and the top of the list generally looks like what you’d expect. New York, San Francisco, Boston, and Philadelphia took the top four spots, though our friends at Transit Miami did take strong exception to their hometown rating right up there in fifth place. All […]
STREETSBLOG USA

“Opportunity Score” Shows Best Places to Find a Job Without Owning a Car

|
Which places put economic opportunity within reach for residents who don’t own cars? There’s a new tool to evaluate housing locations according to the accessibility of jobs via transit and walking. Redfin, the company that runs Walk Score, today released “Opportunity Score,” which ranks millions of addresses across 350 cities based on the number of jobs within a 30-minute walk […]