Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Streetsblog

City Councilman Greets Philly’s Bike Progress With Anti-Bike Legislation

According to a recent report from the Philadelphia Bicycle Coalition, Philly is now the bike-commutingest big city in the U.S., with the most people riding to work per capita of any of the nation's ten largest cities.

false

Just weeks after the city's bike progress made headlines, a city councilman has introduced legislation that could bog down further bike projects in politics and bureaucracy. Councilman William Greenlee wants to make every new bike lane in Philadelphia subject to a City Council vote.

Network blog Plan Philly reports:

Requiring City Council approval of all new bike lanes is bad policy because: It will delay making our streets safer. Motorists, pedestrians and bicyclists have all benefited from the 46% reduction in serious car crashes on Spruce and Pine streets since the new bike lanes were installed. (While the cost to motorist convenience has been tiny: a 2 mph reduction in average speed.) No City Council approval is needed for new vehicular travel lanes, crosswalks or bus stops.

"We're #1 in big city bicycle commuting," said [Bike Coalition] Executive Director Alex Doty. "Do we really want to be #1 in bike lane bureaucracy?"

Why single out a cheap, healthy way to commute? The City's Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan has already gone through a public review process and been approved by the Planning Commission. When taking out a travel lane, the Streets Department already consults with the local civic associations. It doesn't allow the traffic engineers at the Streets Department to do their job. Bike lanes installed as pilot projects will require review by City Council before the Streets Department can move the lanes to another street if that is what is recommended by their traffic engineers.

Plan Philly is urging local residents to contact the City Council and voice their opposition to this bone-headed measure.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Charlottesville Tomorrow reports that the local metropolitan planning agency is discussing reviving a decade-old, $161 million bypass plan despite questions about whether it is still, or ever was, necessary. PubliCola pans the design for Seattle's new light rail station, which lacks mixed-use amenities and has been compared to an "airport terminal. And GreenCityBlueLake reports on an opposition campaign that has emerged in Cleveland after a casino developer proposed demolishing a historic downtown structure to make way for -- what else? -- parking.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Federal Drug Agents Seize New 10th Avenue Bike Lane

The Department of Transportation is letting the DEA effectively redesign a block that should have a protected bike lane.

September 24, 2025

Opinion: DOT’s Flatbush Plan Is A Model For Fast Buses in the Heart of Brooklyn

The DOT commissioner, plus two top transit advocates, weigh in on the city's bus rapid transit plan.

September 24, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: Look, You’re the Traffic Edition

Why don't French leaders take Le Subway (which is definitely NOT what French people call the subway)? Plus other news.

September 24, 2025

Talking Headways Podcast: Live from MARS To Change the ‘Crash First, Fix Later’ Mentality

Welcome to MARS: Modern Analytics for Roadway Safety. Let's talk about it in a special edition of the podcast.

September 24, 2025

‘Treated and Streeted’: How The City’s Safety Net Fails Homeless People in the Subway

The Big Apple’s $30-billion social safety net cannot reliably get a homeless person in psychiatric crisis out of the subway and into a hospital bed, a Streetsblog investigation has found.

September 23, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines: ‘Not In My Back Yard’? ‘Yes, In Your Back Yard’ Edition

Our editor-in-chief joins the expert panel at the popular Upright Citizens Brigade's political comedy roundtable on Wednesday night. Plus other news.

September 23, 2025
See all posts