Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Streetsblog

Debunking the Myth of Motorist Entitlement to Monopolize the Road

There's an old line among opponents of cycling and pedestrian infrastructure. It says road construction funds shouldn't be used to build bike lanes and sidewalks because cyclists and pedestrians don't contribute to the gasoline taxes that fund road construction.

gas_prices_060908_lg.jpgA bicyclist may be able to duck past high gas prices, but everyone pays for roads. Image: The Daily Green

Josh Cohen at Network blog Publicola is refuting that argument by examining the transportation budget in Seattle, where local gas taxes play only a small role in the overall picture.

The Seattle Department of Transportation’s 2009 annual reportbreaks down the agency’s $340.8 million budget by funding source. Thegas tax accounts for $13.4 million, or 4 percent of that total.  The full budget breakdown (in millions):

Grants & Other: $96.9 (29 percent)Debt: $77.4 (23 percent)Bridging the Gap (a property-tax levy passed by voters in 2007): $60.9 (18 percent)General Fund: $42.3 (12 percent)Reimbursables: $42 (12 percent)Gas Tax: $13.4 (4 percent)Cumulative Reserve Fund: $7.6 (2 percent)

The majority of those funds are paid for by taxes and fees levied on the general public, whether or not they own a car. It's a far cry from a system where drivers are carrying the full costs of roads.

Elsewhere on the Network, Bike Portland admires Boulder, Colorado's "Driven to Drive Less" program, encouraging the public to go carless one day per week; Seattle Transit Blog looks at the success of Tacoma, Washington's "Not on Our Bus" campaign, which seeks to make public transportation more pleasant by cracking down on unlawful or disruptive conduct on buses; and Car Free Baltimore explains why rush hour parking restrictions are bad for pedestrians.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Opinion: Weakening Injury Insurance Coverage for Cabbies Will Harm Victims of Road Violence

A victim of road violence talks about her experience with insufficient liability insurance coverage.

February 12, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: Congestion Pricing is Good for Business Edition

We hope President Trump is listening to New York's elite business community instead of to N.J. Gov. "Flail" Murphy as he decides congestion pricing's fate. Plus other news.

February 12, 2025

FDNY To Drivers: Please Stop Parking At Hydrants

Parking scofflaws turn a fire fatal. The public could help, if the Council would pass a bill creating citizen enforcement.

February 11, 2025

Who Benefits from Trump ‘Birthrate’ Funding Scheme? Wealthier, Whiter Drivers

This prioritization lacks evidence of how it will meet the memo’s stated purpose to “bolster the American economy and benefit the American people.”

February 11, 2025
See all posts