Memo to Goldsmith: To Balance NYC’s Transpo System, Make Cycling Safer

goldsmith_bloomberg.jpgDeputy Mayor Stephen Goldsmith and Mayor Bloomberg. Photo: Daily News

There’s a lot to like about Stephen Goldsmith’s answers during yesterday’s must-read interview with WNYC’s Andrea Bernstein. It’s clear that NYC’s new deputy mayor for operations has a passion for efficiency. He comes across as deeply attuned to the fact that we allocate much of our scarce street space in a grossly inefficient way — whether by giving motorists a free ride during the most congested times of day, or by letting space-hogging single occupant vehicles have the same priority as buses full of people.

Here’s a highlight from his take on Select Bus Service on the East Side:

I think the way we should look at this is how New Yorkers can move most
efficiently at the lowest cost, going where they want to go –- to shop, or
to entertainment, or to work. And express bus lanes are definitely an
important element of that. They are a way to move lots of people more
efficiently and less expensively than other ways. And to the extent
that we can shorten the travel times of those buses will be in
everybody’s best interests.

But Goldsmith is more tentative when it comes to another spatially efficient mode — the bicycle:

There are differences in opinion about bikes. The transportation
director is a very creative woman. She has lots of ideas and those
ideas make the city a very exciting place but many of those ideas are
also controversial and I think the program for bikes is a good one. I
also understand that those policies can literally and figuratively
collide with automobiles and transportation policy. I know the mayor is
interested in getting the balance right and so I salute a director who
has a lot of innovative ideas and also understand that we need to
balance those against the interests of others and see what happens.

Let’s assume that Goldsmith’s separation of bike policy from transportation policy is a rhetorical slip-up. (Later on, he gives Bernstein his thoughts on bike-share as a solution to a transportation problem: "A lot of New Yorkers travel short distances and if we can help them
travel short distances in a safe way then it should be considered but
it’s not without challenges.") Even so, it’s notable that the question of "balance" only seems to arise when the subject is bicycling.

"Balance" in this case makes sense mainly on a political level. (Goldsmith tells Bernstein that he and the mayor want to avoid "ancillary
byproduct problems" — read into that phrase what you will.) In terms of transportation policy and allocation of the street, bike improvements are attempts to restore balance and bust up the spatial monopoly of motorized modes. In Manhattan, especially north of 34th Street, there’s not much balance on wide avenues. On First and Second, where plans for separated bikeways face continued uncertainty uptown, there’s no protected space for cycling, even in neighborhoods that are demanding it.

Goldsmith doesn’t seem to be sold yet on the way bike infrastructure fits into a lean, efficient, low-cost transportation system. But the potential to promote cycling — improving public health and safety, reducing traffic, and putting less wear and tear on our roads — is substantial and cuts across every borough. According to a recent study from the Department of City Planning, most workers in Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island commute within the same borough — they’re not making long trips. But a majority of those workers arrive by car. (We’ll have more on that study soon.)

A robust commitment to cycling should be of a piece with Goldsmith’s commitment to use public resources efficiently. Better bikeways make sense for many of the same reasons that busways appeal to him. Thus, we present this re-mix:

I think the way we should look at this is how New Yorkers can move most
efficiently at the lowest cost, going where they want to go –- to shop, or
to entertainment, or to work. And safe, convenient bike routes are definitely an
important element of that. They are a way to move lots of people more
efficiently and less expensively than other ways. And to the extent
that we can improve the safety and convenience of those bike trips will be in
everybody’s best interests.


Getting to Know Stephen Goldsmith, NYC’s New Deputy Mayor

New York’s new deputy mayor for operations, Stephen Goldsmith. Photo: AP. As the new deputy mayor for operations, Stephen Goldsmith will soon be responsible for a portfolio of about a dozen city agencies, including NYCDOT, the NYPD, and the Office of Long-Term Planning and Sustainability. To a certain extent, the livable streets agenda will go […]

Stephen Goldsmith Out, Cas Holloway in as Deputy Mayor For Operations

Deputy Mayor Stephen Goldsmith has resigned as deputy mayor for operations, the mayor’s office announced today. Current Department of Environmental Protection Commissioner Cas Holloway will replace him. Goldsmith was brought in for the mayor’s third term with a charge to reinvent city government, particularly along the libertarian lines that he espoused as mayor of Indianapolis. […]

Parking May Be Part of PlaNYC Update, Tweets Goldsmith

Deputy Mayor Stephen Goldsmith dropped an intriguing hint this afternoon about the upcoming revision of New York City’s long-term sustainability plan. “We are looking at parking as part of @PlaNYC 2.0,” he tweeted. Now, there’s a lot that needs to happen between today and Earth Day 2011, when the update is due. “Looking at” parking […]

Cities Learn From Chicago Parking Meter Debacle. Did Goldsmith?

When Chicago Mayor Richard Daley announced that he was striking a deal to privatize his city’s 36,000 parking meters, it was a golden opportunity for transportation reform. If all went well, the deal could have cleared a political path for higher peak-hour meter rates, curbing double-parking and congestion-causing cruising. But Chicago managed to completely bungle […]

State of the City’s Transportation: Livery Cabs and Ferries

Mayor Bloomberg delivered his tenth State of the City address this afternoon, laying out what he believed to be the city’s accomplishments, challenges, and priorities for the future. And if the speech is any indication, taxis and ferries are at the top of his transportation agenda. Bloomberg’s plan to create a new class of taxi […]

Questions Linger About Bloomberg’s New Livery Van Service

Commuter vans, like this one in Sunset Park, could become a more common sight on New York’s streets. Image: The Brooklyn Ink. On Tuesday, Mayor Bloomberg announced a new pilot program to provide livery van service for transit-starved neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Queens, a proposal stemming from his 2009 campaign transit platform. The push to […]