Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

More Bad News for Transit Funding: Payroll Tax Comes Up Lame Again

The MTA's budget picture took another turn for the worse today. The payroll tax instituted as part of last year's funding package continues to raise far less revenue than expected. Which means that even if the extensive service cuts on the table take effect, the MTA will still have to deal with a $400 million deficit in 2010.

What's more, the MTA noted in a statement today that the payroll tax shortfall is probably a fact of life. The agency now projects revenue from the tax to come up $200 million short of what was predicted each year after 2010. In other words, the payroll tax just doesn't raise the money it was supposed to. And even that wasn't enough to shore up the MTA's finances in the first place.

The MTA must maintain a balanced budget, which leaves two options: increasing revenues or decreasing costs. The Daily News floats the possibility of fare hikes on top of next year's planned 7.5 percent increase, while noting that those fighting to overturn service cuts -- including the phasing out of student MetroCards -- now have a steeper hill to climb.

The current round of service cuts is painful enough. With transit funding absorbing body blows every few weeks, how long will riders have to wait before New York's elected leaders put more options on the table?

In yesterday's Huffington Post, John Petro of the Drum Major Institute laid out the stakes, arguing that congestion pricing "is the only option left to Albany and City Hall." Without it, Petro writes, "the cycle of short-term fix followed by financial crisis will continue, and there won't be much mass transit system to save anymore."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Streetsies 2025: The Best Projects of the Year

Even amid Mayor Adams's bikelash lame-duck era, there were some major bright spots this year.

December 24, 2025

Hey, Insurance Companies, Here’s Some Driver Fraud Hiding in Plain Sight

Insurers don't seem to care, but we've provided a list!

December 24, 2025

Streetsies 2025: The Biggest Failures Of The Year

2025 was rough year to be a cyclist in New York City, now's your chance to vote for what pissed you off the most.

December 24, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: See You In Court Edition

President Trump's case against congestion pricing will finally be heard next month. Plus other news.

December 24, 2025

Mamdani Appoints Pro-Labor Lawyer To Run Worker Protection Agency

"My life's work has been about ensuring that money and power cannot trample the rights and dignity of working people," said the incoming DCWP commissioner, Sam Levine.

December 23, 2025

Don’t Believe the Hype: NJ Turnpike Widening Still Happening

Gov. Murphy's late revision will just move the problem around, advocates say.

December 23, 2025
See all posts