Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Brooklyn

Killer DWI Cop’s Defense: Victim Shouldn’t Have Been Drinking and Walking

andrew_kelly.jpgAndrew Kelly. Photo: Daily News

The lawyer representing Andrew Kelly, the off-duty NYPD officer who last September killed pedestrian Vionique Valnord, then refused to submit to alcohol tests, has indicated that his line of defense will go something like this: The victim precipitated her own death by drinking at a wedding before my client ran her down on a Brooklyn street.

"There was alcohol in her system and witnesses at the wedding said she
was clearly, visibly intoxicated," said attorney Arthur Aidala at a hearing on Tuesday. "This goes to solidify the fact that
this was just a terrible accident."

Kelly himself was reported to be visibly intoxicated after hitting Valnord as she tried to hail a taxi. Yet in today's papers both the Post and Daily News point out that Valnord was legally too drunk to drive. Here's the News:

[Valnord] had a blood alcohol level of .22 - nearly three times the legal limitif she had been driving, according to the toxicology report.

Now the Post:

The minister's daughter run down and killed by an allegedly drunkoff-duty cop last fall was drunk herself, with a blood-alcoholpercentage more than three times the legal DWI limit, sources told ThePost.

The legal limit for driving is .08 percent.

Clearly the Post, at least, is on board with equating DWI and attempting to catch a cab after drinking: The victim's autopsy results, the Post says, "bolster" Kelly's claim that "it was Valnord who was to blame for the accident ... when she raced out into
the street mid-block with no warning."

Trifling as it may be, the fact is Valnord wasn't driving, and Kelly was. Said Valnord's sister Ruth Jean: "What does it matter she had something at a wedding if he's the one driving drunk."

Kelly's defense is not without precedent. Richard Anderson refused a Breathalyzer test after he struck and killed Florence Cioffi
in Manhattan two years ago this month, and was ultimately able to plea down to a sentence of 16 days in jail and 250 hours of community service. According to the News, Cioffi's lawyer suspected prosecutors backed down because Cioffi was intoxicated when she was hit.

Maybe Valnord could have avoided being put on trial herself by evading a blood alcohol analysis long enough to clear her system, as Kelly allegedly did. If only Kelly hadn't killed her first.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Amtrak’s Dithering Means Penn Access Won’t Be Done ‘Til 2030, MTA Says

Boom: The MTA's ambitious Penn Access project is delayed until 2030 at the earliest ... and Amtrak is to blame, says the MTA.

October 28, 2025

From Parking to Park: East Side Lot To Become Public Space

The East Side finally gets back some of its waterfront from cars.

October 28, 2025

Talking Headways Podcast: ‘Life After Cars’ With Doug Gordon and Saray Goodyear

Sarah Goodyear and Doug Gordon of The War on Cars podcast on their new book, opposing views, Turtle Jesus and potential off-ramps towards car-free cities.

October 28, 2025

Vision Zero Cities: How Istanbul Builds Subways Cheap — And What U.S. Cities Can Learn

Istanbul has expanded its subway network by more than 200 miles over the past three decades.

October 28, 2025

Tuesday’s Headines: Amtrak Agonistes Edition

The MTA is blaming the national rail system for delays on the Penn Access project. Plus other news.

October 28, 2025

Ugly Truth: Feds’ Canal Street Raid Pushed Aside NYPD, Safety and Free Speech

President Trump's heavily armed and masked immigration troops are turning American cities into battlegrounds — and eliminating accountability and free speech in the public realm.

October 27, 2025
See all posts