Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Car Culture

Tom Vanderbilt Dissects “The ‘E’ Word”

eword.jpgImage: Reclaim

In the latest issue of TA's Reclaim, "Traffic" author Tom Vanderbilt revisits the May New York Magazine profile of Janette Sadik-Khan, and its portrayal of projects like car-free Broadway as tributes to the city's oft-mythologized non-driving "elite."

Vanderbilt's piece, entitled "The 'E' Word," deconstructs what he considers one of the most "abused word[s] in contemporary political discourse."

A few facts -- "stubborn things," as Reagan called them -- are in order. The most obvious thing to note is that car drivers make up a verysmall portion of the commuter population -- 16.9 percent of travelersinto the proposed "congestion zone" of Manhattan, and that includestrucks. And as the New York City Independent Budget Office has found,those people who do drive into Manhattan have a median annual incomethat exceeds other commuters by some 28.6 percent. And yet it's thecyclists who are elite.

Council Member Liu complained that Sadik-Khan's job is not to be a"visionary." Rather it's to strike a "balance between all the entitiescompeting for street space." Well, let's think about that "balance"under the status quo so beloved by Liu. In regards to the Times Squareproject, the space under consideration currently hosts nearly seventimes as many pedestrians as vehicles. And yet how much space wasdevoted to those pedestrians? 11 percent.

Of course, what else but propaganda such as this would we expect from a publication produced by Transportation Alternatives -- the group that, according to one anonymous New York Mag source, "is literally writing
transportation policy in the city of New York -- unchecked."

Carry on, TA overlords. We look forward to future elitist measures like parking reform, car-free parks and, naturally, the ultimate prize of the ruling class: congestion pricing.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Live from New York (State), It’s Wednesday Night!

Hallelujah, congestion pricing now getting big laughs in Albany.

May 23, 2025

Friday Video: A Deep Dive on the Endless Debate Over Bike Helmets

Everything you need to know the next time someone asks you if you're "for" or "against" bike helmets.

May 23, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: John Mulaney, You Are Officially On Notice Edition

When did Netflix start airing community board meetings? Plus other news.

May 23, 2025

Assembly Member Ditches Her Car — and Discovers The Good Side of Albany

"I love Albany now," says the Greenpoint lawmaker, who ditched her car. Will others follow? Well, Gov. Hochul offered a start...

May 22, 2025

Public Demands Safer West Side Highway at Packed Workshop

Seemingly all in attendance agreed that the existing bike and pedestrian path isn't cutting it and ought to be expanded.

May 22, 2025
See all posts