Red Light Cam Expansion Gets All Clear From Gantt

red_light_reduction.jpgRed-light running "events" have declined dramatically where cameras have been installed. Source: NYCDOT.

New York City’s red light cam program is on track to expand by 50 percent, pending legislation currently winding through Albany. Since 1994, the city has run a red light camera "demonstration program" — with proven safety benefits — which has to be renewed this year to continue. The bill
would extend that program for five years and increase the number of
cameras from 100 to 150 (here’s the legalese).

Notably, Rochester Assemblymember David Gantt, who has consistently blocked automated enforcement measures from his position as chair of the transportation committee, signaled yesterday that he won’t stand in the way of this one, reports Gannett:

Gantt said Wednesday he will no longer object to the measure and sponsored legislation this week to let Rochester have the cameras, which take snapshots of vehicles that run red lights.

Gantt said he still has reservations about whether the cameras invade privacy and increase safety. But he said legislative leaders and Gov. David Paterson have been pushing for the measure, so Rochester should be included.

Gantt’s openness to new automated enforcement programs is welcome, but the fact that he still harbors reservations about safety benefits suggests he’s not keeping up with the growing body of research on the subject. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, in a report released last May, found that red light cameras yielded a 68 percent drop in the number of front-to-side collisions involving injuries. New York City’s own camera program has reduced red-light running at camera-equipped locations by as much as 72 percent. (Both stats are cited in this NYCDOT report [PDF].)

Automated enforcement also figures heavily in plans for Bus Rapid Transit in New York, since planners are counting on bus-mounted cams to help keep exclusive BRT lanes clear of private vehicles. Similar cameras in London have improved bus speeds significantly. The last time bus-cam legislation came up in Albany, civil liberties groups did not raise objections, but Gantt spiked the bill citing worries about Big Brother.

  • Seriously, after reading this I made a quick mental check that today was the 2nd, not 1st of the month.

  • Mike

    Guys, you posted this a day late.

  • It’s not just the safety it’s also letting BRT function properly. I mean how “rapid” is the bus going to be if there are cars in the bus lanes. People only obey traffic laws if they are enforced. If you don’t enforce a traffic law it’s like it’s not even there. This is why we need the cameras on the buses.

    I wonder of out letters and emails had any impact on Gantt? I hope so!

  • We need this on the traffic light of the corner of 7th Ave. and West 10th Street here in Greenwich Village where I live. This intersection has had regular collisions for decades and recently two fire engines collided. Fortunately nobody ever gets killed but there’s always a first time for everything, it’s a only a matter of time.

  • mk3

    Excellent. We also need speed limit enforcement, as well as general enforcement of safe driving practice (use of turn signal, for example). Finally, all non-emergency horn-blowing should be fined.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Gov’s Budget Would Beef Up Red Light Camera Program

By Ben Fried |
Red light cams have been proven to increase safety on New York City streets. Photo: mwilkie/Flickr Dig deep enough into Governor Paterson’s austerity budget and you’ll actually find a few pieces of good news. Case in point: One provision would allow New York to expand its red light camera program, currently limited to 100 cameras, […]

David Gantt, Longtime Foe of Red-Light Cams, Changes Tune

By Ben Fried |
One of Albany’s chief foes of automated traffic enforcement appears to have softened his opposition to red-light cameras, but allegations of patronage may taint his turnaround. For years, State Assembly Member David Gantt, a Rochester Democrat, has used his position as chair of the transportation committee to block the expansion of red-light cameras in New […]

Silver Gives Gantt Two More Years Atop Transpo Committee

By Ben Fried |
Sheldon Silver and David Gantt On Thursday, Sheldon Silver re-appointed Rochester’s David Gantt to chair the Assembly Transportation Committee (Excel spreadsheet via Daily Politics). Gantt is the chairman who engineered the defeat of bus lane enforcement cameras last June, when six co-sponsors of the bill wound up voting against it in his committee. With the […]

How David Gantt Sent Bus Cameras to Defeat in Albany

By Ben Fried |
After state lawmakers dealt a setback to the city's Bus Rapid Transit plans, Streetsblog looked into how Assembly transportation committee chairman David Gantt was able to bring down a bill that reportedly enjoyed majority support among his members and won approval in the New York City Council by a 40 to 7 vote.