Two Staten Island Pedestrians Killed in Four Days; One Driver Charged

Two pedestrians were killed by drivers in Staten Island in separate incidents last week. Despite indications that both deaths were caused by careless driving — one motorist struck an elderly man while making a left turn, the other jumped a curb and slammed into a man waiting for a bus — only the driver involved in the latter crash faces charges, according to reports.

On Thursday, as Nathan Pakow, 47, waited for a bus at the intersection of Seaview Avenue and Capodanno Boulevard in the Ocean Breeze area, an out-of-control car driven by 19-year-old Joseph Catrama came up onto the sidewalk, pinning Pakow against a metal pole. Pakow was later pronounced dead at Staten Island University Hospital.

Catrama, a licensed driver for a little over a month, was suspected of speeding at the time of the crash. Police initially let him go, but a short time later a charge of criminally negligent homicide was issued, and Catrama surrendered to authorities.

Last Monday, 84-year-old World War II veteran Howard Adrian was hit by an SUV driver turning left at the intersection of Burgher Avenue and Hylan Boulevard in Dongan Hills. Adrian died Monday evening. A quote from the driver seems to paint the victim as the culpable party.

About two dozen relatives crowded the waiting room of
Staten Island University Hospital’s Intensive Care Unit
in Ocean Breeze … some sobbing, others raging
against the driver who hit him.

That man, Michael Pierre of Castleton Corners, said he had
just pulled out of the parking lot of the TD Bank on the
corner; he made the left, he said, after the two cars ahead
of him started moving.

"He [Adrian] tried to rush, you know, to cross the
street," Pierre said.

No charges had been filed against Pierre as of last week, as Adrian’s relatives and neighbors continue to grapple with the most basic of questions.

Alex Harris, who lived in the apartment above Adrian on
Delaware Avenue, wondered why the driver didn’t stop
for Adrian as he crossed.

"Why wouldn’t you slow down? You’re not
speeding to make a left turn," he said.

  • This sort of thing happens all the time on Staten Island. To think, at one time, Staten Island was a rail based region, with individual communities and legitimate town centers. The borough is a perfect case study for the failure of auto based planning.

  • Saturday night I had drinks with a friend who works at the Brooklyn DA’s office. A discussion of other types of crimes evolved into one about the feasibility of bringing criminally negligent homicide charges in car-on-ped deaths where they’re warranted (talking about the Chinatown van tragedy as an example). The impression I was left with is that it’s a tremendously difficult charge to make stick, and that the various DA offices in NYC are all overworked and understaffed, and that they’re thus often not brought out of a desire to use resources efficiently rather than out of any sort of institutional tolerance towards unsafe driving.

  • Kaja Geis

    Doesn’t that mean that ‘unsafe driving’ (you mean criminally negligent homicide) is institutionally tolerated because making the charge stick is resource-inefficient?

    You’ve offered an explanation, but it’s hardly exculpatory. This is their job.

    I don’t get to not do things my clients pay me for because they’re too hard. I work fifty-five hours a week. If this government isn’t gonna do it, can I get a government that will?

  • I hear it’s tremendously difficult to make charges stick against the mafia too. I guess the DA’s office should just give up.

    Thanks for passing that info on, Josh.


In Memoriam

If anyone can put a stop to the suffering and death wrought by reckless New York City motorists, she will be a grieving mother. Time and again in 2013, parents were left to cope with incomprehensible loss at the hands of a driver abetted by a legal system that facilitates, if not condones, his negligence. […]

Slap on the Wrist for Staten Island Pedestrian Killer

Joseph Catrama, right, was speeding and ran a red light before killing Nathan Pakow as he waited for a bus in Ocean Breeze. Photos: Staten Island Advance Joseph Catrama, the 19-year-old driver whose out-of-control Hyundai struck and killed Nathan Pakow at a Staten Island bus stop last February, will serve no more than six months […]

In Memoriam

Each year, scores of pedestrians and cyclists die on New York City streets, while thousands are injured. Though the total number of road fatalities is trending down, those who get around the city on foot and by bike have seen their casualty rate rise. Incidents of vehicle-inflicted violence are so frequent that many go unreported […]

In Memoriam

When the book is written on the fight for traffic justice in New York City, an entire chapter might well be devoted to 2012. This was the year when Commissioner Ray Kelly’s NYPD revealed to the City Council that only a handful of officers are assigned to investigate serious traffic crashes. The public learned that, […]

The Weekly Carnage

The Weekly Carnage is a Friday round-up of motor vehicle mayhem across the metro region. For more on the origins and purpose of this column, please read About the Weekly Carnage. Fatal Crashes (6 Killed This Week, 155 This Year*, 15 Drivers Charged**) Brooklyn: Man Crushed to Death Changing Oil of SUV (AP) Staten Island: […]

The Weekly Carnage

  Fatal Crashes (15 Killed this week; 582 Killed this year) Queens: Off-Duty Cop Inexplicably Slams SUV Into Pole on LIE, above (News) Manhattan: Off-duty cop shoots driver in road rage incident (News) Related: "Road rage cop speaks out" (Post) Manhattan: Retired Broadway actor killed in hit-and-run (Newsday) Staten Island: Mother dismembered in fatal hit-and-run on way […]