Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

Pricing is Alive. JFK Rail Link and SMART Fund May be Dead.

Annie Karni reports in today's New York Sun that the outlines of a congestion pricing bill may be hammered out in Albany before Memorial Day, though not exactly as Mayor Bloomberg initially proposed.

Karni writes that MTA executive director Lee Sander would prefer to see the $3.75 billion earmarked for a direct rail link from Lower Manhattan to JFK Airport allocated to the Second Avenue subway instead.

Critics of the JFK Rail Link, which have included the Regional PlanAssociation, say the project would benefit fewer riders than a newsubway line. Because it would cut down on the commute between LongIsland's North Shore and Lower Manhattan, some say it would mostlybenefit downtown developers by narrowing the large gap between Midtownand Downtown rents.

Sander also doesn't like PlaNYC's proposal to direct congestion pricing revenue to a new transit funding authority known as the SMART fund.

Mr. Sander on Friday expressed grave misgivings about the creationof a new funding authority at an oversight hearing run by AssemblymanRichard Brodsky, a Democrat of Westchester.

State Senate leader Joe Bruno is reported to be enthusiastic about Mayor Bloomberg's plans.

"He called the mayor's presentation last week to Senate Republicans 'outstanding,'" and sources say he is likely to support the mayor's plan.

And Karni's sources speculate that State Assembly Leader Sheldon Silver may be willing to swap his beloved one-seat ride to JFK for the completion of the Second Avenue subway.

"The city needs a full length Second Avenue Subway, as opposed to themoney being spread out in smaller pieces of big projects," the chiefattorney for the Straphangers Campaign, Gene Russianoff, said. "Theproblem over the last 10 years has been that if you're for all of theprojects, you're really for none of them. That's why they've inchedalong."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Lyft Hoses Citi Bike Riders Compared to Bike-Share in Other Cities: Report

The price of a yearly Citi Bike membership has grown by 77 percent in inflation-adjusted dollars since the bike-share program launched 2013, the Independent Budget Office said.

November 19, 2025

Most People Don’t Drive To Court Street: DOT

And more people bike than drive on the Brooklyn street!

November 19, 2025

DOT Crawls Towards Safe Battery Charging Infrastructure As Fires Rage On

The DOT is once again slow rolling the completion of public charging infrastructure as the city continues to face a battery fire crisis.

November 19, 2025

Report: Biden Infrastructure Bill Spurred Increase in State and Local Highway Spending

The Urban Institute found an overall increase in capital investment in ground transportation — mostly on highways — and flat investment in public transit.

November 19, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: The People v. Yarimi Edition

It was horrific, it was depraved, it was predictable. And it will happen again. Plus other news.

November 19, 2025

Security Blanket: Will NYPD Smother Mamdani’s Love of Transit and Bikes?

Zohran Mamdani likes taking the train and riding a Citi Bike — but the demands of being New York City’s mayor may not be compatible with his transit habit.

November 18, 2025
See all posts