Chicago Cracks Down on Drivers Who Threaten Pedestrians

In just the last ten days here in New York City a 7-year-old boy was killed in the crosswalk by a trucker trying to beat a red light in Brooklyn, a young woman on the Upper East Side and a Brooklyn Heights law professor were crushed to death by private sanitation trucks, and a 12-year-old boy was mowed down by a hit-and-run driver in Queens. The list goes on. Yet, none of these horrible killings of innocents on the streets of New York City merited even a mention from Mayor Bloomberg or any other high level city official. Apparently, in America’s safest big city, this is just business as usual.

maya_hirsch.jpgNot in Chicago. After a hit-and-run driver killed Maya Hirsch, a 4-year-old girl walking with her family near the Lincoln Park Zoo (right), Mayor Richard Daley launched a major pedestrian safety initiative. Skipping the years of study that we like to do here in New York, Chicago’s Departments of Transportation, Emergency Management and Police immediately teamed up to run sting operations at hazardous intersections using plainclothes officers posed as pedestrians. Daley also formed a "Mayor’s Pedestrian Advisory Council" while a program called Safe Streets for Chicago is responsible designing and installing traffic calming measures throughout the city.

Here, in its entirety, is the story that ran in yesterday’s Chicago Tribune, "Arrogant Drivers Best Look Both Ways" by John Hilkevitch:

Attention, drivers who rip around corners without yielding to pedestrians: Starting in the spring, city officials posing as pedestrians will be sent to high-accident intersections as part of a new crackdown on motorists who endanger walkers.

"We all have families with children and elderly members, who are the most vulnerable in traffic situations. We are trying to cool tempers that flare when people get behind the wheel and remind drivers that they cannot treat pedestrians as if they were just another vehicle on the street," said Cheri Heramb, acting commissioner at the Chicago Department of Transportation.

On average more than one pedestrian is killed in a traffic accident each week in Chicago. Accidents involving pedestrians in the city have dropped from 4,478 incidents in 2000 to 3,632 in 2004, the most recent year for which data are available from the Illinois Department of Transportation. But some experts say the drop could partly be a sign that fewer people are walking city streets out of fear of getting hit.

Officials from the city Transportation Department and the Office of Emergency Management and Communications are working with Chicago Police Department commanders on an approach to carry out stings on motorists who drive dangerously near walkers at hazardous intersections. But the Police Department has not yet committed to using plainclothes officers to pose as pedestrians, said police spokeswoman Monique Bond. It could be city traffic-control aides working with uniformed police, officials said. At first, warning citations will be issued to drivers who fail to yield to pedestrians. Tougher steps would follow, officials said.

The city had been focusing on decreasing pedestrians’ risks, but the effort gained momentum in May after a hit-and-run driver struck and killed a 4-year-old girl, Maya Hirsch, who was walking with her family near Lincoln Park Zoo.

Mayor Richard Daley named Heramb co-chair of the newly formed Mayor’s Pedestrian Advisory Council, which will meet in January for the first time.

Under Daley’s Safe Streets for Chicago plan, the look of intersections will begin to change. Corners will be equipped with "bulb-outs"–an extension of the curb that reduces the roadway in traffic lanes. With the "bulb-outs," pedestrians will be in the street for a shorter amount of time.

Bulb-outs will be installed first at spots where there are many senior citizens and schoolchildren. A number of bulb-outs have been installed recently on the North Side near the lakefront, including at Foster Avenue and Marine Drive.

Also islands in street medians, called "pedestrian refuges," will be constructed to provide places for pedestrians to wait if they cannot cross streets in the allotted "walk" time. The crosswalks at some intersections will be elevated several inches to make pedestrians more visible to drivers, city officials say.

One example that the city is testing is in a parking lot on Science Drive at the Museum of Science and Industry. The raised crosswalk also creates a speed bump to remind drivers to slow down.

Crosswalk striping also is being intensified with bolder lines to alert drivers to pedestrian traffic.

"The new design guidelines are intended to remind pedestrians that they are equal users of the road and to remind drivers to give pedestrians the respect they deserve," said Beth Gutelius, pedestrian safety coordinator at Chicago Department of Transportation.

Safe Streets’ educational component also will remind pedestrians to walk at crosswalks and intersections and avoid crossing in the middle of a block or against traffic signals. Counselors will be sent to schools to encourage children to make eye contact with drivers before trying to cross streets and to wear reflective clothing when going out after dark or in bad weather.

Plans are under way as well to convert some four-lane streets into three lanes with marked bicycle lanes.

Officials are plastering the city with public service announcements to counter the image of aggressive driving behavior that is often portrayed in advertisements for new cars, such as a recent TV commercial for the Nissan 350Z that brags the roadster "Goes Like Hell."

City-sponsored posters on the back of downtown newspaper racks show schoolchildren walking along with a reminder to motorists to slow down. Other posters warn drivers to obey the law, showing a Chicago police officer using a hand-held laser device to enforce the speed limit.

These measures are in addition to the planned expansion of red-light-running enforcement cameras and more pedestrian countdown traffic signals, officials said.

Red-light-running violations have declined 55 percent with the surveillance cameras, said Andrew Velasquez, executive director of the Chicago Office of Emergency Management and Communications. Drivers caught on camera running red lights receive $90 tickets in the mail.

"This program has allowed us to change negative driving behavior, and it has saved countless numbers of pedestrians and drivers from fatal injuries," Velasquez said.

Thirty red-light cameras are installed citywide, with 20 more scheduled to be added beginning this month and 50 more next year, Velasquez said.

A primary goal of the Safe Streets for Chicago campaign is making it more attractive and fun to walk, officials said.

People are walking less than folks did a generation ago. Part of the reason is that it has become more dangerous, but the unhealthy trend also is increasingly difficult to buck in a society of couch potatoes, experts say.

Children, who are walking less on average than at any point in the last 30 years, are a special concern. Childhood obesity has become a national health crisis because of decreased physical activity, said Dr. Katherine Kaufer Christoffel, a pediatrician who is co-chair of the Mayor’s Pedestrian Advisory Council.

It is difficult to recommend that parents encourage their children to walk more without also significantly reducing the risks of walking in urban areas, said Christoffel, noting that children between ages 5 and 9 are among the age groups at the highest risk of getting injured in a pedestrian accident. Intoxicated young adults and the elderly also fall into the high-risk group, she said.

"If you don’t have cars racing through residential streets, parents won’t be as concerned about their children walking around," said Christoffel, who is the director of the Center for Obesity Management and Prevention at the Feinberg School of Medicine at Northwestern University.

"We need to get more people walking, safely," she said.

  • P

    It’s great that Chicago is implementing changes in street design along with the enforcement of traffic laws but I’m a little skeptical about the use of ‘undercover pedestrians’.

  • This is amazing! Last night I saw a typical scene, just one block from last week’s pedestrian death on Henry Street. A delivery guy was walking in the crosswalk, with the green light. A giant SUV comes ripping around the corner and slams on his breaks just before hitting the pedestrian. Then, the driver started beeping at the pedestrian (who had the right of way)! The 6 or so people on the street (including myself) all started yelling at the SUV. Yet, he gets away with this kind of driving – a total menace to society. Where is the sting operation when you need one?

  • brent

    Chicago has a long way to go before catching up to NYC in street vibrancy. This is a major step in the right direction.
    I once sent a lengthy letter to mayor Bloomberg on this very topic- pedestrian safety and enforcement against reckless drivers. I was later contacted by a police officer in my neighborhood precinct who said the letter had been forwarded to him. He asked if there were any specific intersections in the neighborhood I was concerned about. I said it was more of an overall concern but decided to tell him about a school on my block where motorists habitually blow through a stop sign intersection and intimidate pedestrians. The next day there was a crossing guard there. She has not returned since. I do not write letters to Bloom anymore and have become more of an SUV yeller like Jason.

  • P

    I don’t know Brent- I’m impressed that one letter led to an actual change- albeit temporary.

  • I am constantly amazed at the quick action Chicago has been taking regarding pedestrian and other related issues. From green roofs to bike lanes and now to this, Chicago has this amazing “do it now” attitude that I just really wish we could see here.

    To be honest, it makes me kind of sad to keep seeing these “Look at what Chicago has done!” posts in the sustainable blogosphere. New York has barely done anything in the past few years that I can point to and say “Look at this great change that’s totally improved our lives!”

    But if I’m wrong about this, I’ll look forward to some examples from other commenters.

  • Driving behavior is certainly terrible in New York, and along with it is (I think) a general lack of understanding of the true stakes of the game. Why run a red light (especially on 3rd Ave or another major corridor w/ timed lights) when you will NEVER catch the next light ahead? Will those 10 seconds really make your day? Are they worth the risk that you might hit and kill another person?

    There is also a lack of understanding of and enforcement of the rules–everything from the crosswalk and stop bar to running lights.

    An education (public service) campaign is in order, and I think this Chicago program is a great model. In addition, the campaign could also ask cyclists to look out for peds at intersections and not ride on the sidewalk, and tell peds to cross at intersections and wait for lights. Cheating death, whether in a car or a bike or on foot–is not worth the time value of getting there faster.

  • Chicagoist has some funny commenters on this.

    “You’d be amazed at the number of Chicago natives I’ve met who are firmly convinced that bikes, by law, are supposed to be ridden on the sidewalk.”

  • Steve

    Running reds is commonplace among motorists in NYC (another reason not to criticize bicyclists too harshly when they do so, along with the fact that bicyclists almost never injure anyone when they do). I have filmed three green-yellow-red sequences at an intersection in front of an Upper West Side school every morning for about a month. Every single morning, at least one time out of three, and usually two or three times out of three, a driver runs the red.

    The clip linked below is typical. Watch the gold Toyota (plate ATE-6114) enter the intersection after the light is red, and after the pedestrian in the black jacket at the other side of the intersection has already entered the crosswalk. The pedestrian isn’t even watching the light but is watching the car, because he knows that the flow of traffic is governed not by the traffic laws or traffic devices, but by what drivers decide to do.

  • Bill

    It’s like that in the Journal Square area of Jersey City, too. More than once, drivers have beeped at me while turning while I was walking in the crosswalk, with the Walk light. They are ignorant of the fact that pedestrians have the right of way in crosswalks, and no doubt ignorant of just about everything else.

  • Erickca

    Too bad Seattle couldn’t follow the same path as Chicago. See the following article about pedestrians staging a crosswalk action in their neighborhood:


In Memoriam

When the book is written on the fight for traffic justice in New York City, an entire chapter might well be devoted to 2012. This was the year when Commissioner Ray Kelly’s NYPD revealed to the City Council that only a handful of officers are assigned to investigate serious traffic crashes. The public learned that, […]

In Memoriam

By all indications, 2010 should have been a banner year for street safety in New York. As the city continued to roll out physical improvements to reduce risks to pedestrians and cyclists and announced unprecedented further measures to come, state legislators stepped up with new laws intended to hold accountable, however incrementally, motorists whose negligence […]

6-Year-Old Boy Fatally Hit by Truck in Brooklyn

Three mornings a week I ride past the South Brooklyn Casket Company on Union Street with my two-year-old son strapped to the back of my bicycle on our way to the nursery school. Though the Casket Company always has trucks parked and unloading all over the sidewalk (and someone, I assume it’s the boss, likes […]