Advocates Point Out How Easy it is to Fix Bus Service

Yes...Ha Ha Ha...Yes!
Yes...Ha Ha Ha...Yes!

This doesn’t have to be so hard.

The MTA has a number of easy-to-implement, already-developed, ready-to-go bus improvements that must be undertaken now to improve service as well as help shore up the agency’s finances, a new report from the Bus Turnaround  Coalition will argue today.

The Big Bus ComebackRather than offer pie-in-the-sky solutions that would take years to put in place, the coalition — which is comprised of the Straphangers Campaign, TransitCenter, Riders Alliance and Tri-State Transportation Campaign — is urging a few basic solutions in its report, “The Big Bus Comeback”:

  • Fully install OMNY fareboxes in the back of the bus to enable all-door boarding.
  • Implement The Bronx bus network redesign, which was shelved during COVID.
  • Get more bus-mounted cameras to enforce the dozens of miles of dedicated bus lanes that already exist, plus the 30 or so more miles planned by the Department of Transportation.
  • Revise bus timetables whenever routes improve so that drivers don’t slow service to stay “on schedule.”

Of course, the choice is the MTA’s, the report argues. It can make these quick improvements now or go back to the same old “low-quality bus service that led ridership to dwindle for years.”

That’s no small dare. With cars largely sidelined during the early phase of the pandemic, bus service not only improved, but retained a higher share of its ridership than the subway system. So now is the time, the reporter argues, to improve service so the agency can retain and even add riders at a time when subway turnstiles are collecting not nearly as many fares as before the pandemic.

And the MTA can’t cry poverty for several reasons: not only did the federal stimulus provide the agency with billions of much-needed funding, the costs of the improvements are “inexpensive yet effective,” the coalition said.

And most are already in the works.

For example, all-door boarding was supposed to be fully implemented by the end of this year, but the MTA may be backtracking, saying that rear-door boarding may not be ready until 2023, when the MetroCard is retired.

It’s an essential improvement. According to the coalition, buses spend more than 20 percent of their time standing still at stops (known as “dwell time”). But dwell time is down 40 percent on Select Bus Service routes that already feature all-door boarding.

The group also claims that the pandemic showed the need for the bus network to be redesigned — and the one prepared for The Bronx is ready to go.

“Ridership patterns in the Bronx during the pandemic reinforce the wisdom of many changes in the redesign: Routes that are designated to receive more frequent service also tend to be the ones that have retained the most ridership,” the coalition said.

Most important is improving bus lane enforcement. Only seven lines have bus-mounted cameras. Dozens more could.

“Procuring more bus-mounted cameras is a small expense in the MTA’s capital budget,” the report says. “Furthermore, the bus camera enforcement program is administered by NYC DOT, while revenues from bus-mounted cameras go toward the MTA.”

Look, it’s not like the MTA doesn’t agree with the basic findings of the report.

“We appreciate TransitCenter’s focus on buses and look forward to getting back to work on all elements of our Bus Plan as New York City returns in the coming months,” MTA Bus Company President Craig Cipriano said in a statement.


World-Class Avenues for the East Side: What Great BRT Looks Like

BRT + bike: East Side avenues have enough space for physically separated busways and protected bike lanes. The biggest sustainable transportation story in New York right now is how DOT and the MTA plan to design Bus Rapid Transit corridors for the East Side of Manhattan. Will we get world-class avenues that attract more riders […]

BRT, Rail, and New York City: A Conversation With Walter Hook

Perhaps no one knows the ins and outs of BRT better than Walter Hook. As director of the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy, Hook has advised cities on four continents about BRT implementation, including Jakarta's seven-corridor network, the first full-fledged BRT system in Asia. Streetsblog caught up with Hook -- in between trips to Cape Town and Mexico City -- for an email Q&A about why New York City needs Bus Rapid Transit, common misconceptions of BRT in America, and what will make BRT succeed here.

Bus Rapid Transit Designs for East Side Avenues Still in Flux

Earlier this week DOT and the MTA showed plans for Bus Rapid Transit on the east side of Manhattan to the Seaport/Civic Center committee of Community Board 1. With implementation scheduled for next September, the question of how to allot space on First and Second Avenues is increasingly urgent. Robust bus improvements paired with protected […]

The Case for Center-Running Bus Lanes on Woodhaven Boulevard

The proposal to improve bus service on Woodhaven Boulevard and Cross Bay Boulevard in Queens is the most exciting street redesign in the works in New York City right now, with the potential to break new ground for bus riders and dramatically improve safety. With as many as five lanes in each direction, Woodhaven Boulevard […]