Opinion: Why We Are Organizing a Union at TransAlt

Giving workers a seat at the table will help advance the mission of street safety.

Challenging power is a critical vehicle for change, as we, the staff of Transportation Alternatives, learn through each hard-fought victory at work. We are a progressive organization that isn’t afraid to challenge authority. We believe in bottom-up mass organizing that puts ordinary people in the center of any fight to improve their lives and community. Now, as staff, we are using the same theory by forming a union to ensure that TA will excel at achieving its mission.

Some may think it is ironic that Transportation Alternatives staff would forge an affiliation with United Auto Workers. In fact, TA Executive Director Danny Harris expressed that very concern in a letter to staff suggesting that TA does not believe a union is necessary and encouraging us to weigh the effect that our organizing drive might have on our brand, reputation and mission to “reclaim NYC’s streets from the automobile…” 

So let us explain. In order to safeguard our rights as workers, we have been coordinating with Local 2110 UAW, a union for technical, office and professional workers in universities, publishing, museums, law firms, and other offices. The union represents teachers, secretaries, administrators, editors, computer operators, librarians, museum curators, typesetters, graphic artists, and many others (although no actual auto workers). 

It will be our honor to organize alongside workers from the ACLU, Bronx Museum of Arts, Columbia University, MoMA, The New-York Historical Society, Good Ole Lower East Side, and others. As for being in the same tent as United Auto Workers, we believe unionizing is about harnessing the collective power of workers.

Plus, who knows what kind of transformative change to our streets can happen when Transportation Alternatives staff and auto workers come together?

We are advocating for a voice and a seat at the TA table, to bring about better working conditions and to drive the mission of the organization. We wish to not just be employees, but partners in reaching shared goals. We believe collective bargaining can enable true accountability from management and a more stable, secure, and democratic TA. Integral to that is valuing, respecting, and maintaining the institutional knowledge and contributions of all staff. 

Similar to the staff at other non-profit organizations, we perform our jobs not only because we believe in the work; we also have to support ourselves, and for some of us, families, too. When workers call too much attention to grievances or push too hard on any agenda, however, much can be at stake, from career and financial risks to emotional well being and personal reputations. 

Strategies like “open-door policies,” unfortunately, do not seem to work — just like asking nicely for implementation of known life-saving measures on our streets doesn’t bring us the safety we need. 

Unions are designed to benefit women, BIPOC, LGBTQ communities, individuals with disabilities — in other words, all staff. 

As labor leader Karen Nussbaum has said, “The true face of the unions now is not a man in a hard hat as much as it is a woman in a classroom or in cleaning smocks.” Union efforts raise wages, expose salary disparities, enact anti-discrimination protections, encourage professional development, and enable grievance procedures. 


We are proud and grateful to work at TA, one of the leading street-safety advocacy organizations in New York City. We are aware of the challenges TA and other non-profits face, particularly in this time of COVID-19, including overhead expenses and fundraising hardships. Ultimately, however, we think that our organizing drive will help TA strengthen its mission and achieve its social-justice goals. 

Organizing ourselves during a pandemic has been quite a feat. We look forward to joining Local 2110 and believe that together, we can make a stronger, more equitable TA. 

Dulcie Canton, HP Liao, Marian Jones, Alicia Perre-Dowd, and Chana Widawski are members of the organizing committee of Transportation Alternatives’s union (@TransAltUnion).


From Heroes to Lapdogs, TA Grades the “Class of Vision Zero”

On Wednesday Transportation Alternatives released its “Class of Vision Zero” report, the first in a planned series of biannual “performance reviews” of officials and agencies who have the power to make New York City streets safer for walking, biking, and driving. Traffic injuries and fatalities were down through June 2015 compared to the first six […]

Council Members Van Bramer, Levin Come Out on Top in TA Report Card

Which members of the City Council have made transportation a priority this term? A new report card from Transportation Alternatives [PDF] ranks each borough’s delegation on whether its members sponsored 15 key transportation bills and resolutions signed by the mayor in the first six months of 2014. It found that, while a majority of council members are […]

TA Sends Questionnaires to Mayoral and City Council Candidates

Yesterday, Transportation Alternatives sent out questionnaires to all City Council and mayoral candidates, asking their positions on pedestrian safety, bike lanes, transit, bike-share, and traffic justice. The first responses are set to go up on TA’s website at the end of this month. TA Deputy Director Noah Budnick told Streetsblog that the organization has already heard […]

Ride Citi Bike? TA Wants to Know What You Think

Transportation Alternatives has launched a series of surveys asking Citi Bike riders what they think of the bike-share program. The aim is to better inform TA’s activism and introduce the advocacy group to bike-share users who may not already be familiar with ways they can help improve cycling in New York. “We don’t want this to […]

TA Vision Zero Report: NYPD Traffic Enforcement Up, But Wildly Uneven

NYPD increased enforcement of dangerous traffic violations during the first six months of the city’s Vision Zero initiative, but enforcement varied drastically from precinct to precinct, with some issuing fewer summonses than last year. In “Report Card: Six Months of Vision Zero Traffic Enforcement” [PDF], Transportation Alternatives analyzed NYPD summons data from January through June. TA […]