Delivery Cyclists Have One of the Most Dangerous Jobs, But No One Is Protecting Them

Cops were out on Sixth Avenue ticketing and victim-blaming cyclists.

Working cyclist Robyn Hightman was killed by a truck driver in Manhattan on June 24.
Working cyclist Robyn Hightman was killed by a truck driver in Manhattan on June 24.

Working cyclists have one of the most dangerous jobs in the country, and they are dying at rapid rates on New York City streets — but instead of stepping in to protect them, Mayor de Blasio is off running for president and New York’s Finest are focused on victim-blaming and ticketing bikers.

Twenty-year-old Robyn Hightman, who was killed by a truck driver Monday in Manhattan, is now at least the fifth delivery cyclist to die because of the actions of a motorist while on the job in the past six months. Even more cyclists have been hurt or have experienced other traffic violence while biking in the city, according to advocacy group the Biking Public Project. 

A whopping 62 percent of working cyclists interviewed in a 2017 survey by the Biking Public Project said that they had been involved in a motor-vehicle collision at least once, and an average of 30 percent said they had missed work because of work-related injuries in the last year. 

For comparison, the New York State’s Department of Labor  said that only 1.5 of 100 full-time workers missed work because of work-related injuries in New York in 2017; the national Bureau of Labor and Statistics calculated that .9 per hundred full-time workers had missed work for injuries in that year.

Biking Public Project’s Do Lee attributed the high percentage of injuries to the many hours working cyclists must bike on dangerous streets that aren’t built for them, as well as to the cyclists’ poor working conditions, such as low pay, overlong shifts, demands that they work faster, and lack of worker’s compensation. 

“They’re working long hours under poor labor conditions; it puts them at more risk,” said Lee. “I think it’s constant exposure on the streets, anywhere from eight to 12 to 16 hours a day, an enormous opportunity to have something happen no matter how experienced you are.”

Demand for quick deliveries is only rising, making workers’ jobs harder and more dangerous — but the city can step up and redesign streets to make it harder for reckless drivers to run over and kill working cyclists, said Lee. 

“I think it really speaks to the necessity of infrastructure that accommodates the needs of working cyclists,” he said. “No matter what precautions you take, you can’t protect yourself against a two-ton machine.”

Hightman, whose preferred pronouns were they/then, said their bike was a means of empowerment and even saved them from a troubled childhood. They could not have known, of course, that unsafe streets would kill them.

“As a homeless youth deeply entrenched in the trappings of poverty and parental abuse and neglect, my first bicycle offered a way to seek respite from the horrors of my surroundings and human experience, if only for a few glorious minutes,” Hightman wrote in an application to join an Ambassador Program for a professional cycling team. “My bicycle established a sense of independence, strengthened my ability to be self sufficient, and provided me with the confidence necessary to advocate for myself, my rights, and my needs in public space. My bicycle enabled me to leave our encampment every day to access education, seek out food, and fulfill my basic needs. Eventually, my bicycle allowed me to provide for myself when I began working a full time job at the age of fourteen. My bicycle provided me with the socioeconomic mobility necessary to escape. My bicycle saved my life.”

Police say Hightman and the 54-year-old truck driver, Antonio Garcia, were both traveling northbound on Sixth Avenue when “they collided.” Garcia, who initially left the scene before returning, told Streetsblog that this crash was his first “accident” in 14 years. He claimed he did not feel the impact of hitting Hightman.

Police investigate after the fatal crash on Sixth Avenue. Photo: Julianne Cuba
Police investigate after the fatal crash on Sixth Avenue. Photo: Julianne Cuba

Cops slapped Garcia with five summonses for minor violations related to his truck — although none for actually killing the cyclists. He walked away without so much as a ticket for failure to yield or to exercise due care. A Streetsblog video shows a police officer patting Garcia on the shoulder before Garcia left the crash scene.

More than 100 people came out to mourn Hightman’s death just hours after they were killed — and to demand that cops enforce traffic laws against reckless drivers, not cyclists, in the crash’s aftermath.

But instead of doing more to protect bikers, cops were again out near the scene of the fatal collision — the morning after the massive vigil — victim-blaming and ticketing bikers, just as they have done in the wake of other cyclists’ deaths.

One officer even said Hightman’s death was their own fault for riding outside of the bike lane, despite it likely being blocked by construction that morning.

“As far as the female who passed away unfortunately, yesterday, I believe she was riding off the bike lane, you know,” Officer Carlos Negron told Gothamist, as he stood near the intersection of West 24th and 6th Avenue the morning after Hightman was killed there. “It’s sad, but it’s sad that she was off the bike lane, you know? Maybe if she had been on the bike lane, maybe she’d still be alive.”

Hightman’s tragic death was all too familiar to the messenger community, who just months ago had to bury another friend, 25-year-old Aurilla Lawrence, after a hit-and-run driver mowed her down in Williamsburg back in February. 

Other professional riders told Streestblog that they felt powerless in the face of police indifference toward reckless drivers, adding that even the most experienced riders could also end up as roadkill if the city does not do more to protect them. 

The need for that protection hasn’t changed four months later.

Bikers and safe-street advocates blasted Mayor de Blasio for not doing more to stop the bloodshed, especially with the mayor out gallivanting across the country.

“What are you doing to make sure I go home today? That I won’t be another number? That I won’t be crushed by a speeding commercial truck with 85 summonses running rampant in your city, blowing red lights with no worry of consequence, like my dear friend Robyn?” said Hightman’s friend Kelsey Leigh on Twitter, the day after they were killed. 

De Blasio did not comment directly on Hightman’s death, except to say on Errol Louis’s show Inside City Hall that it’s a “very painful time and our heart goes out to all families involved,” before quickly clapping back on Transportation Alternatives’ characterization that Vision Zero is in crisis now that Hightman is at least the 12th biker to be killed this year. 

“I disagree with that characterization though, I have to be honest it’s five years in a row fatalities have gone down,” Hizzoner said. 

In addition to Lawrence and Hightman, three other working cyclists have been killed in the last six months — 29-year-old Mohammed Abdullah was killed this month while riding an electric bicycle in Canarsie, 21-year-old MD Rajon was killed while delivering food in East New York in December, and 26-year-old Hugo Garcia was killed while biking to work in Sunset Park on Jan. 1.

Police have arrested just one of the five victims’ killers — the four others are still driving. Cops cuffed 32-year-old Jonathan Cuesta and charged him with failure to yield and failure to exercise due care after he struck and killed Rajon in the early morning of Dec. 14.

  • r

    “I disagree with that characterization though, I have to be honest it’s five years in a row fatalities have gone down.”

    Pedestrian fatalities are also up this year. The mayor doesn’t know jack shit about Vision Zero. Anyone awake there at City Hall or DOT who can talk to this insensitive, arrogant, delusional moron?

  • William Lawson

    There are so many people in this city whose jobs are 10x as dangerous as these dough-assed snowflake cops.

  • William Lawson

    ““It’s sad, but it’s sad that she was off the bike lane, you know? Maybe if she had been on the bike lane, maybe she’d still be alive.”” — you ignorant, useless, insufferable piece of shit cop. F*ck you! She was turning off 23rd onto 6th and THERE IS NO BIKE LANE ON 23rd YOU NYPD IGNORAMUS. Also, how about a “maybe if the truck driver hadn’t have run a red light at 45mph, she’d still be alive”? Of course not, because that would be an uncharacteristic departure from the suburban windshield-biased ignorance that infests the tiny minds of every single one of these low IQ scumbag cops. F*ck all of them. I don’t even think of them as human any more.

  • so true, and that’s their dodge: “we have a dangerous job”

  • PDiddy

    Fuck man. And Kelsey Leigh had just made a video saying she’s scared to death of riding because of Aurilla dying and now this.

  • Vooch

    why does any preceint house in Manhattan need any Prowl Cars ?

    Every one of these PD stations was built decades before cops rodearound in prowl cars.

    Its faster for the cops to walk to their beat.

  • Ian Turner

    I’d suggest doing a ride-along with the NYPD, it might help you answer this question.

  • Larry Littlefield

    “Hightman’s death was their own fault for riding outside of the bike lane, despite it likely being blocked by construction that morning.”

    And as for why she had moved to the other side of the street, if she in fact had, it may have been because she was setting up to make a right turn — from the right lane. I used to do that myself when I worked in Midtown. The bike lane ended, and when I thought safe to do so I moved right to get to the bike parking at the Hippodrome Garage.

    If the bike lane was not obstructed, perhaps she could have come to a stop in the bike lane, and turned onto the side street. But in that case, couldn’t she have been ticketed for going through the red light while turning if the police were under quota pressure?

    We’ll never know why she was where she was, because she is gone. I doubt it was a death wish.

  • Paul

    First, this is so sad. As someone who is out there riding the NYC streets daily, it really hits home. I feel so bad for her and her loved ones.

    I often see negligent drivers, but just as often, I see cyclist making bad decisions. Often truck drivers just can’t see you. As a cyclist you have to understand this and adjust how you ride when around trucks. I typically will either speed up to get safely ahead of a truck, or slow down hard, to get safely behind. I don’t get angry at truck drivers, because I understand they can’t see me. Her being in the bike lane or out is irrelevant. you have to know how to handle the situation.

  • Vooch

    funny , really funny

    please tell me why the 1st needs prowl cars ?

  • 1276 people have demanded the NYPD stop victim blaming and stop the absurd policy of ticketing cyclists when reckless drivers kill them. Add your name…..

    https://campaigns.transalt.org/petition/stop-ticketing-cyclists-when-reckless-drivers-kill

  • specialmonkey

    Trucks are probably the most dangerous part of commuting and then not being careful enough — it’s very easy to be careless on a bike, not saying this was the case, and am inclined to think it was the other way around. Is there any video — are cops waiting until it is no longer available — I don’t trust them at all.

  • specialmonkey

    Officer Carlos Negron unfortunately is a representative sample of NYPD.

  • specialmonkey

    Siren on to get through red light.

  • AMH

    Or no siren, and no headlights, all while doing 50mph down residential streets at night. Anything goes, really.

  • Andrew

    Often truck drivers just can’t see you.

    If a driver (truck or otherwise) cannot see whether a given space is occupied or vacant, yet he nonetheless chooses to assume that it’s vacant, he is proven himself incompetent to drive and should be permanently relieved of his license.

    If such a driver manages to injure or kill someone because he couldn’t be bothered to watch where he was going, he should be held fully culpable.

  • Joe R.

    There’s something known as a cabover which generally has excellent visibility. It’s not ubiquitous in the truck world on account of stupid styling concerns. We should mandate cabovers for any truck operated within NYC limits. That fixes most of the visibility problems.

  • alda

    After five years I made the decision to leave my old work which changed my daily life… I commenced doing a task online, for an establishment I saw on the internet, for a few hrs per day, and I rake in a lot more than I have done on my previous occupation… Very last check I got was 9000 bucks… This online based work gave me freedom to do the job from any location and at any time and I could go out on a vacation also. Look it over, what it’s all about… cavallettoethanol.homepage.cx

  • relevantjeff

    And give up that sweet, sweet cyclist ticketing revenue? Oh noooo.

  • Wen

    When I was employed by my earlier organization I was looking to find real work from home opportunities in which I could obtain a nice income and simultaneously get sufficient time to devote with my family members and offcourse I am not looking for scams that misguide you to make you very very rich in simply few days or more. Ultimately I discovered a remarkable opportunity and I can’t tell you how delighted I am nowadays. The best parts about doing work from internet are: Your Office Can Be Anywhere- you’re not tied to your house. You can take good care of your job on a trip, enjoying the wonderful outdoors , or even listening to your favorite band at a live music show. You will be able to additionally save on food costs because you’ll very easily be able to whip up your own lunch and coffee if you work from home. Your Schedule Can Be Your Own: A lot of the work which can be done remotely these days can also be executed on a very flexible routine. If you do have to work particular hrs, you’re certain to still have some break time—time you can use however you’d like! Even if you have just ten mins, you can do something that simply wouldn’t be possible in a traditional office: bust those samba moves, play a few tunes on your guitar, or even take a relaxing power nap. You’re guaranteed to come back feeling a lot more energized than you would after ten minutes at your computer desk surfing Facebook or twitter. You Can Learn More and Become More Independent:Because you don’t have co-workers just a few feet away or a tech team one floor down, you’ll find yourself developing the skill of searching for your own answers and becoming more proactive to find what you need on your own. Of course you can still ask questions and also get help if you wish to. However, a lot of the time, you could do a Google search, download a 100 % free guide. Here’s the means through which to begun > ACT NOW

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

When Media Outlets Cover Delivery Cyclists, They Rarely Talk to Them

|
NYC’s mostly-immigrant food delivery cyclists don’t have it easy, working on car-centric streets through all sorts of weather, all while under pressure to make their deliveries as quickly as possible. But media coverage of delivery cyclists tends to dehumanize them, failing to convey their perspective or consider the difficult working conditions they contend with. That’s the conclusion […]

TA: City Hall’s Spending Decisions Are Limiting Life-Saving Street Designs

|
Transportation Alternatives says the de Blasio administration’s failure to fully fund Vision Zero street improvements is limiting the number of split-phase traffic signals DOT can install to prevent collisions at dangerous intersections. In June, 30-year-old cyclist Olga Cook was killed by an allegedly drunk driver who made a right turn across the Hudson River Greenway at Chambers Street, one […]