NYPD Forced to Protect DOT’s Second Avenue ‘Protected Bike Lane’

An officer from the 19th Precinct checks on the so-called protected bike lane Friday afternoon. Photo: Julianne Cuba.
An officer from the 19th Precinct checks on the so-called protected bike lane Friday afternoon. Photo: Julianne Cuba.

The Department of Transportation’s so-called protected bike lane in the notoriously dangerous area called the “Second Avenue Gap” is such a failure of design that the NYPD is using sawhorses and police tape to keep cars out of it — and the DOT doesn’t plan any immediate changes.

Police in the 19th Precinct — whose support of cyclists is inconsistent, thanks to intermittent crackdowns of delivery cyclists — are now being hailed for setting up physical barriers in the Upper East Side bike lane in order to protect bikers from speeding cars.

“Our officers are back out on 2nd Avenue today ensuring the new stretch of #UpperEastSide #BikeNYC lane is being used by cyclists only,” the 19th Precinct wrote on Twitter on June 20. “Looking good at this hour. We will continue to monitor to ensure cyclist’s (sic) safety.”

The problem is not only DOT’s design but its strategy. Most of the day, cyclists are indeed protected by a row of parked cars. But between 3 pm and 8 pm every day except Sunday, the parking lane becomes a travel lane, apparently to serve rush-hour drivers destined for the Queensboro Bridge entrance at 59th Street — one of the most congested spots in the city. 

Drivers have responded by swerving into the bike lane to drop off passengers, make a left turn off the avenue, or park — forcing the NYPD to set up barriers. 

On Friday afternoon at 5 pm, an officer from the local station house was out fastening police tape to the sawhorse to ensure cars did not go into the newly painted bike lane — the design is a new concept for the neighborhood, so the precinct’s Commanding Officer, Deputy Inspector Kathleen Walsh, has sent out her rank-and-file cops for the past two weeks to set up the physical barriers during some of the busiest sections of the new bike lane, according to the officer at the scene.

Police tape and a sawhorse block the bike lane from the travel lane. Photo: Julianne Cuba
Police tape and a sawhorse block the bike lane from the travel lane. Photo: Julianne Cuba

Physical barriers are supposed to help drivers know that they can’t just cross into a bike lane, but because of the confusing nature of Second Avenue — changing from a parking lane to a moving lane halfway through the day — and without any physical protection, drivers either don’t know or just don’t care about encroaching on cyclists’ space. 

Bikers questioned why DOT, which came up with the design, can’t just install physical protections like jersey barriers or even flexible delineators as it does on other bike lanes, including Grand Street and 12th and 13th streets.

“If only the DOT had the technology to erect some sort of ‘barrier’ so the NYPD doesn’t have to do this all day. They could call it a ‘protected bike lane’ or something like that,” Bike Snob Eben Weiss joked on Twitter on June 20

DOT told Streetsblog it cannot install physical barriers because of the need to accommodate the width of street sweepers and snow plows — adding flexible delineators nine feet off the curb in the buffer would not allow for standard street sweepers or snow plows to reach the curb, while instead using parked cars allows for flexibility to reach the curb when the lane is cleared during rush hours and street sweeping. 

A spokeswoman for the Department of Sanitation did not respond to a request for comment, telling Streetsblog to reach out to DOT for details about the Second Avenue bike lane.
But the city must figure out a work around if it really wants to protect cyclists and plans to build out even more protected bike lanes, said Bike New York’s Jon Orcutt.

“This is a problem we’re seeing more and more of — these protected bike lanes that don’t actually have anything but various porous arrangements of these vertical sticks with nothing else to keep cars out of them,” said Orcutt. “This is something city government needs to resolve — the more protected bike lanes we have the more there’s a need for smaller street sweeping equipment. It’d be nice if there was some sense that DOT was actually on it or City Hall, actually helping to coordinate.”

  • HamTech87

    Excited by news of the so-called protected bike lane filing the 2nd Ave gap, a friend took his 15 year old nephew along it on their way to Brooklyn. He regretted his decision, and called it “terrifying”.

  • Vooch

    A tiny bit of cultural change by the NYPD’s 19th is most welcome.

    Thank you.

  • Emmily_Litella

    Why not use police manpower to simply ticket many or most drivers not minding their Ps and Qs along there?

  • Street sweepers are working during rush hours?


  • Been seeing this on Twitter, and was baffled as to why an NYPD precinct would openly display such a concern for human life and wellbeing. I did a bit of snooping, and found the answer. The 19th Precinct is helmed by a woman, Deputy Inspector Kathleen Walsh. Sorry for making sweeping generalizations about women but as Elizabeth Cady Stanton once observed, woman understands the value of human life better than man.

  • It would be so useful to have a team of officers on bicycles whose main task would be to ride up and down the bike lanes on the Manhattan avenues. This would protect bicyclists by discouraging encroachment, and it would also broaden the perspective of the police department by providing that department with some understanding of the needs of cyclists.

  • PDiddy

    Why do you need street sweepers for a bike lane? How does NYC keep sidewalks clean?

  • qrt145

    Keeping the sidewalk clean is the responsibility of the owner of the property abutting the sidewalk.

  • PDiddy

    Yes. I seem to have forgotten the Seinfeld episode where Elaine demands the shop owner to use a bucket instead of a hose to clean the sidewalk in front of his store.

  • AMH

    That’s the only time I see them.

  • AMH

    It also takes about 2 hours if you strictly mind every traffic light.

  • Aloyicious


    Hillary Clinton

  • crazytrainmatt

    They keep bringing up the street sweeper excuse, but have the filthy lanes on 26th/29th been swept once in their existence? No way a street sweeper fits in there if anybody decides not to respect alternate side.

  • SSkate

    This is also the precinct that occasionally runs cyclist and e-cyclist stings where First Ave passed under the Queensboro Bridge.

  • cjstephens

    Ugh. Puh-leez. I give you the compassionate, female (and Democrat!) Diane Savino:

  • tiffiny

    If you are planning to get paid $5712 month-to-month with by using your own internet connection and computer therefore I wanted to let you know about my experience. 2 years back in the past I used to be being employed in independent corporation without receiving effective paycheck in respect to my hard work. And my best friend informed me about home based internet employment you can use from comfort of home making use of the web and workstation and great thing about it it’s possible to perform at any time we intend to and receive the payments on week after week basis. It’s different from a promotion that you see all over the net that assures to help you become unbelieveably wealthy in two or three months or so. Right now after working on this work opportunity for 2 yrs I am going to that this is now the most desirable web-based work I am going to secure in consideration that by performing on this project I am able to get the job done any time I want. Every Time I was employed in private sector venture I used to be the inability to to get a chance to spend time with my family but during 2 yrs I have been utilizing this web based profession and and now I have been savoring spare time with my loved ones at home or rather by going outside to just about anywhere I like. This business is really as stress-free just as going through online message boards and performing copy/pasting paste job that everyone can do ====> blushnicotine.aa9.de

  • Cleta

    It is possible to simply leave your tiring 9 am to 5 pm job and then begin with earning checks each month approx 12000 dollars working on the internet. Let’s be real, no matter where you’re doing work from, you’re still doing just that: working. While working from home you might have Extremely flexible daily routine – you can take breaks at any hour, feel no rush to hang up on your loved ones when they call, and have lunch at any weird time you choose, Forget crowds and heavy traffic – Absolutely no stuffing yourself into a rickety transportation tube, having people scuff your new shoes, or walking behind agonizingly slow individuals who apparently don’t understand what a straight line is, Much more time with loved ones -Take proper care of a sick significant other at home, get ready for your kids earlier in the day time, get some extra snuggles in with your doggo, or simply have some peaceful time to your-self! Test it yourself, what it is about… concepttrumpet.im-internet.eu

  • willie dean

    So people that ride bikes need to stay in their bike lane and don’t ride in traffic! A headlight should be used at all time. Because i drive at night and some bikers ride in the street without headlights and it’s very hard for me to see them!


Kallos Puts Out a Meek Report on Upper East Side Street Safety

The Upper East Side is full of dangerous intersections, and residents are clamoring for bus countdown clocks, benches, and bike racks, according to a two-part report released today by Council Member Ben Kallos [PDF 1, 2]. It’s not often a council member releases a report on livable streets, and Kallos should be commended for his […]

NYPD “Bicycle Safe Passage” Stings Aren’t Creating Safe Passage for Cyclists

Rather than ticket cars blocking Jay St #bikenyc lane, I saw @OpSafeCycle @NYPD84Pct ticketing bikes near Mnhtn Bridge. #WhenIsBrattonDone? — dave ‘paco’ abraham (@subtle116) July 26, 2016 Earlier this year, when City Hall announced NYPD’s “Bicycle Safe Passage” enforcement initiative to ticket drivers for blocking bike lanes and failing to yield to cyclists, it sounded like a […]