Lower Manhattan to DOT: Protect Our Cyclists Better!

Pedestrians need help. It may be on the way. Photo: Isaac Blasenstein
Pedestrians need help. It may be on the way. Photo: Isaac Blasenstein

SB Donation NYC header 2Downtown residents want big changes to Broadway, but the city is offering only a “step towards the right direction.”

That half-a-loaf language is how a Department of Transportation official described the agency’s plan to improve the Village and NoHo sections of Broadway by adding more room for pedestrians and painting a bike lane between 14th and Bleecker streets.

But it’s not enough for Manhattan Community Board 2’s Traffic and Transportation Committee. A painted bike lane is less safe than a protected one, members pointed out, and the plan does nothing to reduce traffic volume or parking space on Broadway.

On one thing, everyone agrees: Changes are long overdue on Broadway between 14th and Canal streets, where 77 people have been injured so far this year. Sidewalks along the corridor are full of pedestrians, especially just above Houston and well into SoHo’s busy retail district.

Pedestrians are particularly at risk because drivers are so prioritized that two-legged roadway users spill into the roadway at many intersections, especially near the R-train stations on the corridor. Prince Street station averages about 13,600 riders per day while the Eighth Street-NYU station averages more than 15,200, enough to place both stations among the 25 percent busiest stations in the system.

“[The pedestrians] are already out there, they’re already standing in the roadway,” said the DOT’s Assistant Director of Project Management Julio Palleiro.

The new configuration would try to make sense out of the chaos. Photo: DOT
The new configuration would try to make sense out of the chaos. Photo: DOT

To address that immediate safety issue, DOT will add pedestrian curb extensions on 25 corners from Ninth  to Howard streets. The areas will be designated with tan paint extending out to the edge of the parking lane. Plastic bollards will make the areas visible to motorists, and granite blocks will provide physical safety for pedestrians waiting to cross.

Transportation officials say crosswalks will also be given a larger profile, extending to the edges of the new pedestrian areas.

“The curb extensions really help pedestrians shorten the crossing distance, they don’t have to cross the street as long, it gets them out so they’re more visible to drivers,” Department of Transportation Project Manager Mia Moffett explained. 

Broadway currently features a protected bike lane from Central Park to Union Square (minus the pedestrianized Times Square). At Union Square, cyclists lose their protection — and many continue riding down Broadway below 14th Street even though it has no bike lane at all. Fifteen cyclists have been injured this year on Broadway between 14th and Spring streets.

Painted areas on Broadway will give pedestrians more room. Photo: DOT
Painted areas on Broadway will give pedestrians more room. Photo: DOT

Committee members thought the city needed to try harder to create its proven safety enhancement — a protected bike lane — even at the cost of roadway capacity or altering the current curb regulations, which allow three-hour commercial vehicle parking on both sides of the road.

“Is it really appropriate to have parking on both sides in that area?” asked Ritu Chattree, vice-chairwoman of the committee, referring to the section of Broadway between 14th and Bleecker streets.

For now, at least, the plan will merely narrow the parking lanes on both sides of Broadway to create a five-foot-wide painted bike lane, terminating at Bleecker Street. The city will not make any changes to the roadway south of Bleecker Street, which will retain three lanes for motor vehicles and not feature a bike lane.

“We’re making a step toward the right direction.” said Moffett.

Many cyclists stay on Broadway below 14th Street, despite the danger. Photo: Isaac Blasenstein
Many cyclists stay on Broadway below 14th Street, despite the danger. Photo: Isaac Blasenstein

The city also lacked a plan for the intersection at 14th Street. Currently, the protected bike lane on Union Square East abruptly ends at 15th Street with sharrows directing southbound cyclists into both the right and left turn lanes. The CB2 committee said the city needs a plan for the complicated intersection that will safely direct cyclists from the protected bike lane on the right side, switch them across the multiple travel lanes to the left side of the street, move them across 14th Street, and connect them with the proposed bike lane on the left side of Broadway.

“It’s a very dangerous condition because you go from a protected bike lane and then it’s not clear what you’re supposed to do next,” said committee member Janet Liff.

SB Donation NYC header 2Our December Donation Drive continues!

  • Geck

    Pedestrian improvements on Broadway are a start, but we need a two-way protected bike lane the full length of Lafayette Street-Union Square to the Brooklyn Bridge.

  • AnoNYC

    Can we just make this stretch bus and bike only already with huge sidewalks?

  • AMH

    “Is it really appropriate to have parking on both sides in that area?”

    Music to my ears! It’s wonderful to hear a CB member asking this.

  • Impressive, indeed. Perhaps not every Community Board is made up entirely of half-wits and lunatics.

  • Daphna

    That proposal is pathetic. Why does the DOT keep proposing 11′ travel lanes when 10′ is plenty wide even for trucks and buses considering that the citywide speed limit is 25mph? What is really needed is that a parking lane is eliminated and a travel lane is eliminated. Then the sidewalks can be widened on both sides and there can be a curbside bike lane.

  • “We’re making a step toward the right direction.”

    The problems we face are massive. It’s not enough to take steps in the right direction anymore. Incrementalism will get us nowhere. We need the right solution right now.

  • dave “paco” abraham

    Steps are helpful.. but when the CB itself is asking for more, DOT ought to jump. I’m surprised they didn’t have an option B to present as well that shows a protected lane. It ought to be an option in every presentation the Bicycle Program makes since the data is clear. When paint fades, blood spills.

  • Agreed. In this case, why not go with the biggest and best option and THEN dial it back if need be instead of starting with something this weak? The CB wants more!

  • Jacob

    Why not get rid of a car travel lane and keep loading zones on both sides?

  • JL

    East-West travel below Houston is no Cakewalk either. I use the Prince Street Bike Lane several times a month traveling EW from Mullberry to the West Side Greenway. It’s a full contact sport on the left side AND on the right side. Does anyone know a better way to get to the highway? The last bit going into the tunnel with trucks at Houston is especially harrowing.

  • redbike


    Lafayette at Astor Pl is something of a cluster-fuck, but otherwise, sanctioning the current de facto 2-way bike traffic on Lafayette’s existing bike lane is the low-hanging fruit.

  • Joseph R.

    That used to be my daily commute. The tunnel is the worst. During rush hour you have literally dozens of cars, busses and trucks taking right turns from the left turn lane at the last second because the left turn lane is usually a bit shorter, and unfortunately the bike lane is the first thing they dart through(usually without signals).

  • Very important article . big city with big problems and great vibes.
    visit us at https://www.carpetcleaningnyc.com/

  • Daphna

    I’d like these curb extensions on every corner of every intersection citywide!!

  • disqus_irJbtjnq92 yes but


DOT Unveils Union Square Upgrades to Manhattan CB 5

NYCDOT’s plans for Union Square would add pedestrian plazas and better bike facilities on Broadway and 17th Street. Image: NYCDOT. For a larger version, click here. Last night NYCDOT showed plans for a package of safety upgrades and public space improvements for Union Square [PDF] to Manhattan Community Board 5’s transportation committee. Under the plan, […]

DOT Compromises, to a Point, on Union Square Plan

Though Broadway will remain a through street, NYCDOT is still building bike lanes and pedestrian plazas at Union Square. Image: NYCDOT. It took a few tries, but the Department of Transportation finally won the support of Manhattan Community Board 5’s Transportation Committee for its Union Square bike-ped plan last night. While a few safety improvements […]

CB 12 Committee Endorses Ped Improvements at Chaotic Inwood Intersection

Long-awaited improvements to a hazardous Broadway crossing in Inwood could be implemented next year, if Community Board 12 passes a resolution that cleared the board’s transportation committee this week. The committee and around 50 residents gathered Monday night to hear DOT’s proposals for the intersection of Broadway, Dyckman/200th Street and Riverside Drive [PDF], where pedestrians must […]

CB 3 Supports DOT’s Manhattan Bridge Proposal

  On Tuesday, Community Board 3 unanimously approved a resolution in support of DOT’s plans for improved Manhattan Bridge access, including bike lanes on Chrystie Street. Though members of the board’s transportation committee (along with Streetsbloggers) advocated for protected lanes, these recommendations were not included in the resolution, the full text of which appears after […]