Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Carnage

SI Motorist Who Killed Senior Mary Cerqua Pleads to Violating Victim’s Right of Way

Video showed Deborah Pecoraro strike Mary Cerqua while making a left turn into the crosswalk at Hylan Boulevard and Wiman Avenue. Image via NY1

A driver who killed a senior walking on Hylan Boulevard has pled guilty to violating the victim's right of way.

At around 9:24 a.m. on April 12, 2016, Deborah Pecoraro hit 73-year-old Mary Cerqua with a Nissan SUV while making a left turn into the crosswalk at Hylan and Wiman Avenue.

Mary Cerqua
Mary Cerqua
Mary Cerqua

Cerqua, who lived in Great Kills, sustained head trauma and died at Staten Island University Hospital.

The Daily News reported that Pecoraro, of Annadale, told police Cerqua caused the crash. NYPD routinely blames the victims of fatal traffic crashes based on the drivers' version of events, though those accounts are often proven false. In this case, video evidence showed the victim was following traffic rules when she was struck.

Court records say Pecoraro, then 55, was charged with a misdemeanor under the city's Right of Way Law, failure to exercise due care, and disorderly conduct -- a violation that includes a provision for disrupting vehicular or pedestrian traffic. She pled guilty earlier this month to the right of way charge and disorderly conduct.

Under the terms of the plea agreement, Pecoraro will take a driving course and participate in a victim impact panel, according to the Staten Island Advance. When those conditions are met, the misdemeanor conviction will be vacated, and Pecoraro will be sentenced to a conditional discharge for the disorderly conduct conviction and will be fined $250, the Advance reported.

The Advance says Pecoraro is the first Staten Island motorist to plead guilty to a Right of Way Law violation. Staten Island drivers have killed at least 18 people walking and biking since the law took effect in 2014, according to crash data tracked by Streetsblog. Drivers were known to be charged for taking victims' lives in four of those cases.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Cough, Cough: Adams Administration Hands Largest Ever Idling Law Exemption to NJ Charter Bus Company

Academy Bus Lines requested the exemption — the largest in DEP's history — after receiving more than $500,000 in idling violations. But there is some good news.

December 19, 2025

Hochul Will Veto Controversial Bill Mandating Two Operators on Most Subway Trains

The veto from Hochul came over the concerns of organized labor who saw the legislation as a way to make subway travel safer.

December 19, 2025

Pedestrian Killed by Hit-and-Run Driver on Crowded Lowest East Side Street

The driver kept going. EMTs took the badly injured woman to Bellevue Hospital, where she died.

December 19, 2025

NJ Legislature Poised to Pass Victim-Blaming E-Bike Restrictions

An e-bike registration bill is speeding through the New Jersey Legislature after several crashes in which drivers killed young cyclists.

December 19, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: Streets Master Plan Edition

Speaker Adrienne Adams explains why she didn't bother holding Mayor Adams accountable for following the law. Plus other news.

December 19, 2025

Streetsblog’s ‘Car-Free Carolers’ Bring the Joy, Mirth and Ho-Ho-Hope to this Holiday Season

Streetsblog's singers are back, belting out their parody classics to make a serious point: New York's roadways don't have to be dangerous places for kids and lungs, but can be joyous spaces for people to walk around, shop, eat or just ... hang out.

December 18, 2025
See all posts