Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Polly Trottenberg

A Call to Shake Up New York and New Jersey’s Anachronistic Transit Agencies

2:22 PM EDT on April 21, 2017

NYC does not get good bang-for-buck from its transit spending. Image: RPA

The first phase of the Second Avenue Subway, which opened years behind schedule, cost more per mile than any subway project in modern history. The ongoing East Side Access project connecting the Long Island Railroad to Grand Central Terminal is also years late and billions over budget. While cities like Paris have built dozens of miles of new rail in the last decade, the entire New York region has added just 13 miles.

There's no shortage of known culprits for New York's high transit construction costs -- infighting between agencies, inefficient work rules, and poor contracting and procurement practices, to name a few. While public awareness of the problem has been growing in fits and starts, action to address it has been lacking. And that won't change until there are clear consequences for the people in charge, panelists suggested this morning at the Regional Plan Association's annual assembly.

The region's current tangle of transportation authorities, with its surplus of turf wars and deficit of political accountability, isn't up to the task.

"What we really need to be thinking about is the accountability and governance model. That's the thing, I think, that undergirds all of what we're talking about," said DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg.

The agency Trottenberg leads has to navigate no fewer than three levels of government oversight and approvals -- city agencies like the Office of Budget and Management, plus state and federal entities. "For [DOT] projects, there's probably a 10 to 15 percent drag just dealing with the investigatory oversight side of the hat," she said.

For contrast, she pointed to the creation of Transport for London in 2000, which transferred control of London's transportation system from the national government to the city itself. The buck stops at the mayor's desk, which ensures accountability to voters while streamlining decision-making.  "The beneficiaries, the funding, the accountability -- there are much clearer lines," Trottenberg said.

"Reinventing" the region's public authorities will be a top recommendation in the RPA's fourth regional plan, set to be released in the fall, according to board member Rohit Aggarwala, who led the development of PlaNYC in the Bloomberg administration and now serves as chief policy officer at Sidewalk Labs.

"We are managing our transportation infrastructure through a set of organizations that are deeply flawed for the challenges that they face today: in what they control, in who they report to, in how they are organized, and in how they are funded," he said. "The times have changed, but our institutions have not."

Aggarwala said New York policymakers need to reconsider a model that divides the region's transit at the Hudson River, put its airports under the same management as the PATH train, and depends on the national rail operator -- Amtrak -- to manage Penn Station, the region's busiest commuter rail terminal.

A governance structure that functions more efficiently will also unlock more resources, he said. "The funding will come if the confidence is rebuilt. Other cities have the courage to recognize when their institutions have outlived their usefulness."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Congestion Pricing Opponents Are Blocking Disabled Access to Mass Transit, Politicians Charge

Just as the MTA begins speeding up new elevator construction, congestion pricing opponents are poised to stop it.

February 23, 2024

Legislation Introduced in Georgia to Fight Temporary License Plate Fraud

The bill is the most significant effort yet to stop the flow of fraudulent paper tags from Georgia car dealerships to New York City streets.

February 23, 2024

Community Board Backs DOT Road Diet for Brooklyn’s Deadly Third Av.

“This is just a beginning of what we could do to fix our community,” said one board member. “This is not done, this is not where we finish off.”

February 23, 2024

Friday’s Headlines: More Lunch Consumption Edition

Streetfilms goes to Paris. Plus more news.

February 23, 2024

Advocates Slam Albany Pols for Using Transit Fund to Encourage Driving

Gov. Hochul and state legislators in Albany are spending a congestion pricing-adjacent fund on toll rebates for drivers and showing zero interest in bus or rail, transit advocates charged.

February 23, 2024
See all posts