Brooklyn CB 4 Not Sold on Myrtle-Wyckoff Safety Overhaul Despite Lives Lost

The city held a successful one-day plaza at the location in April. Photo: David Meyer
A successful one-day plaza in April also wasn’t enough to convince the community board that the streets around the Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub need to change. Photo: David Meyer

Three people have been killed by turning drivers at the crowded Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub since 2009, and the local community board still won’t vote for a city plan to improve pedestrian safety at the complex six-legged intersection.

Last Wednesday, Brooklyn Community Board 4 declined to endorse DOT’s plan to simplify the intersection and create a car-free plaza on one block of Wyckoff Avenue between Myrtle and Gates [PDF]. Since the project straddles the Brooklyn-Queens border, DOT will also seek a vote from Queens Community Board 5’s transportation committee tomorrow evening.

People outnumber vehicles three-to-one at the Myrtle-Wyckoff intersection, which is located at the convergence of two subway lines and six bus routes. The current configuration leads to too many conflicts between drivers and pedestrians: Three pedestrians were killed there between 2009 and 2014.

Two and a half years ago, hundreds of people gathered at the intersection to remember Ella Bandes, who was struck and killed by a bus driver in 2013, and call for safety improvements. Minor changes afterward were not enough to prevent the death of Edgar Torres, who had the right of way when he was struck and killed by a turning MTA bus driver in 2014.

Making a block of Wyckoff car-free would do what previous adjustments could not: give pedestrians safe passage between the train and the Ridgewood Bus Terminal on Palmetto Street. Turning movements would be dramatically simplified, reducing potential conflicts.

CB 4 District Manager Nadine Whitted could not provide a vote tally from Wednesday’s meeting but said only two board members sided in favor of the project. Whitted did not explain why the board rejected the project other than to say members did not like the “bus reroutes,” by which she was presumably referring to the B26, which currently utilizes the block of Wyckoff that would be pedestrianized.

Reconfiguring this dangerous intersection with a car-free plaza will simplify vehicle movements and reduce the potential for turning drivers to hit pedestrians. Image: DOT
Reconfiguring this dangerous intersection with a car-free plaza will simplify vehicle movements and reduce the potential for turning drivers to hit pedestrians. Image: DOT

Florent Morellet attended the meeting and was the only member of the public to speak in favor of the project. He said some attendees suggested that the three victims had been killed because they put themselves in harm’s way. “The only reasonable person that was there was our councilman, [Antonio Reynoso], who stood up and said that this is hateful speech,” said Morellet. “He said, you know, I’m not going to sit here silently if there is going to be more hateful speech.”

Community board votes hold no legal sway over DOT or its projects, but in practice the department often scales back or even cancels street safety projects at the behest of local community boards. Reynoso has consistently argued that DOT should not let community boards obstruct street safety projects.

Ella Bandes’s parents, Judy Kottick and Ken Bandes, said they were disappointed by the board’s failure to support the project. “It’s so disheartening because every day we go without doing anything — I mean, it’s Russian roulette,” Kottick said. “It could be you [who gets killed], it could be someone on the community board, it could be someone else’s child.”

Kottick and Bandes said they heard about Wednesday’s meeting too late to attend, but have found CB 4 to be more concerned with driver convenience than pedestrian safety. When the board’s transportation committee reacted to the project in May, Bandes said, “They were mainly concerned about the driving issues and how convenient it would be to be dropped off and cross the street.”

Queens CB 5 has been much more responsive to the pedestrian safety concerns at the intersection, Kottick and Bandes said. In March, CB 5 Chair Vincent Arcuri told Streetsblog that while it was not his preference to make any streets car-free, he understood that other interventions had failed to make the intersection safe.

“Something has to be done, obviously,” he said at the time. “We’ve tried different things and we still haven’t stopped the fatalities. I have mixed feelings about the plaza, but what else can you do?”

Tomorrow’s transportation committee meeting gets underway at the Queens CB 5 office, 61-23 Myrtle Avenue, at 7:30 p.m.

  • Brian Howald

    DOT should come to these meetings with waivers, stating that by failing to endorse its safety plans, community boards are assuming any financial liability that the city should face for suits stemming from crashes at these locations.

  • We care what CB4 has to say because…………..?

    Oh right. Because DOT is too spineless to do anything that a bunch of cranks on a community board might object to.

  • Jeff

    Three people have been killed here since 2009. Everyone who speaks out against the project at the community board meeting should be required to point to three people in the room whose death they would be willing to accept in order to maintain the status quo.

  • greenlake101

    Community boards do not truly represent their communities. I recommend you all go to at least one board meeting in your neighborhood. You will find that the attendees and board-members are overwhelmingly older, white, and concerned with drivers above everyone else.

    In this instance, the DOT did a survey (linked to in the article) and 95% of respondents said yes to a permanent plaza. The survey also showed that only 5% of people at the location arrived by car. I hope the DOT goes ahead with this project that will save lives and improve the neighborhood. It’s clear that while the neighborhood is in favor of the project, the board only cares about their own opinions, not the opinions of residents.

  • squidonabike

    DOT and the Mayor’s Office have to stop being so afraid of a few old cranks on the community boards. If the board can offer some constructive input or show some legitimate reason to alter a safety plan, fine. Otherwise hear them out and move forward. They have no real power over street safety and when they talk nonsense they should be ignored.

  • Several others in the area that are bad as well. See searchable database map.


Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza Gets Near-Unanimous Approval From Queens CB 5

With 29 votes in favor, none against, and one abstention, Queens Community Board 5 overwhelmingly endorsed DOT’s safety plan for the Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub last night. The project would significantly reduce potential conflicts between turning drivers and pedestrians, mainly by creating a car-free plaza on Wyckoff Avenue between Gates and Myrtle [PDF]. Pedestrians outnumber motorists at the six-legged Myrtle-Wyckoff […]

Antonio Reynoso: DOT Should Forge Ahead With Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza

Council Member Antonio Reynoso wants DOT to move forward with its safety plan at the busy Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub, with or without the endorsement of the local community board. Last Wednesday, Brooklyn Community 4 voted against DOT’s plan, which would dramatically reduce potential conflicts between drivers and pedestrians and create a car-free plaza on one block of Wyckoff Avenue between Myrtle and […]

Tonight: Queens Community Board 5 Takes Up Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza

Queens Community Board 5 will vote on DOT’s safety plan for the Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub at its monthly meeting this evening. The plan, which creates a one-block public plaza on Wyckoff Avenue between Gates and Myrtle [PDF], won near-unanimous support from the CB 5 transportation committee three weeks ago. Since 2009, three pedestrians have been killed by drivers at […]

Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza Gets Support From Queens CB 5 Transpo Committee

Last night, the Queens Community Board 5 transportation committee endorsed DOT’s safety plan for the Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub on the border between Brooklyn and Queens, including the creation of a one-block pedestrian plaza on Wyckoff Avenue between Gates and Myrtle [PDF]. The project straddles two community board districts and was voted down by Brooklyn CB 4 […]