An All-Too-Real Hollywood Tale of New York City Traffic Justice

When I happened upon the trailer for “Margaret” I could scarcely believe it. Did Hollywood really make an A-lister movie about a New York City pedestrian who is struck and killed by an MTA bus driver? I thought it must surely be a secondary plot line, the shared trauma that serves to catalyze a love affair between beautiful witnesses or some such. For the most part, I was wrong.

I’ll be giving away a plot point or two here, so for the spoiler-averse I’ll say this: If you read Streetsblog closely enough to know what the “rule of two” is, you should watch this film.

If you’ve never heard of “Margaret,” neither had I. It was shot in 2005, and according to my cursory research its release was delayed due to legal issues. There may have been other factors. It’s overlong and there are story threads that don’t really lead anywhere, including one that seems shoehorned in for the sole purpose of having Matt Damon in the credits. But as an obsessive observer of New York’s broken traffic justice system, I have to be impressed it exists at all.

Anna Paquin plays Lisa, a spoiled and narcissistic teenager who, while walking along Broadway on the Upper West Side, tries to get the attention of a passing MTA bus driver, Gerald, played by Mark Ruffalo. Instead of ignoring Lisa or stopping the bus to ask what she wants — she likes his cowboy hat — Gerald drives on, looking toward the sidewalk instead of the street ahead. At the next corner he runs the light and hits a middle-aged woman, Monica, portrayed by Allison Janney. In a tortuously long and graphic scene, Monica dies in the street as approaching sirens wail in the background.

In the Hollywood version of a New York crash scene, detectives in suits and ties immediately swoop in to question the driver and witnesses. When a detective asks if Lisa saw the traffic light, she lies, telling him it was green. With a touch of what I can only imagine was unintended verisimilitude, the investigation scene only lasts a few seconds.

Lisa reveals to her family that she lied about the light because she didn’t want Gerald to lose his job. But when she learns that he has a history of crashes, and a visit to his home (in Bay Ridge) proves him to be an unapologetic lout, she decides to set the record straight — partly for Monica, mostly to assuage her own guilt.

Once the detective explains to Lisa that, despite her recanted story, Gerald won’t be charged with a crime — because he wasn’t breaking two traffic laws at the time of the crash — she tries to have him fired by convincing a relative of Monica’s to file a civil suit. I won’t give any more away except to say that Lisa gets a hard and utterly believable lesson in New York City traffic justice.

Writer and director Kenneth Lonergan weaves in nuanced bits that the general public would probably overlook, or accept as a given regardless of context: long and languid shots of ceaseless vehicle traffic, the rage of Monica’s best friend at the “stupid, meaningless” way she died. In one scene, Monica’s loved ones gather in the best friend’s apartment for an intimate, informal wake. If I could change one thing about “Margaret” (other than the title, which is another story) it would be to somehow emphasize how many times a similar scene actually occurs somewhere in the city during any given month — that it’s not just Hollywood.

  • Ray Kelly

    I give this film two thumbs way way up.

  • Cyclist101

    I had a chance to see it when it was briefly in theaters earlier this year. A film well worth seeing. 

  • Oh my god, that was frightening to see, and think this movie represents only one of thousands of deaths due to negligence by irresponsible motorists.

    Also, I got so mad when she said the light was green!

  • Clarence Eckerson Jr.

    I went to go see it a few months ago when released, but the box office was so bad it got yanked from most theaters after one week.

  • Lisa Sladkus

    This is such an upsetting and important film. Please see it and get re-charged to fight the fight for safer streets. 

  • Kelly Mary Beth

    Watching “Margaret” as a survivor, psychotherapist, and mother, I recommend viewing by all New Yorkers. This excellent film captures a realistic rendering of our abysmal legal labyrinth, which following trauma, compounds suffering. Portraying the insidious nature of such trauma, Lisa is struggling in its aftermath with pain, guilt, and confusion. The kind of community atunement that survivors of trauma need is achingly absent for this young women whom I do no experience as spoiled, but already a product of parental emotional absence. She seeks and acutely needs connection to heal. I personally found an important part of my own healing (which doesn’t come to any neat closure) through my connecion to advocates for livable streets (TA in particular) for which I will be forever grateful.

  • Niccolo Machiavelli

    Another nail in the MTA’s coffin.


Going Nowhere Fast

This weekend’s City section of the New York Times featured a mind-blowing essay by children’s-book writer Sarah Shey about her habit of taking her one-year-old son out for drives in the city — drives with no destination or purpose in mind, in which she crossed and recrossed the Brooklyn Bridge endless times. Shey, who is […]

Another Model: Berkeley’s Bicycle Boulevard Network

Yesterday I showed some photos of the "Share the Road" Bike Route signs that were recently installed on Fifth Avenue in Brooklyn and that sparked an interesting discussion on different possible ways to design and build on-street bike paths. This summer I was in Berkeley, California for a friend’s wedding. NYCSR filmmaker Clarence Eckerson was […]

Traffic’s Human Toll

For the last two years or so Transportation Alternatives’ Karla Quintero has been working on a New York City-based update of the famous "Appleyard Study" examining the social costs of traffic. Karla presented the study’s preliminary findings last year at a forum I helped organize in Brooklyn and it was really interesting. This event is sure to be a […]

Congestion Charging in New York City: The Political Bloodbath

Though many New Yorkers are learning about congestion charging for the first time this week, the transportation policy community has been working to sell this idea to a resistant public for more than three decades. What happens when Nobel Prize winning theory meets bare-fisted New York City politics? A heavily condensed version of this story ran in this week’s […]