Albany Unlikely to OK Speed Cameras This Year

The state legislature will not allow New York City to enforce its speed limit using automated cameras this session, say street safety advocates. Though the New York Times touted the legislation’s forward momentum in an article yesterday, the bill is unlikely to pass the Assembly before the legislative session closes this week.

“For all intents and purposes, we’re looking at next year,” said Transportation Alternatives general counsel Juan Martinez.

Speed cameras made significant progress in Albany this year. Staten Island Republican Andrew Lanza signed on as the Senate sponsor of the legislation, giving advocates new confidence in its ability to pass that chamber. “Senator Lanza promised that it would pass the Senate this week,” said Martinez. “I think that would be a huge boost.”

In the Assembly, however, safety supporters were unable to recruit enough individual legislators to overcome the consistent opposition of Transportation Committee Chair David Gantt to the use of cameras to enforce traffic rules (or to force Speaker Sheldon Silver’s hand).

Martinez felt optimistic about the bill’s future chances in Albany, though. “They understand speeding is a problem,” he said. “They all get dozens of requests a week for speed bumps and stop signs. They just have to make the connection that predictable enforcement is the only way to solve this citywide.” He pointed to strong support for speed camera enforcement from more car-dependent parts of the city, like Staten Island, as evidence that the idea has broad-based support.

Martinez also guessed that pending legislation to increase penalties for dangerous driving — such as bills to eliminate an incentive for drunk drivers to flee the scene of a crash or to create a three-strikes policy to rescind driver’s licenses — would not pass this year.

  • disappointing. extremely disappointing.  while, i’m excited for bike share, love our new pedestrian plazas, and want to improve mass transit all over in my personal opinion, these battles against the NYPD’s lack of investigation/concern and Albany’s tangled mess of laws which keep deadly drivers behind the wheel… those are the absolute most important things for us as advocates to fight for and win. our lives are literally on the line.  

  • Mark Walker

    Gantt and Silver have blood on their hands.

  • Ben Kintisch

    Absolutely right, Mr. Paco. Just outside my door, on Brooklyn’s Bedford Avenue, drivers speed with impunity through a densely populated neighborhood, zooming past schools, a YMCA, churches, and thousands of residents. Are speeders ever ticketed? Hardly ever. Without speed cameras throughout the camera, we’re stuck relying on NYPD to enforce safety…and we know how that goes…”

  • Bronxite

    When this does come, eventually, I hope they focus on residential and commercial/retail streets. Sure, a camera on the FDR may bring more revenue but the difference in quality of life one would bring to 3rd Avenue is immeasurable.


Albany’s Slimmed-Down Speed Cam Legislation Could Cross the Finish Line

This afternoon, the City Council passed a home rule resolution calling on Albany to pass legislation enabling speed enforcement cameras in school zones. The last time there was action on speed camera legislation, more than two months ago, Mayor Bloomberg was chastising state senators Marty Golden, Simcha Felder, and Dean Skelos for torpedoing the program in the Senate’s budget […]

Lanza Introduces Amended Speed Cam Bill in State Senate

Albany legislation to let New York City enforce its speed limit using automated cameras got a new lease on life last week. A slate of amendments have made the bill more politically palatable, and Staten Island Republican Andrew Lanza has introduced a version of the bill in the State Senate, the first time this version […]