Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
PlaNYC

PlaNYC 2.0 Reactions: Rachel Weinberger, UPenn Professor

Streetsblog has been gathering responses to last week's release of PlaNYC 2.0. This is the fourth installment. Read the firstsecond, and third parts.

In a phone interview with Streetsblog yesterday, Rachel Weinberger, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania and an architect of the transportation section of PlaNYC 1.0, gave us her take on the update of the city's sustainability plan.

On setting expectations:

The first PlaNYC seemed really bold in the transportation area. Maybe it seemed much bolder than we would think if it were to come out today.

On the significance of PlaNYC 1.0:

The shift in thinking is far more important than the specific projects that were enumerated in the first go.

One of the big accomplishments of PlaNYC 1.0 was that it got City Hall thinking in a way that opened City Hall up to the idea of hiring a [transportation] commissioner like JSK.

On parking policy:

The parking stuff [in the update] is a little bit anemic. But in PlaNYC 1.0 we couldn't even touch it, it was considered untouchable. It was our judgment that congestion pricing had more legs than taking on the parking question. That's telling.

Since we tried to break open that barrier, there's been maybe a gestation period for the city to start coming around to thinking, "Okay, here's an area of public policy that we can and should address." ... Now we're on the threshold of being able to look at it in a robust kind of way. Now let's do it.

On paving the way for other cities:

The first one also created space in other places, like Chicago and Washington. The sustainability director of Philadelphia went all around Philadelphia waving around PlaNYC, saying, "We're going to steal everything we can from this document."

Other cities benefited from the hard work that we did. It might be too much to push that hard again right away.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

A Father Speaks: Here’s Why The Speed Limit Must Be 20 MPH Everywhere

At an event on Wednesday, no one was more eloquent than the spotlight-avoiding father of the boy for whom Sammy's Law is named.

October 9, 2024

Council Bill Would Shift Taxi Driver Crash Costs onto Victims: Experts

Lower insurance for cabbies could mean higher costs for crash victims.

October 9, 2024

Wednesday Headlines: What is ‘News’ Edition

We'd much rather be writing about the Mets than counterpunching the DOT for barring us from a briefing. But that's where we are. Plus other news.

October 9, 2024

Gale Brewer Flips on E-Bike Registration Due To ‘Nasty’ Pressure

The former Manhattan borough president says she supports banning e-bikes from parks and a state campaign to require licensing.

October 8, 2024

Is Amtrak’s Big Dig Harming West Baltimore’s Black Neighborhoods?

Amtrak's single biggest infrastructure project got hit with a civil rights complaint. How should sustainable transportation advocates get involved in the conversation?

October 8, 2024
See all posts