Lynn Nunes Gets Stage All to Himself at District 10 Transpo Q&A

It turns out that Shirley Huntley was the no-show at Wednesday night’s State Senate District 10 transportation debate, letting challenger Lynn Nunes turn in a solo performance. Nunes is young — 25 — but he’s commanding attention in this race after coming within four votes of unseating the recently deceased Thomas White in the City Council’s 28th District last year, despite a near total lack of institutional backing.

Lynn Nunes.
Lynn Nunes.

Before an audience of about 20 at the Q&A session, Nunes came across as eager to support safer streets and better transportation options, but lacking a firm grasp of the most pressing problems facing New York’s transit system.

This southeastern Queens district stretches up from Broad Channel, curving through the neighborhoods north of JFK and over to Forest Hills. The subway network doesn’t reach very deep here, and neighborhoods are criss-crossed by dangerous traffic sewers like Atlantic Avenue, Merrick Boulevard, and service roads for the Van Wyck. Still, more than a third of households do not own a car.

“It’s very isolated,” said Nunes in response to a question about whether bike lanes belong in the district. “That’s why we have to make investments in bus routes, in safe bikeways — to give people access.” If elected, he said his first priority would be to address the lack of transportation options in southeast Queens, and he sensibly identified the bus network as the area most ripe for improvements. He also promised to direct some of his discretionary funds (a.k.a. member items) to street safety projects.

As for how to pay for transit improvements when the system is starved and shrinking, Nunes refused to rule anything out. He listed his top choices as raising the gas tax and imposing a commuter tax, calling bridge tolls and congestion pricing acceptable as last resorts. (He gave a noticeably more enthusiastic endorsement of congestion pricing in his response to the TA/TSTC transportation survey, which Huntley failed to fill out.)

The most telling moment of the evening came when a woman in the audience described how she reacts to press coverage of the MTA. “Every day I open the paper and there’s some story about how the MTA is wasting money,” she said. “Long Island Railroad pensions, audits, laying off workers while hiring $200,000 executives — the gravy train has got to stop. I resent every penny I pay.”

That must be the sort of reaction that Shelly Silver, John Sampson, and most of the New York-area politicos in Albany love to hear. The state legislature stole enough cash from the MTA in December to prevent all of the agency’s service cuts, but here we are right before primary day, and this voter just wants to know who’s going to stop the MTA gravy train.

Nunes could have pivoted from this question to pillory the incumbent legislators who let the MTA’s finances reach the sorry state they’re in today, but he didn’t. “I think it’s mismanagement that’s built up over the years,” he said, referring to the MTA.

He did get in a few digs at Albany after I asked what the legislature could do to prevent the theft of transit funds from happening again. While the message was a little muddled, he implied that transit tax revenue should only go toward transit. “I think that’s part of the problem with the culture in Albany,” he said. “It’s important to treat each entity separately.”

Nunes told Streetsblog that there is “absolutely no truth” to the rumor that he’s looking to drop his State Senate bid and enter the race for White’s City Council seat, which will be filled in a special non-partisan election on November 2. Claire Trapasso at the Daily News, who moderated the Q&A, reports that Nunes may look to enter the council race if he doesn’t win the State Senate primary.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Let’s see if the press covers this “debate.” It is entirely predictable that an incumbent wouldn’t want to participate in the process of an election. They owe their sinecures to the absence of elections in New York.

    Huntley, like the rest of them, knows the people getting paid will show up and vote for her. If no one else bothers, it is her fault of theirs?

  • Love seeing the politicians focusing on matters of daily importance. Anything that help increase the likelihood of enforcing bike and bus lanes!

  • ddartley

    Ooooh, I like that phrase “traffic sewer.” I thought perhaps you had just coined it Ben, but I googled it and I guess not. Nevertheless I shall commence using it at every opportunity and I hope to see it spread, in the hopes that it nudges public thinking about the costs vs. benefits of road capacity.

  • I think I picked up the term from Jeff Wood at Reconnecting America. It’s a good one.

  • And what do you call a place that’s full of traffic sewers? The national automobile slum (JH Kunstler).

  • Truth Seeker

    Ben, your story is totally flawed. I wonder if you’re receiving a paycheck from the Nunes Campaign. The Daily News reported that the transportation group had in fact LIED to them by stating Senator Huntley was a no-show.

    I don’t think it’s fair to build a campaign on negative and untruthful information, therefore you need to get your facts straight. In addition, as a constituent residing in Senator Huntley’s District, I have attended several debates in which Mr. Nunes was confirmed but never showed up. Maybe it’s because he was focused on his race for the City Council.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Challenger Nunes Attends Transpo Debate; Incumbent Huntley a No-Show

|
UPDATE: Strike the original post (formerly titled: “Challenger Nunes Reportedly Backs Out of Transportation Debate”). Lynn Nunes did answer questions at tonight’s District 10 transportation debate, while longtime incumbent Shirley Huntley did not attend. We’ll have details from the event tomorrow. Lynn Nunes, the challenger going up against Shirley Huntley in the State Senate’s 10th […]

Three Transpo Debates Coming Up in First Week of September

|
This November, New York voters will elect the occupants of every seat in the State Senate and Assembly, as well as their next governor, attorney general, and comptroller. For many races in heavily Democratic New York City, the deciding moment will come a lot sooner — on primary day. That’s just two weeks away on […]

A New Vision for the Meatpacking District

|
The Gansevoort Project Aims to Turn a Chaotic Intersection into a Grand Piazza At Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer’s transportation policy conference last week, DOT Commissioner Iris Weinshall said she was committed to working "with communities and other city agencies to reallocate street space" to "create public plazas in neighborhoods in all five boroughs." "These […]

Participatory Budgeting Will Fund 21 Livable Streets Projects

|
The votes are in, and 21 livable streets projects got enough support to be funded in this year’s round of participatory budgeting. All told, 124 projects made the cut and will receive City Council funds [PDF]. In dollar terms, the streets projects will account for $5.1 million of the $32.5 million distributed by council members. During the participatory budgeting process, […]

Council Candidates on the Issues: Yetta Kurland, District 3

|
In anticipation of primary day on September 10, we continue our series on City Council candidates with a Q&A with civil rights lawyer Yetta Kurland, who’s running to represent District 3. The district covers Midtown, Hell’s Kitchen, Chelsea, and the West Village, and it’s currently represented by Council Speaker Christine Quinn. Yesterday we posted responses from District 3 […]