Why Car Chases Are Never Worth the Risk

Peter Moskos is a former Baltimore police officer and an assistant professor at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice. A version of this essay also appeared on his blog, Cop in the Hood, and in the West Side Spirit.

Karen Schmeer, a friend of a dear friend, was killed on January 29 while carrying groceries home on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. She was killed by a speeding car filled with drug-shoplifting hoodlums fleeing the police. The impact knocked her out of her boots and flung her through the air, half a city block.

Let me be clear: the police did not kill Karen Schmeer. Criminals did. Let them rot. But their guilt does not absolve the police of responsibility.

Karen’s death is more than a simple tragedy. Karen wasn’t just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Karen might be alive if police did not bend or break the exact rules put in place to prevent this kind of senseless death.

Let me be clear: the police did not kill Karen Schmeer. Criminals did. Let them rot. But their guilt does not absolve the police of responsibility.

While it is the job of police to catch crooks, it’s not always their job to chase crooks. Not in cars. Cars are dangerous.

Police say they weren’t in pursuit at the time of the crash, but witnesses, according to the Daily News, “saw the car weaving in and out of traffic going north on Broadway with a squad car with lights and sirens blaring in hot pursuit.” Why the discrepancy? Because police should never be chasing suspects up Broadway at 8 p.m.

You don’t need to pull the trigger to be guilty of murder. You don’t have to want to kill somebody. You do need to accept the likely consequences of your actions. This is what moral responsibility is about.

New York, like most cities, forbids car chases “whenever the risks to [police] and the public outweigh the danger to the community if the suspect is not immediately apprehended.” That’s pretty much all the time unless it’s Osama Bin Laden himself at the wheel.

Car chases aren’t worth it. They often end in some crash. And the pursued car does not have the emergency lights and sirens to warn people out of the way. The car that killed Karen didn’t even have its headlights on.

The NYPD pursuit policy is based on the only effective way to reduce the danger of a car chase: don’t do it. For police, it’s as simple as it is unsatisfying.

Police love a good chase, and there are informal rules to keep your supervisor from stopping the fun. Don’t “chase.” Instead, “follow.” Don’t get on the radio unless your voice is calm and your siren is off. When the suspects bail and run, the one you catch is the driver. If, God forbid, something really bad happens, say you lost contact before it happened.

We all know that driving is dangerous — especially so for police — and we all know people who have been hurt and killed in car crashes. When I was a rookie cop on the streets of Baltimore and driving too fast to some call, I was confronted by my partner: “Do you know anybody [out there]!? Would you cry if anybody died?!” My sergeant put it another way, “I think of my wife or children in a car. They may die. For what?” This was the wisdom of experience. The message was simple: slow down.

Still I couldn’t resist the thrill of the chase. I remember one fondly, on small empty city streets in the middle of the night. A guy with a van was speeding, ran a red light, and wouldn’t pull over. It ended OK. The guy bailed and didn’t crash. I caught him. Nobody got hurt. I had a blast.

Three months later, when the judge saw my suspect in court, he said, “I know you! You’re a drug dealer.”

Taken off guard, the young man replied meekly, “I used to be a drug dealer.” Then he requested a jury trial. When I talked to him later, he said, “That judge doesn’t like me. I used to deal, but I don’t play that no more.”

“Then why did you run?” I asked.

“I didn’t have a license… And I was little drunk.” He was also backing up five years of prison time. He got off with a $500 fine for a suspended license.

I didn’t need to chase that guy, but I did it for the thrill. When I look back, I count my lucky stars nobody was killed. I made a dangerous situation worse by going the wrong way down one-way streets and pushing another driver past his limits.

Had Karen Schmeer walked in front of the car I was pursuing that night and been killed, I would have tried to cover my ass with the exact words a NYPD spokesman used in this case: “Cops tried to pull over the suspects minutes before the crash, but they lost the car momentarily. When they caught up with the vehicle, it had already struck Schmeer, as well as several other vehicles.” Maybe that’s true.

But I’m at least willing to say I was wrong.

  • BB

    Thank you for the truth! I couldn’t live in that town way to many cops 49,000 of them.

  • There are about 35,000 police officers in New York City. And like most New Yorkers, I love living here. And that is in no small part due to the hard work and dedication of those police officers.

  • The only good thing that could come of this terrible tragedy is for NYPD, DA’s office and general citizenry to recognize that traffic crime presents a much bigger problem than most property crimes and should be allocated law enforcement resources accordingly.

    For example, it takes about an hour of two cops’ time to make out an accident report just so that drivers’ insurers can more easily adjust or litigate claims over car damage. Cops should be relieved of making accident reports except in cases where a live person was injured. Forcing cops to provide these investigative services for fender benders is just another way the public is forced to subsidize vehicle ownership. Or, continue to provide the reports, but make people pay serious money for them, not $15 or whatever the fee currently is.

  • BB

    Yes like most New Yorkers and that’s good for New Yorkers. Wikipedia numbers you got 1 officer per 237 people. Phoenix has 1 per 437 people. They are pretty close on square mileage. Estimated. Arizona is an open carry state. New York

    I think much like paramedics and firefighters they are needed and appreciated. But like the airport we tend to loose our self in feeling safe or wanting instant contact by authority.

  • Here in Bristol, England, the police moved from cars to helicopters to track stolen cars, put “stinger” intercepts in ahead. It works way better for catching the cars and eliminates the whole chase problem -there isn’t a pursuing car to escape from, so the stolen cars drive less aggressively. And when they eventually abandon their cars, the infrared cameras catch where they are hiding. Chasing cars with other cars is the wrong solution.

  • LN

    Quoting NYC Police Department Patrol Guide Manual (2006 = latest edition currently available) p 764 P.G. 212-39

    “Department requires that a vehicle pursuit be terminated whenever the risks to uniformed members of the service and the public outweigh the danger to the community. If suspect is not immediately apprehended…”

    — a librarian

  • BicyclesOnly

    Time to re-institute the arithmetic test for blocking robo-comments.

  • West Side Watcher


NYPD Admits Error in Pedestrian Death, Says Chases Off-Limits

Karen Schmeer. Image: New York Times The NYPD is no longer denying its involvement — or error — in the January 29 car chase that ended with the death of Karen Schmeer on the Upper West Side. At a meeting of the 24th Precinct’s community council, Deputy Inspector Kathleen O’Reilly laid out the police’s official […]

DA Begins Inquiry Into NYPD-Involved Pedestrian Fatality

Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance’s office is beginning an inquiry into the collision that killed Karen Schmeer last Friday, and expects to review all circumstances leading up the crash, according to a spokesperson. Witnesses cited by the Daily News say cops pursued three men suspected of petty theft at an Upper West Side pharmacy before […]

Why Must a Driver Be Drunk or Fleeing Cops to Be Prosecuted for Killing?

On Tuesday, Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance announced the sentencing of Dyson Williams, the driver who killed Mary Celine Graham while attempting to evade police. On June 22, 2010, police investigating a string of gunpoint robberies stopped a minivan occupied by Williams and William Robbins near W. 142nd Street and Adam Clayton Powell Boulevard, according to […]

The Weekly Carnage

The Weekly Carnage is a Friday round-up of motor vehicle mayhem across the five boroughs and beyond. For more on the origins and purpose of this column, please read About the Weekly Carnage. Karen Schmeer. Photo: Garret Savage Fatal Crashes (2 Killed This Week*, 24 This Year, 5 Drivers Charged**) Pedestrian Karen Schmeer, 39, Killed […]