DA Offers Plea to Road Rager Gonzalez

20090521_AssaultOnCyclistD_1.jpgThe DA’s office has not contacted the witness who took this photograph of Gus Gonzalez last May.

At a hearing in criminal court on Monday, Manhattan prosecutors offered a plea deal to Gus Gonzalez, the driver who assaulted cyclist Ray Bengen in the Ninth Avenue bike lane last May.

Gonzalez had been charged with third degree assault, a misdemeanor offense. The offer from the DA’s office would reduce the charge to disorderly conduct, classified as a violation (which would not appear on Gonzalez’s criminal record). Gonzalez would have to complete one day of community service if he accepts the plea, which he declined to do on Monday, asking instead for the case to be dismissed pending good behavior.

Dave Rankin, an attorney who often represents cyclists, told me it’s common for prosecutors to offer this type of deal when the original charge is third degree assault. But how seriously has the DA’s office pursued the case? The witness who photographed the assault — in which Gonzalez knocked Bengen to the pavement with the door of his Ford Excursion, badly bruising Bengen’s leg, then drove away from the scene — says neither police nor prosecutors have contacted him about what happened.

"I never got any contact from anybody," said the witness, who declined to give his name, citing concerns for his safety. He described the dooring as a seemingly willful effort by Gonzalez to harm Bengen. "Ray was next to the SUV, basically next to the door. He was barely moving. I think [Gonzalez] intentionally knocked him down."

Given the DA’s large misdemeanor caseload, Rankin said, it’s not unusual for witnesses to go unquestioned at this stage of the legal process. The Gonzalez case may not go to trial, and Assistant District Attorneys typically don’t contact witnesses until immediately before a trial gets underway.

Though the circumstances and severity of the crime differ, the consequences for Gonzalez still stand in marked contrast to the sentence recently handed down to L.A. road rager Dr. Christopher Thompson, who got five years for using his car to injure two cyclists.

"[Gonzalez] didn’t kill Ray, but it was an assault," said the witness, "and he ought to have it on his record."

  • As long as windshield perspective rules the system, assault will be OK as long as you do it with a car.

  • NattyB

    Oh man,

    I would’ve smashed that guys window with my lock. But then, I’d be the guy with the summons and complaint.

    Rule #1 about biking in the city: Don’t get allow yourself to become angry.

  • The problem is that this guy should never have been charged with such a measly initial charge – 3rd degree assault. Sure it’s standard procedure to plead that down, because that charge is meant for much more minor acts of battery. He should have been charged at the minimum with a class E felony, leaving them much more latitude for reducing the charge for a fair plea deal.

  • Whatever happened to a speedy trial? Witnesses can move out of state or become unavailable in the year it seems to take for this case to be resolved. Gonzalez appears to be a nudnik of the first water, but even jerks deserve timely justice.

  • I feel compelled to reiterate that Ray Bergen did a dumb thing by attempting to pass an SUV via schluffing w/ no room to maneuver.

    Strongly recommend one pass a so-parked SUV on the right, in the left-turn lane, while belling, and optionally hockin a lugie at his windshield.

  • Bill from Brooklyn

    Does anyone know if Bergen has brought a civil case against Gonzalez? I hope he has.

  • Also, ten bucks says the only people it’s illegal to mow down with your car while “the sun’s in your eyes” are:



Legal Ordeal Continues for Driver Assault Victim Ray Bengen

Ray Bengen had his day in Manhattan Criminal Court this morning, but it might not be his last appearance at 100 Centre Street. Hit with a potential "criminal mischief" charge by the Manhattan DA’s office after getting doored, bruised, and screamed at by an SUV driver in the Ninth Avenue bike lane (allegedly this man: […]

Road Rage Victim’s Reputation Smeared Until Proven Innocent

Ray Bengen, pictured on the sidewalk below his assailant, is paying a steep price for defending himself while riding in the Ninth Avenue bike lane. Following Brad’s post last week about one pedestrian’s encounter with an enraged driver and the NYPD, I caught up with Ray Bengen, another New Yorker charged with criminal mischief after […]