Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Streetsblog

Blaming Cyclists for Dangerous Roads: It Goes Way Back

On Bicyclelaw.com yesterday, there was a terrible story out of Canada about a crash involving a reckless motorist and law-abiding cyclists.

What was the response to the shocking case of careless driving, which left five bikers gravely injured? The local police initiated a ticket blitz aimed at…cyclists breaking the law (one of the offenses often cited was a failure to have a bell on the bicycle). It's reminiscent of the recent crackdown on jaywalking in Savannah in response to a pedestrian death.

Rick Bernardi writes on the blog that people on bikes should certainly obey the rules of the road. But:

3097166595_15057244b0.jpgHow safe are these streets? And who is really responsible? Photo from Copenhagenize.

All that said, didn’t it strike anybody -- anybody? -- at the Ottawa Police Service that in
rounding up “the usual suspects,” they just might be targeting the
wrong people? If they were truly attempting to develop an enforcement
response to a shocking and horrific crash -- and there’s no reason to
believe that they weren’t sincere in their response -- would it make any
sense at all to target cyclists? After all, the cyclists injured in the
crash were all law-abiding cyclists, riding in the bicycle lane, and
run down by a driver who never hit his brakes, continued driving for
another 400 feet as he hit one cyclist after another, and then with his
victims lying critically injured on the roadway behind him, continued
on his way as if nothing had happened.

The strategy of targeting more vulnerable users in efforts to improve road safety is nothing new. The Copenhagenize blog is running a fascinating series on the perception and reality of cycling safety by Dave Horton, a sociologist in the UK. In a post today, Horton goes into the history of how a "fear of cycling" was "constructed" -- and how the onus for staying safe was placed not on drivers of motor vehicles, but on pedestrians and cyclists:

The transformation of streets for people into roads for cars,perhaps inevitably, produced death and injury. By 1936 concerns aboutthe alarming rise in cyclist casualties had led to the idea of acycling proficiency scheme, eventually adopted nationally in 1948 (CTC2005). To stem the carnage, cyclists must be trained to deal with thenew, dangerous conditions. But things could have been otherwise. A 1947book by J. S. Dean, former Chairman of the Pedestrians’ Association, isinstructive here. In his "study of the road deaths problem," Murder Most Foul,Dean's basic tenet is that, "as roads are only 'dangerous' by virtue ofbeing filled with heavy fast-moving motor vehicles, by far the greatestburden of responsibility for avoiding crashes, deaths and injury on theroads should lie with the motorist" (Peel n.d., 3).

Yet roadsafety education concentrates not on the drivers of vehicles, but onthose who they have the capacity to kill. Dean saw how placingresponsibility for road danger on those outside of motorised vehiclesmight lead, by stealth, to placing of culpability on those groups, andMurder Most Foul is a tirade against the placing of responsibility forroad accidents on children.

This history is especially relevant in light of the recent wave of prohibitions on cycling to school in this country that Brad wrote about earlier this week.

Special cognitive dissonance bonus: an item on the Wall Street Journal website about Tea Party protesters who went to Washington to complain about government spending of taxpayer money, and then were dissatisfied with the city's taxpayer-funded Metro (h/t Trains for America).

Some of them, apparently, even had to resort to the free-market taxi system.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Thursday’s Headlines: Welcome to the War on Cars, Scientific American

Our favorite story yesterday was this editorial in an unexpected place. Plus other news.

April 18, 2024

Meet the MTA Board Member and Congestion Pricing Foe Who Uses Bridges and Tunnels For Free Every Day

Mack drives over the transportation authority's bridges and tunnels thanks to a rare perk of which he is the primary beneficent.

April 18, 2024

Randy Mastro Aspires to Join Mayor’s Inner Circle of Congestion Pricing Foes

The mayor's reported pick to run the city Law Department is former deputy mayor under Rudy Giuliani and notorious foe of bike lanes and congestion pricing.

April 18, 2024

Donald Shoup: Here’s a Parking Policy That Works for the People

Free parking has a veneer of equality, but it is unfair. Here's a proposal from America's leading parking academic that could make it more equitable.

April 18, 2024

Brooklyn Civic Panel Can’t Agree How to Solve NYPD Sidewalk Parking

Move the illegal sidewalk parking or denounce it altogether?

April 17, 2024
See all posts