Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
2009 Transportation Bill

Compromise or Concession: Congress Faces Tough Transport Choices

Health care and transportation funding are very different items on Congress' to-do list, but the Washington Post's assessment of the former issue fits the latter as well: Lawmakers return today from a month-long recess to find a political landscape that has barely shifted from the impasse of late July.

Voinovich_to_bow_out_at_end_of_term.jpgSen. George Voinovich (R-OH). Photo: UPI

Jim Oberstar (D-MN), chairman of the House transportation committee, continues to press for action on a six-year infrastructure measure with a $450 billion price tag that has no matching source of revenue.

Meanwhile, the Obama administration is pushing for an 18-month extension of current law that would delay broader reform until 2011.

Oberstar counts many allies on his committee -- and even House leaders are sympathetic to his cause -- but a July letter urging Democrats to find a way to pay for his six-year bill "as soon as possible" was not signed by 10 members of the pivotal Ways and Means panel, which controls the bill's revenue source.

With a September 30 deadline for action on federal transport policy, the biggest question may be whether the Obama administration is willing to compromise with Oberstar and like-minded House members on a shorter-term stopgap.

Sen. George Voinovich (R-OH), one of a small group in the upper chamber that has not sided with the White House in favor of an 18-month delay, has not given up on his proposal for a 12-month extension of current law. In a newsletter for his constituents published over the Labor Day weekend, Voinovich wrote:

Across the country,Americans are still hurting. In our home state of Ohio, where unemploymentcurrently stands at 11.2 percent, people are asking, Where are the jobs?

Folks should knowthat some of their elected leaders are actively joining the Obama administration in its quest to blow yet another golden opportunity whenit comes to creating jobs and stimulating the economy: they are refusingto support a robust new highway bill. ...

[After aligning with Oberstar] I offered an amendment at an Environment and PublicWorks (EPW) Committee business meeting to shorten the length of theproposed extension to 12 months and keep the pressure on Congress toinvest in our nation's roads and bridges, meet America's surface transportationneeds, and create thousands of jobs. Those few months could make theworld of difference when it comes to job creation, yet the amendmentfailed by a vote of 8 to 11.

My proposal for a12-month extension is a reasonable compromise; the House is opposed toany type of extension. They understand the urgency of the situationwe face.

Oberstar and the White House held fast to their positions in July, which ended with lawmakers approving a $7 billion rescue for the nation's cash-strapped highway trust fund that did not include extra transit money secured by several senators.

Given that the capital's transportation stalemate remains largely the same in September, the next year or so of federal policymaking on the issue could depend on whether Oberstar and Voinovich assemble a workable coalition in favor of a shorter delay -- or whether the administration wins over enough House Democrats to its side.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Agenda 2026: Will Zohran Mamdani’s Left-Progressive Backers Mobilize for Faster Buses?

The new mayor must mobilize the coalition that got him elected if he wants to avoid his recent predecessors' failure to speed up buses.

December 1, 2025

‘Easy Win’: Uptowners Want To Keep Deteriorating Henry Hudson Parkway Off-Ramp Car-Free

The shuttered off-ramp off the Henry Hudson Parkway has become a draw for local residents.

December 1, 2025

Memo to Mamdani: When It Comes to Faster Buses, The Challenge Is Political

The solutions for faster bus service are obvious — it’s the politics that always get in the way, writes a former MTA bus official.

December 1, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Canal Street This Time Edition

More violent battles in public space. Plus other news.

December 1, 2025

Not So Fast! We Rode NYC Ferry with Would-Be Council Speaker Amanda Farías

Council Member Julie Menin claims she has the votes to be the next Speaker, but Bronx Council Member Amanda Farías has shown a lot more interest in livable streets issues.

November 28, 2025

Book Excerpt Special: Jonathan Lethem’s ‘Program’s Progress’

Class struggle. Infirm secondary superheroes. Suicidal sheep. It’s all in Jonathan Lethem's new collection of short stories, "A Different Kind of Tension." Here's one — featuring class struggle with cars!

November 28, 2025
See all posts