Time for Working Families Party to Step Up for Riders, Endorse Bridge Tolls

cantor.jpgWFP director Dan Cantor (center) at a "Halt the Hike" rally last week. Photo: Working Families Party.

Here’s another wake-up call for state legislators dithering over a transit funding package: The sinking economy continues to choke off revenues for New York City’s subways and buses. The MTA finance committee announced this afternoon that the agency’s budget gap is $621 million bigger than previously forecast. That’s on top of the $1.2 billion hole that brought about the imminent doomsday fare hike and service cuts. The culprit? Plummeting revenue from dedicated taxes, fares, and tolls.

If there was any doubt before, now it should be clear: The latest transit rescue package proposed by Malcolm Smith is too skimpy to get the job done. By refusing to ask car commuters to shoulder any of the burden, the plan Smith put forward would merely postpone the day of reckoning for straphangers.

Tomorrow the State Senate is expected to vote on that plan, or some variation on it. For months obstructionist senators have excused their own inaction by pointing fingers at the MTA for what they deem a lack of transparency. But now the Senate might pass a transit
funding package without holding any public hearings whatsoever. How opaque is that? The utter lack of transparency or discussion about this latest plan should be enough to preclude any votes from senators looking to burnish their good government cred.

The new budget numbers also set the stage for tomorrow’s big rally in Union Square, where the Working Families Party and transportation advocates will gather to protest the doomsday fare hike and service cuts. The Senate’s proposal is a band-aid that won’t deliver what this coalition demands: a long-term, sustainable revenue stream that will protect straphangers from paying more for a deteriorating transit system. A real remedy, like the Ravitch plan, needs a united front behind it in order to regain momentum. This rally must be a galvanizing moment, and the person best positioned to deliver is Dan Cantor, head of the labor-backed Working Families Party.

Here’s a chance for the Working Families Party to make a strong push for a robust transit plan. A plan that will put the city’s subway and bus systems on sound footing. A plan that will spare working New Yorkers from worse fare hikes and deteriorating service.

Car commuters are one constituency asked to sacrifice next to nothing in the Senate’s latest proposal, even though the average income of the city’s car owners more than doubles that of the transit-riding, car-free majority. The official position of the Working Families Party is that the MTA funding plan should be "based on the Ravitch principles." Coming out with a more forceful position at tomorrow’s rally — like a full-fledged endorsement of the Ravitch plan itself, including bridge tolls — could change the terms of the debate.

  • Larry Littlefield

    After all the fun everybody had sucking money out of the future, you didn’t expect they’d be lining up to prevent the resulting institutional collapse, did you? Nope, everyone just wants to delay that collapse a little while longer, and make someone else the patsy. Or is refusing to even cooperate with that.

    Conservative think tankers blame retiree benefits:


    The TWU believes that “waste, fraud and abuse” is the only reason it won’t get a 1.5% cost of living adjustment (in a year when the cost of living is falling and many people’s wages are too). They want to audit the MTA’s books and find the hidden billions.


    Drivers don’t want to pay. Riders don’t want to pay. No one dares to suggest the retired should pay anything. It’s a fiscal tragedy of the commons, and has been for 15 years.

    I’m not sure who aggravates me more: the evildoers who are steering what is left of the ship into the rocks by refusing to cooperate (ie. the fare hike four), or the evildoers who want to suddenly seem like they are on the side of the angels.

    The clear winners are those who cashed in and moved out; the clear losers anyone who plans to live in this city in what was the far off future but is increasingly the near future. The most painless way out is unacceptable to all concerned, as it would likely involve something like “doomsday” plus the Ravitch plan or equivalent plus cost cuts. The most likely way out is 20 years of sacrifice and rebuilding following an institutional collapse.

  • Ms. Gelinas is right: union concessions and social spending cuts are crucial. Unfortunately, our current leaders are, shall we say, unlikely to pursue such a course of action.

  • mfs

    As someone who has defended the WFP here multiple times, I strongly agree with this sentiment. It is time to ask for shared sacrifice, including from Manhattan-bound drivers. Raising bridge tolls at other MTA crossings is only going to drive more cars to the free bridges.

  • Moser

    Ever see any union leaders of any kind, including TWU, show up to something on the bus or train? Labor leaders who want to drive around without paying are probably WFP’s main problem here.


Today’s Headlines

Texas Spending $181M in Stimulus Cash on 15-Mile Highway Outside Houston (NYT) Most Transit Riders Support Bridge Tolls, But This Story Is All About the Ones Who Don’t (NYT) Nation’s Transit Systems Still in Crisis (WSJ) MTA Finance Board Votes Today on Doomsday Fare Hikes (Newsday) Paterson Expects State Leg to Blow Deadline on MTA […]

Where Does the Working Families Party Stand on MTA Rescue?

Millions of New York City bus riders are counting on an MTA rescue plan to maintain service and hold fares down. Last week, some of the biggest unions in New York came out in favor of the Ravitch Commission’s MTA rescue plan, including the bridge tolls that a handful of state senators refuse to support. […]

The Fare Hike, the Service Cuts, and the Ballot Box

This afternoon the MTA officially unveiled the fare and toll increases it’s proposing to help close the agency’s remaining $400 million budget gap. The dailies had already reported many of the measures on the table, and it looks like the burden is going to fall mainly on New Yorkers who use subways and buses the […]